- Practice
- About 16 min
- 5 practice questions
The Making of the Earth, part 2: Nehru's account of the earth, the moon and the oceans - and today's science
Retell Nehru's account of how the earth and moon broke away and cooled and how the oceans formed, explain his 'rope' for gravity, and compare it with how scientists explain the making of the earth and the moon today.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Retell, in order, Nehru's account of the making of the earth, the moon and the oceans.
- Explain his comparison of gravity to a rope.
- State how today's science explains the formation of the earth and the moon.
- Use the words hollow, condense, tremendous and interior.
In the second half of the letter Nehru tells how, according to what astronomers told people in his time, the earth was made. Remember that he wrote this in 1928. Your exam answers should report his account, as the lesson asks; but you should also know that science has moved on, and this lesson shows how.
Nehru's account, step by step
Long ago, Nehru writes, the earth and all the planets were part of the sun, a mass of flaming, terribly hot matter. Somehow small pieces broke loose and shot out into space. But they could not escape their 'father' completely; it was as if a rope tied them to the sun, so they kept whirling round it. This 'rope' is the force that attracts small things to big things - the same force that makes things fall by their weight. (Today we call it gravity.)
The earth was one of these pieces. At first it was very hot, wrapped in hot gases, and nothing could live on it. Being much smaller than the sun, it began to cool, while the sun cools far more slowly. In the same way, Nehru says, a piece of the earth shot out and became the moon; many people then believed it came from the great hollow now filled by the Pacific Ocean. The earth's surface cooled slowly, but its interior stayed hot - which is why mines get hotter the deeper you go. The moon, smaller still, cooled faster; Nehru playfully wonders whether the 'cold moon' is full of glaciers and ice. When the earth cooled, the water vapour in the air condensed and fell as tremendous rain, filling the great hollows and forming the oceans and seas. Once the land and seas had cooled, living things could begin to exist.
Nehru's account (1928) in six steps
- Part of the sun The earth and planets were once in the hot sun.
- Shot out Pieces broke loose, held by the 'rope' of attraction.
- Moon breaks away A piece of the earth became the moon.
- Cooling Surface cools; interior stays hot.
- Rain Vapour condenses; rain fills the hollows.
- Oceans and life Seas form; life becomes possible.
What science says today
Nehru was passing on ideas held by many people in the 1920s. Since then, scientists have gathered much more evidence, and the established explanation is different on several points:
Nehru's account and today's science
-
Nehru's letter (1928)
- Planets were thrown out of the sun
- The moon came out of the earth, from the Pacific hollow
- The moon may be full of glaciers and ice
- Gravity is like a rope
-
Science today
- The sun and planets formed together from a huge spinning cloud of gas and dust, about 4.6 billion years ago
- The moon most likely formed from debris thrown out when a Mars-sized body crashed into the young earth
- The moon has no air and no glaciers; some ice is found only in dark polar craters
- Gravity is the pull between all masses
Some parts of Nehru's account do agree with science today: the young earth was extremely hot, it cooled from the outside, its interior is still very hot, and much of the water of the oceans came from vapour that condensed and fell as rain. The sun is indeed a star. And the sun will keep shining for billions of years, not merely millions.
New words
| Word | Meaning | Our own example |
|---|---|---|
| hollow | an empty space or a low place in the ground; (adj.) empty inside | Rainwater collected in a hollow behind the school. |
| condense | to change from gas or vapour into liquid | Steam condenses into drops on a cold lid. |
| tremendous | very great in amount or force | The team made a tremendous effort in the final. |
| interior | the inside part | The interior of the old fort was cool even in June. |
| whirling | moving round and round quickly | Whirling leaves danced in the courtyard. |
Worked example 1: how were the oceans formed, according to the lesson?
Question: How were oceans and seas formed? Working: find the cause (the earth cooled), the process (vapour condensed and fell as heavy rain) and the result (the water filled the great hollows). Answer: when the earth cooled, the water vapour in the air condensed and came down as tremendous rain, which filled the earth's great hollows and formed the oceans and seas.
Worked example 2: why did the moon cool faster than the earth?
Question: Why, according to Nehru, did the moon cool more quickly than the earth? Working: he links cooling time to size - the earth cooled faster than the sun because it was smaller. Apply the same idea. Answer: the moon is much smaller than the earth, so it lost its heat more quickly. (This idea - smaller bodies cool faster - is correct science.)
In an answer, report Nehru's account as his: 'According to Nehru...'. Know too that scientists today say the sun and planets formed together from a cloud of gas and dust.
Key takeaways: Nehru tells how the earth broke off from the sun, the moon from the earth, how both cooled and how rain made the oceans. His 'rope' is gravity. Science today explains the planets as forming together with the sun from a cloud of gas and dust, and the moon as most likely formed after a giant collision.
Check your understanding
-
1. In Nehru's letter, what does the 'rope' stand for?
- A real chain in space
- The force that attracts small things to great ones, which makes things fall
- The sun's light
- The path of a train
Show answer
Answer: B. He compares the force that keeps the planets whirling round the sun to a rope; it is the same force that makes things fall - gravity.
-
2. According to Nehru, why does a coal mine get hotter as you go down?
- Because of the miners' lamps
- Because the sun shines into it
- Because the earth's interior is still very hot
- Because coal burns by itself
Show answer
Answer: C. He says the surface cooled but the interior remained very hot, so it grows hotter the deeper you go.
-
3. Where, according to the view Nehru reports, did the moon come from?
- From the great hollow now filled by the Pacific Ocean
- From Mars
- From the sun directly
- From a comet
Show answer
Answer: A. He says many people thought the moon came out of the hollow that is now the Pacific Ocean, between America and Japan.
-
4. How do scientists today explain the formation of the sun and planets?
- The planets were thrown out of the sun
- The sun was made from the planets
- The earth is the oldest body and made the sun
- They formed together from a huge spinning cloud of gas and dust
Show answer
Answer: D. The established explanation is that the sun and planets formed together, about 4.6 billion years ago, from a rotating cloud of gas and dust.
-
5. Which sentence uses 'condense' correctly?
- On a cold morning, our breath condenses into tiny drops.
- The sun condenses the sky at noon.
- He condensed home after school.
- The river condensed the hill.
Show answer
Answer: A. To condense is to change from vapour into liquid; breath meeting cold air turns into droplets.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.