• Practice
  • About 14 min
  • 5 practice questions

From barter to money: double coincidence of wants and the evolution of money

Explain how the barter (commodity for commodity) system worked, list its four main difficulties, and trace how money developed from metal coins to paper, plastic and electronic money.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Describe the barter (C-C) system with an example.
  • Explain double coincidence of wants and the other difficulties of barter.
  • Explain how money solves these difficulties.
  • Trace the evolution of money up to e-money and cryptocurrency.

Fire, the wheel and money are often called three of humanity's greatest inventions. Every day you buy and sell with money without a second thought. This lesson goes back to a time before money, to see why people needed it at all.

The barter system

Under the barter system, goods were exchanged directly for goods. It is also called the C-C system, meaning commodity for commodity. When people's needs were few, this worked. A potter could give pots to a farmer for grain; a farm worker could be paid in grain for his labour; a blacksmith could receive grain for making ploughs and sickles.

Difficulties of barter

As needs grew, barter became hard to use. The textbook lists four main difficulties.

  1. Double coincidence of wants: what one person wants to sell must be exactly what the other wants to buy, and the other way round. Finding such a match is rare.
  2. Waiting: a person might have to wait a long time to find someone ready to trade on those terms.
  3. Storage: many goods spoil or lose value if kept for long.
  4. Transport: carrying large amounts of goods, say tonnes of grain, from place to place is difficult and costly.

Worked example 1: the broken chain

Situation (made-up): A potter has pots and wants cloth. The weaver has cloth but wants sugar. The sugar-maker has sugar but wants a goat. The goat-keeper wants pots. Question: Can the potter get cloth directly by barter? Reasoning: The weaver does not want pots, so there is no double coincidence of wants between the potter and the weaver. The potter would have to arrange a chain of three trades: pots to the goat-keeper for a goat, the goat to the sugar-maker for sugar, and the sugar to the weaver for cloth, finding each partner at the right time. Answer: Not directly. With money, the potter sells pots to anyone who wants them, then buys cloth from the weaver. Money breaks the chain into simple sales and purchases.

Barter and money exchange

  • Barter (C-C)
    • Goods for goods
    • Needs double coincidence of wants
    • Long waits, spoiling goods
    • Costly to carry
  • Money exchange
    • Goods for money, then money for goods
    • No need for a matching partner
    • Money keeps its value and is easy to store
    • Light and easy to carry

Where the word 'money' comes from

The word money comes from Moneta, a title of the Roman goddess Juno. Coins were minted at her temple in ancient Rome, and so the name passed to money itself.

The evolution of money

How money developed

  1. Barter Goods exchanged for goods
  2. Metal coins Gold, silver, copper, brass, later alloys; good for small payments
  3. Paper currency For larger payments
  4. Plastic money Debit and credit cards
  5. Electronic money E-money for digital transactions

The textbook also mentions cryptocurrency: a digital currency whose transactions are verified and whose records are kept by decentralised control, so that no single person or government controls it.

Worked example 2: why coins were not enough

Question: Why did paper currency follow metal coins? Reasoning: Coins of metal were fine for small amounts, but a large payment would need a heavy sack of coins, which is hard to carry and count. Paper notes can carry a large value in a light, small form. Answer: Paper currency was introduced to make large payments easy.

Barter needs a double coincidence of wants. Money removes it by acting as a medium of exchange.

Key takeaways: Barter is the C-C (commodity for commodity) system. Its difficulties are double coincidence of wants, long waiting, storage and transport. Money solves them by acting as a medium of exchange. The word comes from Moneta, a name of the goddess Juno. Money evolved from coins to paper, plastic and electronic money, and now cryptocurrency also exists.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. The barter system is also called the:

    1. M-M system
    2. Credit system
    3. E-banking system
    4. C-C system
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Barter exchanges commodity for commodity, so it is called the C-C system.

  2. 2. Double coincidence of wants means:

    1. Each person has exactly what the other wants, and wants what the other has
    2. Two people want the same good
    3. Wants are unlimited
    4. Two banks lend to one person
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Barter needs both people to want each other's goods at the same time. That double match is rarely found.

  3. 3. Which is NOT one of the difficulties of barter listed in the textbook?

    1. Goods spoil when stored
    2. Goods are costly to carry
    3. Money loses value too fast
    4. Long wait to find a partner
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Barter does not use money, so money losing value is not a barter problem. The other three are difficulties the textbook lists.

  4. 4. The word 'money' comes from:

    1. A Greek word for household
    2. Moneta, a name of the Roman goddess Juno
    3. The Latin word for gold
    4. The name of the first bank
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Coins were minted at the temple of Juno Moneta in Rome, and 'money' comes from Moneta.

  5. 5. Debit and credit cards are examples of:

    1. Barter
    2. Plastic money
    3. Full-bodied coins
    4. Commodity money
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The textbook calls debit and credit cards plastic money, a stage after paper currency.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery