- Practice
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
Bed Number 29: the third operation and the truth about Naeem
Retell the ending of Tariq Rahman's story in your own words, explain the twist that Naeem was blind and was himself the buyer, and read the clues the writer hid along the way.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Retell the ending of the story in your own words.
- Explain where Naeem was when the narrator could see again, and why.
- Explain the twist in the ending and the clues that point to it.
- Answer the 'how' and 'why' questions on the ending with reasons.
A good twist ending surprises you the first time and seems obvious the second time. Bed Number 29 works this way. In this lesson we follow the last part of the story and then go back to find the clues.
Part 9: light at last
After the third operation the narrator is told not to move or talk to anyone. When the day comes to remove the bandage, he asks for Naeem, but the nurse says Naeem is ill and cannot come. The doctor unwinds the bandage, the narrator opens his eyes, and a flash of light tears through them. He can see.
Part 10: the empty bed and the letter
Wheeled back to his room, he calls out for Naeem again and again. The nurse turns pale and hands him a letter from Naeem. Its message, in our words, is that art had blessed him for a short while and then left him. Wild with grief, the narrator rushes to the cupboard. There lie all his paintings, the ones he believed had been sold. Now that he can see them, they are only masses of haphazard lines without colour.
Part 11: the truth
The nurse explains. Naeem was a great man. He spent all his own money buying the narrator's paintings, and when he could no longer afford to stay, he moved out of the hospital. He could not have his own third operation. The narrator asks what operation she means. On his eyes, of course, she replies: Naeem was blind. The narrator is stunned and weeps. Under Naeem's pillow he finds four paintings of the four seasons that Naeem himself had painted before he lost his sight. The seasons Naeem had described so lovingly were his own paintings, remembered, which he had tried to recreate through the narrator's hand.
What Naeem secretly did
-
Hid his own blindness
- Described scenes from memory
- Spoke as if he saw the window view
-
Praised the paintings
- They were really colourless, haphazard lines
- Praise rebuilt the narrator's confidence
-
Was the 'buyer'
- Paid with all his own money
- Let the narrator keep his pride
-
Gave up his own cure
- Could not afford his third operation
- Left the hospital without a word
The clues the writer planted
- We know almost nothing about Naeem. The narrator never asks; he is too wrapped up in his own sorrow.
- The silence after the haystack. When asked why he did not paint the scene, Naeem goes quiet. He could no longer see to paint.
- Naeem is in the same hospital and has operations ahead. The ward is clearly one for eye patients.
- The attendants are surprised when they see the painting materials, and Naeem quickly hushes them.
- The pause before the praise. Naeem says nothing for a while after the first painting, then praises it lavishly.
- The convenient 'rich friend' who buys every painting, never meets the painter and appears just when money runs out.
- Naeem is 'ill' on the very day the bandage comes off.
Worked example 1: where was Naeem?
Question: Where was Naeem when the narrator regained his sight? Working: the nurse first says he is ill, which is a kind cover story; later she explains the truth. Answer: he had already left the hospital, because he had spent all his money buying the narrator's paintings and could no longer afford to stay or pay for his own operation.
Worked example 2: how could Naeem describe the seasons so well?
Question: How could a blind man describe the four seasons in such detail? Working: link the descriptions to what is found under his pillow. Answer: Naeem had been a painter himself before he went blind, and had painted the four seasons. He described those paintings from memory, which is why his descriptions were so rich in colour.
A twist ending changes the meaning of everything before it. Reread the early scenes and ask: what did this really mean?
Key takeaways: the third operation succeeds, but Naeem has gone. His letter and the nurse reveal that he was blind, that he bought the colourless paintings with all his money, and that he gave up his own treatment. The four seasons he described were his own lost paintings.
Check your understanding
-
1. What did the nurse first say when the narrator asked for Naeem before the bandage was removed?
- That he was busy painting
- That he was ill and could not come
- That he had gone home for a holiday
- That he was having his own operation
Show answer
Answer: B. She said Naeem was ill. The truth, which she told later, was that he had left the hospital.
-
2. What did the narrator find in the cupboard?
- Naeem's four paintings of the seasons
- A bag of money from the buyer
- All his own paintings, which were only haphazard lines without colour
- Nothing at all
Show answer
Answer: C. The paintings he thought had been sold were all there. Seen with his own eyes, they were masses of haphazard lines. Naeem's four paintings were under Naeem's pillow, not in the cupboard.
-
3. Why could Naeem not have his treatment?
- He had spent all his money buying the narrator's paintings
- The doctors said his eyes could not be cured
- He was afraid of operations
- He did not want to leave his friend
Show answer
Answer: A. The nurse explains that Naeem used all his money to buy the paintings and then moved out because he could not afford to stay. So he could not have his own third operation.
-
4. Which of these is NOT a clue that Naeem was blind?
- He fell silent when asked why he had not painted the golden haystack
- He paused for a while before praising the first painting
- The attendants were surprised to see the painting materials
- He offered the narrator money
Show answer
Answer: D. Offering money shows generosity, not blindness. The other three hint that he could not see or paint, and could not judge the painting by sight.
-
5. What were the four paintings under Naeem's pillow?
- Paintings of the four seasons that Naeem had made before he went blind
- Four paintings the narrator had sold
- Gifts from the rich art lover
- Pictures the nurse had drawn
Show answer
Answer: A. They were Naeem's own paintings of the seasons from before his blindness. He had described them to the narrator and tried to paint them again through him.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.