- Practice
- About 16 min
- 5 practice questions
Pipes, strings and temperature: a mixed problem set
Compare open and closed pipes of equal length, test which forks resonate, and find the effect of temperature on pitch and beats.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Examination questions often mix pipes, strings and the temperature of the air. Most can be done with three formulas: the closed pipe f = (2n − 1)v ÷ 4L, the open pipe f = nv ÷ 2L, and the string f = (1 ÷ 2L)√(T ÷ μ). The extra step is to decide what changes. Take v = 340 m/s at 20 °C, and use the rule that v rises by 0.6 m/s per 1 °C.
Comparisons worth knowing
- For the same length L, the open pipe's fundamental is twice that of the closed pipe: v ÷ 2L against v ÷ 4L.
- A closed pipe of length L has the same fundamental as an open pipe of length 2L.
- A closed pipe gives only the odd multiples of its fundamental. An open pipe gives all whole-number multiples.
- The pitch of a pipe rises when the air warms, since f is proportional to v. The frequency of a string depends on tension, not on the air.
Worked examples
Example 1: equal lengths. A pipe is 0.85 m long. As an open pipe, f₁ = 340 ÷ (2 × 0.85) = 200 Hz. As a closed pipe, f₁ = 340 ÷ (4 × 0.85) = 100 Hz. The open pipe sounds an octave higher.
Example 2: which forks resonate? A closed pipe has f₁ = 100 Hz, so it resonates at 100, 300, 500, 700 Hz and so on. A 500 Hz fork resonates (the fifth multiple). A 600 Hz fork does not, because 600 is an even multiple. A 700 Hz fork does resonate. An open pipe of f₁ = 100 Hz would resonate with all three.
Example 3: matching lengths. An open pipe of 1.0 m has f₁ = 340 ÷ 2 = 170 Hz. A closed pipe has the same fundamental if its length is 340 ÷ (4 × 170) = 0.5 m, half the length.
Example 4: temperature and beats. Two identical closed pipes of length 0.5 m are at 20 °C and 30 °C. At 20 °C, v = 340 m/s and f₁ = 340 ÷ (4 × 0.5) = 170 Hz. At 30 °C, v = 340 + 0.6 × 10 = 346 m/s and f₁ = 346 ÷ 2 = 173 Hz. The pipes sounded together give 173 − 170 = 3 beats per second.
Example 5: pipe and string. A string of length 0.5 m, tension 100 N and mass per unit length 0.01 kg/m has v = √(100 ÷ 0.01) = 100 m/s and f₁ = 100 ÷ (2 × 0.5) = 100 Hz. A closed pipe of 0.85 m also has f₁ = 340 ÷ (4 × 0.85) = 100 Hz, so they are in unison. If the tension of the string is raised to 104 N, v = √(104 ÷ 0.01) = 101.98 m/s and f₁ = 101.98 ÷ 1 = 101.98 Hz, and the two sounded together give about 2 beats per second.
Same length: open pipe is double the frequency of a closed pipe. Closed pipe: odd multiples only. Warm air raises the pitch of a pipe.
Traps
- Using the open-pipe formula for a pipe that has a closed end.
- Forgetting that even multiples of a closed pipe's fundamental are missing.
- Thinking a warmer room raises the frequency of a string; it is the air column that changes.
Key takeaways
- Compare pipes of equal length by the ratio 2 : 1.
- Odd multiples only for a closed pipe.
- Pitch of a pipe tracks the speed of sound in the air column.
Check your understanding
-
1. A closed pipe has a fundamental frequency of 80 Hz. Which of these frequencies will also resonate in it?
- 160 Hz
- 240 Hz
- 320 Hz
- 480 Hz
Show answer
Answer: B. A closed pipe resonates only at odd multiples of its fundamental: 80, 240, 400 Hz and so on. Of the options only 240 Hz is such a multiple.
-
2. An open pipe and a closed pipe have the same length. The ratio of their fundamental frequencies (open : closed) is:
- 1 : 2
- 2 : 1
- 1 : 1
- 4 : 1
Show answer
Answer: B. Open: v ÷ 2L. Closed: v ÷ 4L. The ratio is 2 : 1.
-
3. An open pipe of length 0.4 m has the same fundamental as a closed pipe of length:
- 0.8 m
- 0.4 m
- 0.2 m
- 0.1 m
Show answer
Answer: C. Closed pipe length = half the open length = 0.2 m.
-
4. The air in a closed pipe warms so that the speed of sound rises from 340 m/s to 346 m/s. A fundamental of 170 Hz becomes:
- 166 Hz
- 176 Hz
- 170 Hz
- 173 Hz
Show answer
Answer: D. Frequency is proportional to speed: 170 × 346 ÷ 340 = 173 Hz.
-
5. Which statement about a closed pipe is correct?
- It gives all whole-number multiples of its fundamental
- Its fundamental is twice that of an open pipe of the same length
- Both its ends are antinodes
- It gives only odd multiples of its fundamental
Show answer
Answer: D. A closed pipe has a node at its closed end and an antinode at its open end, and so supports only odd multiples of its fundamental.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.