• Practice
  • About 17 min
  • 5 practice questions

Stanzas 8-20 explained: Pertab's choice, the priests and the caste of noble hearts

Understand the second half of the ballad: the request for a bearer, Pertab's decision to carry his friend himself, the funeral procession, the priests' warning that he has lost his caste, and his reply.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Explain the second half of the ballad in your own words.
  • Explain why Pertab was asked to send for another bearer and why he refused.
  • Explain what the priests said he had lost, and why.
  • Explain Pertab's final reply about a higher caste.

This is the dramatic heart of the ballad, told mostly through dialogue. Notice how calm and sure Pertab is at every step, and how his anger flashes only once, at the very end.

The request and the choice (stanzas 8-11)

The three Englishmen ask the Maharaj to send them a man from the sweepers' community, because, as the custom of the time held, such a man 'has no caste to lose' even by carrying a foreigner's bier (a frame for carrying the dead). This request reflects the old caste system, which unjustly placed some communities at the very bottom and treated them as outside caste. The poem presents this belief so that it can be rejected.

Pertab bows his head and says there is no need: he himself has no caste, for he is carrying the dead. The Englishmen warn him, calling him a passionate heart: think carefully, for what you lose today is lost for ever, till the last sun sets. Pertab answers that only God knows what he loses today, and that no other hand but his shall carry his friend.

The funeral (stanza 12)

Slowly, with dignity, raised on four pairs of shoulders, the coffin goes down the rose-red steps in full view of all Jodhpore. The fourth bearer is the prince himself. The alliteration of 's' sounds in this stanza (stately, slow, shoulder-high, sight, steps) gives a solemn, measured beat, like slow footsteps.

The priests (stanzas 13-17)

At dawn, which the poet says relit the lamp of grief, a soft-spoken priest sends word to Pertab. He rises and goes out dressed all in white, the colour of mourning, and finds the Brahmins bowing in the hard morning light. They lament that a fearful thing happened in Jodhpore yesterday. Pertab agrees: God and his own heart know it well; he lost a friend. The priests say something more fearful happened: when he went down those steps in front of all Jodhpore, he lost his caste.

Pertab's reply (stanzas 18-20)

Now light leaps in Pertab's eyes, like a flame leaping out of smoke. He tells the priest that his soul has never understood the word his lips are speaking. There is a caste above his own and the priest's; next to that undying line, Brahmin and Rajput are only dust. That caste is as wide as the world, as free as the air and as pure as death itself: it is the faith of the true soldier, shared by all the noble hearts of the earth. The textbook glossary explains this immortal line as a noble, deathless race of people who live on through their deeds.

Two ideas of caste in the ballad

  • The priests' view
    • caste comes from birth
    • it is lost by touching a foreigner's bier
    • losing it is more fearful than losing a friend
  • Pertab's view
    • true nobility comes from the heart and deeds
    • it cannot be lost by an act of loyalty
    • the noble of all races form one caste

Worked example 1: what had Pertab lost, according to the priests?

Question (textbook type): What, according to the priests, had Pertab Singh lost, and why? Working: find their words in stanzas 16-17 and the action they refer to (going down the steps carrying the coffin). Answer: they said he had lost his caste, because he had carried the coffin of a foreigner of another faith in full view of the city, which went against the caste rules of the time.

Worked example 2: why was he asked to send a sweeper?

Question (textbook type): Why was Pertab Singh asked to send a sweeper when the English soldier died? Working: connect stanza 7 (only three bearers) with the caste belief in stanza 8. Answer (our own): the Englishmen needed a fourth bearer, and by the custom of the time a high-caste man was thought to lose caste by touching a foreigner's bier, while the sweeper community, unjustly treated as outside the caste order, was thought to have no caste to lose. So they asked for one of them. Pertab rejected this way of thinking by carrying the coffin himself.

Pertab chose a friend over a rule of birth, and said the noble hearts of every land share one caste.

Key takeaways: Pertab refuses to let anyone else carry his friend and becomes the fourth bearer; the priests say he has lost his caste; he replies that above all castes stands the brotherhood of noble hearts, the true soldier's faith.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. What did Pertab do when asked to send someone to be the fourth bearer?

    1. He sent a servant.
    2. He sent for the priests.
    3. He carried his friend's coffin himself.
    4. He refused to attend the funeral.
    Show answer

    Answer: C. He said there was no need, because he himself would bear the dead. He became the fourth bearer.

  2. 2. Why did the Englishmen warn Pertab to think carefully?

    1. They feared what he lost that day would be lost for ever.
    2. They thought the coffin was too heavy for him.
    3. They did not like him.
    4. They wanted the funeral delayed.
    Show answer

    Answer: A. They told him that what he lost today would stay lost till the last sun set, meaning his caste could never be regained.

  3. 3. Why did Pertab go out 'all in white' in the morning?

    1. It was a festival day.
    2. White was his army uniform.
    3. He was going to a wedding.
    4. He was in mourning for his friend.
    Show answer

    Answer: D. White is worn in mourning in Indian tradition. He had lost his friend the day before.

  4. 4. What did Pertab call 'a fearful thing' that happened yesterday?

    1. Losing his caste
    2. Losing a friend
    3. Losing a battle
    4. Losing his house
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The priests meant the loss of caste, but Pertab said the fearful thing was the loss of his friend. The two sides value different things.

  5. 5. According to Pertab, what is the caste of all Earth's noble hearts?

    1. The Rajput caste
    2. The Brahmin caste
    3. The true soldier's faith
    4. The English race
    Show answer

    Answer: C. He says there is a caste above his and the priest's, before which Brahmin and Rajput are dust: the right soldier's faith, shared by all noble hearts.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery