- Practice
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Worth, not looks: Ashtavakra, Lord Rama, Swami Vivekananda and the honour of women (parts III and IV)
Retell parts III and IV of the essay: Ashtavakra in King Janaka's court, Lord Rama and the Bheel woman, Swami Vivekananda's reply about dress, Chhatrapati Shivaji and the place of women, and learn the new words.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Retell the Ashtavakra episode and explain his reply.
- Explain how the examples of Lord Rama and Swami Vivekananda support the author's point.
- Describe how the essay presents the place of women in ancient India and the question it asks today.
- Use the words ticklish, derisive, intrinsic, tacitly and frivolous correctly.
The second half of the essay moves from sacrifice and sharing to two other values: judging a person by inner worth rather than appearance, caste or profession, and honouring women. As before, each part gives examples and ends with a question for the reader.
Part III: Ashtavakra in King Janaka's court
King Janaka of Mithila (in present-day Bihar, as the book notes) called a meeting of scholars to discuss a difficult philosophical question. Among those invited was the sage Ashtavakra, whose name comes from his body being bent in eight places. As he walked into the hall, some scholars laughed at him mockingly: how could someone who looked like that discuss deep philosophy? Ashtavakra replied boldly to the king that he was ashamed to be in an assembly of skin-dealers, because only a dealer in hides judges a person by the skin and the outward shape of the body. The scholars were put to shame and begged his pardon.
The author's point: the colour of the skin or the shape of the body has never been a measure of a person's intelligence or status. Ashtavakra's reply works like a mirror - the scholars who mocked his body showed that they themselves could see only bodies.
Lord Rama, the Bheel woman and Swami Vivekananda
The author adds the episode, from the Ramayana tradition, of Lord Rama gladly eating berries that a poor Bheel woman had tasted first to make sure they were sweet. The author argues that this shows a person's caste, creed or work was not a reason to look down on them. He then recalls a reply attributed to Swami Vivekananda: when a lady in America laughed at his simple dress, he answered, in substance, that in her country the tailor makes a person, but in his country a person is made great by inner worth and character. The part ends by asking whether it is wise to support, even silently, any discrimination on such silly grounds today.
Part IV: the honour of women
Part IV says that in the land's history no auspicious ceremony was thought complete without a woman taking part. The book gives the example (in a footnote) that at the Setubandh puja a statue of Sita was specially made so that her presence could be marked. For the author, this shows that a woman was honoured as a goddess, as a kanjak (a young girl worshipped in ceremonies), as the mother of mankind and as the ardhangini - the equal half, like the second wheel of the chariot of life.
He gives the example of Chhatrapati Shivaji, who, when some soldiers of his victorious army brought him a woman as a 'gift', bowed his head before her and returned her with respect, treating her as a mother. He adds that the great wars of the Ramayana and the Mahabharata were fought to defend the honour of women. The essay ends with its strongest question: should this not shame those who think of female foeticide or who deny women their rightful place in the world?
Two values in parts III and IV
-
Inner worth over looks
- Ashtavakra shames the scholars who laughed
- Lord Rama accepts the Bheel woman's berries
- Vivekananda: character, not clothes, makes a person
-
Honour for women
- No auspicious rite without a woman
- Shivaji returns the woman with respect
- The epics' wars defended women's honour
New words from parts III and IV
| Word | Meaning | Our own example |
|---|---|---|
| ticklish | difficult and needing care (also: causing a tickle) | Sharing one laptop among four cousins was a ticklish problem. |
| derisive | mocking; showing that something is thought ridiculous | The new player ignored the derisive shouts and scored. |
| intrinsic | belonging to the real nature of something | Honesty is an intrinsic part of good character. |
| tacitly | in a way that is understood without being said | By staying silent, the class tacitly agreed to the plan. |
| frivolous | silly; not serious | Don't waste the meeting on frivolous complaints. |
| auspicious | promising good fortune; suitable for a holy event | The family chose an auspicious day for the house-warming. |
Worked example 1: why did the scholars laugh?
Question: Why did some scholars laugh at Ashtavakra, and how did he react? Working: find the cause - his bent, misshapen body made them think he could not discuss philosophy. Find the reaction - he did not plead; he turned their own judgement against them by calling them dealers in skin. Answer: they mocked him for his looks; he replied that only a skin-dealer judges people by their skin, which shamed them into asking his pardon.
Worked example 2: why did Shivaji bow his head?
Question: Why did Shivaji bow before the woman brought to him as a gift? Working: notice what the soldiers did wrong - they treated a woman as a prize. Notice Shivaji's view - he saw her as a mother deserving respect. Answer: he honoured her as a mother and restored her dignity, showing that a woman must never be treated as an object.
The essay's two questions for today: Do we still judge people by looks or birth? Do we still deny women their rightful place?
Key takeaways: Part III argues, through Ashtavakra, Lord Rama and Swami Vivekananda, that worth lies in character, not in skin, dress, caste or profession. Part IV argues that women were honoured as equal partners and mothers, and asks those who harm or sideline girls and women today to feel ashamed.
Check your understanding
-
1. Why did some scholars in King Janaka's court laugh at Ashtavakra?
- He arrived late
- He was very young
- His body was bent and misshapen
- He spoke a foreign language
Show answer
Answer: C. They doubted that a man with such a deformed body could discuss high philosophy - they judged him by his looks.
-
2. Why did Ashtavakra call the assembly one of 'skin-dealers'?
- Because only a dealer in skins judges a person by the skin and body
- Because the scholars sold leather goods
- Because the palace was decorated with skins
- Because the king wore animal skins
Show answer
Answer: A. His point was that judging intelligence by outward appearance is what a hide-dealer does. The insult shamed them for doing exactly that.
-
3. What did Swami Vivekananda's reply to the American lady mean?
- Good clothes are the most important thing
- Tailors in India are poor
- He would buy new clothes soon
- A person's greatness comes from inner worth and character, not dress
Show answer
Answer: D. He contrasted 'the tailor makes a person' with greatness coming from character and intrinsic worth.
-
4. What, according to the essay, does Shivaji's behaviour towards the woman show?
- That he wanted to punish his whole army
- That a woman deserved the respect due to a mother
- That he did not like gifts
- That he was afraid of her family
Show answer
Answer: B. He bowed his head and restored her dignity as a mother - the author uses it to show the honour given to women.
-
5. Choose the sentence that uses 'derisive' correctly.
- The derisive medicine cured her cold.
- He derisive the letter to his aunt.
- The crowd's derisive laughter hurt the shy singer.
- We walked derisive along the river.
Show answer
Answer: C. 'Derisive' is an adjective meaning mocking. It correctly describes the crowd's laughter; the other sentences misuse it as a verb or adverb or give it the wrong meaning.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.