- Practice
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
Answering questions and discussing Return to Air
Write clear answers in your own words to the kinds of comprehension questions the PSEB textbook asks on Return to Air, and prepare the book's discussion topics on swimming as exercise and school amenities.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Answer factual and 'why' questions on the story with supporting details.
- Answer 'did he know' questions by explaining what the character could and could not see.
- Speak and write on the discussion topics: swimming as exercise, and the facilities a school should have.
The PSEB textbook asks eleven comprehension questions on this story and gives two topics for discussion. This lesson shows how to answer similar questions in your own words and how to prepare the discussions.
Model answers
Frequently asked questions
Why couldn't Sausage see well inside the water?
He had taken off his glasses before going into the pond, and he cannot see much without them. Also, as he says, nobody can see much under water, especially in murky pond water that grows dark as you go deeper and is clouded by mud.
What happened when Sausage tried duck-diving for the first time?
He dived to the bottom, dug something out of the mud and rose through a cloud of mud, terrified that he would not reach the air. He burst out near the far end of the pond and found that he had brought up an old tin box instead of the brick.
Did Sausage know what he had caught hold of? Why?
No. He thought it was the brick. Without his glasses and in the dark, muddy water, he could not see clearly, and the tin was the same size as the brick and just as heavy because it was full of mud. He found out only when he put his glasses on at the bank.
Where did Sausage come up?
He came up almost at the other end of the pond, which shows how far he had swum under water without realising it.
How is duck-diving taught?
The instructor throws a brick wrapped in white flannel into deep water, and the learner dives to bring it up before it sinks into the mud. This prepares swimmers to rescue someone who has sunk to the bottom.
Worked example: improving an answer
Question: Why did the water change colours? Weak answer: 'Because he went down.' Better answer: the water changed colour because of depth and light. Near the surface, sunlight made it look bright like lemonade; deeper down less light reached, so it became green-brown and then blackish-brown; the mud he stirred up made it darker still. Coming up, the colours changed back in reverse order as the light grew stronger. The better answer gives the cause and the order of change.
Discussion 1: swimming is a good exercise
Points for the discussion
-
Body
- Works the arms, legs and back together
- Strengthens the heart and lungs
- Gentle on the joints because water supports the body
-
Mind
- Relaxing and refreshing
- Builds confidence, as it did for Sausage
-
Safety
- A life skill that can save lives
- Learn only under a trained instructor or lifeguard
- Never swim alone in rivers, canals or ponds
Discussion 2: why not every school has a swimming pool
Reasons you can give: a pool needs a lot of space, money to build, a regular supply of clean water, cleaning and maintenance, and trained staff and lifeguards for safety. Many schools must spend first on more basic needs. Then discuss the facilities every school should have, for example: clean drinking water, separate clean toilets for girls and boys, a playground, a library, a science laboratory, a computer room, first-aid arrangements, ramps for students with disabilities, and well-lit, airy classrooms.
Worked example: a short speech opening
Good morning, everyone. Today I want to argue that swimming is one of the best exercises we can do. It uses almost every muscle in the body, it strengthens the heart and lungs, and it is a skill that can one day save a life. But, as the boy in Return to Air learnt, it must be learnt with an instructor watching, step by step. (Then give two more points and a conclusion.)
For a 'did he know' question, say yes or no, then explain what the character could or could not see or know.
Key takeaways: Answer directly, then support with details and causes. For discussions, organise your points under clear headings, such as body, mind and safety, and always include the safety rule about learning to swim under supervision.
Check your understanding
-
1. Why did Sausage not know he had picked up a tin instead of the brick?
- The instructor had swapped them.
- He was not wearing his glasses, the water was dark and muddy, and the tin was as heavy and as big as the brick.
- He was asleep under water.
- He never looked at it afterwards.
Show answer
Answer: B. Several reasons together: no glasses, poor light in muddy water, and the tin's similar size and weight. He found out only on the bank.
-
2. Where did Sausage come up after his dive?
- At exactly the same spot
- Under the diving board
- Almost at the other end of the pond
- Next to the fishermen's stools
Show answer
Answer: C. He realised he had come up almost at the other end of the pond, so he had swum a long way under water.
-
3. Which is the best explanation of why the water changed colours?
- Because he went down
- Because the fish changed colour
- Because the instructor added dye
- Because less sunlight reaches deeper water, and stirred-up mud darkened it further
Show answer
Answer: D. The colour depended on light and depth: bright near the surface, darker deeper down, and darker still in the mud cloud.
-
4. Which point is a good reason why not every school can have a swimming pool?
- A pool needs space, money, clean water, maintenance and trained lifeguards.
- Students do not like water.
- Swimming is bad for health.
- Pools are not allowed anywhere.
Show answer
Answer: A. Building and running a pool safely needs space, funds, water, upkeep and trained staff, which many schools cannot afford.
-
5. Which safety rule should every talk on swimming include?
- Always swim alone to concentrate.
- Learn only under a trained instructor or lifeguard.
- Dive into any pond to test its depth.
- Swim right after a heavy meal.
Show answer
Answer: B. Swimming should be learnt under supervision, as Sausage did with his instructor. The other choices are unsafe.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.