- Advanced
- About 16 min
- 5 practice questions
The constitutional frame: Article 3, the Seventh Schedule and the limits on the Governor
Use the Constitution's rules on forming and renaming states, the three lists and the Governor's powers to solve statement and reasoning questions.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Advanced questions on Odisha's government seldom ask for a bare fact. They ask you to reason from the Constitution: can the state do this, or only Parliament? Can the Governor act alone? This lesson builds the reasoning tools, using Odisha's own history as the case.
Who can change a state: Articles 3 and 4
Under Article 3, Parliament may by law form a new state, change the area, boundaries or name of any state. A bill for this can be introduced only on the recommendation of the President, and the President must refer it to the legislature of the state concerned to express its views within a stated time. Those views are not binding on Parliament. Article 4 adds that such a law is not an amendment of the Constitution under Article 368, so it needs only a simple majority.
This is how the change of name from Orissa to Odisha in 2011 was made: by Parliament, not by the state government acting alone. Because the Eighth Schedule of the Constitution listed the language as Oriya, the language's new name Odia was entered by a separate constitutional amendment, the 96th, also of 2011. The state of 1936 had been created differently: the province of Orissa was created by the British Parliament's Government of India Act, 1935, and orders made under it, since the Indian Constitution did not yet exist.
| Question | Who decides | Authority |
|---|---|---|
| Rename the state | Parliament, simple majority | Articles 3 and 4 |
| Change a language's name in the Eighth Schedule | Parliament, constitutional amendment | Article 368 |
| Change the capital city within the state | State government | Not a matter for Parliament |
| Create a new district | State government | State administration, not Article 3 |
The three lists and the state
The Seventh Schedule distributes law-making. Police, public order and local government are State List subjects; defence and foreign affairs are Union List subjects. On the Concurrent List both can legislate, but if they conflict, the Union law prevails (Article 254). A question that asks whether the Odisha Vidhan Sabha can legislate on defence has a short answer: no.
The Governor's powers and their limits
Governor: acts on advice or on own judgement
-
On ministers' advice
Normal course
- Summoning and proroguing the House
- Giving assent in most cases
- Appointing ministers on the Chief Minister's advice
-
Own judgement
Few matters
- Choosing a Chief Minister when no party has a majority
- Reporting that the constitutional machinery has failed
- Reserving a bill for the President in some cases
If the Governor reports that the government of the state cannot be carried on according to the Constitution, the President may impose President's Rule under Article 356. The Governor's report is not the only way the President may act, but it is the usual one. Parliament must approve the proclamation within two months. While it lasts, the Vidhan Sabha may be suspended or dissolved and the President takes over the work of the executive; the High Court's powers stay.
Worked example 1: statement analysis
Statements: (1) the name of Odisha was changed by an Act of Parliament under Article 3; (2) the Odisha Vidhan Sabha's consent is binding on Parliament in such a change. Working: statement 1 is right. Under Article 3 the views of the state legislature are only to be heard; they do not bind Parliament. So statement 2 is wrong. The answer is 1 only.
Worked example 2: assertion and reason
A: the Odisha Vidhan Sabha cannot pass a law on defence of India. R: defence is on the Union List. Working: both are true and the reason is exactly why the assertion is true. The answer is both true, R explains A.
Worked example 3: a calculation of years
Question: how many years passed between the formation of the province of Orissa (1936) and the change of name (2011)? Working: 2011 - 1936 = 75 years.
Article 3: Parliament forms and renames states; the state's views are heard but do not bind. Article 4: not an Article 368 amendment. Article 356: President's Rule.
Key takeaways: Parliament, not the state, renames a state, by simple majority under Articles 3 and 4. A language's name in the Eighth Schedule needs a constitutional amendment. The Governor generally acts on advice, with a few exceptions. President's Rule under Article 356 needs Parliament's approval within two months.
Check your understanding
-
1. Statements: 1. A state can be renamed by a law of Parliament. 2. Such a law needs the special majority of an Article 368 amendment. Which is correct?
- 1 only
- 2 only
- Both 1 and 2
- Neither 1 nor 2
Show answer
Answer: A. Article 3 allows Parliament to rename a state, and Article 4 says such a law is not an Article 368 amendment, so a simple majority is enough. Statement 2 is wrong.
-
2. Under Article 3, the views of the legislature of the state concerned are:
- Binding on Parliament
- Not obtained at all
- Obtained but not binding on Parliament
- Decided by the High Court
Show answer
Answer: C. The President refers the bill for views, which Parliament need not accept.
-
3. A: The Odisha Vidhan Sabha cannot rename the state. R: Article 3 gives that power to Parliament. Choose:
- Both are true but R does not explain A
- A is true but R is false
- Both A and R are true and R explains A
- A is false but R is true
Show answer
Answer: C. Renaming is a power of Parliament under Article 3, which explains why the Vidhan Sabha cannot do it.
-
4. Parliament must approve a proclamation of President's Rule within:
- Two months
- Two weeks
- Six months
- One year
Show answer
Answer: A. Article 356(3) requires approval within two months.
-
5. If a Union law and a state law on a Concurrent List subject conflict, generally:
- The state law prevails always
- Both are void
- The High Court chooses
- The Union law prevails
Show answer
Answer: D. Article 254 gives priority to the Union law, with a limited exception where the President has assented to the state law.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.