- Practice
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Why public investment in education and health is needed
Explain the textbook's reasons why the government must invest more in education and health: poverty, urban and regional bias, weak infrastructure, population growth, women's status, costly private services, low spending and new diseases.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain why education and health are basic needs that the government must ensure.
- List and explain the textbook's reasons for more public investment in them.
- Use a student-teacher ratio in a simple calculation.
- Connect women's education with family health.
Education and health are two of a person's most important needs: without them, a healthy and prosperous life is hardly possible. The textbook argues that the government has not yet been able to make them available to everyone, especially rural people and those in remote areas, and gives several reasons why public investment (spending by the government) in these services must rise.
The reasons
Why the government must invest more in education and health
-
Poverty
- Poverty keeps people from education and health care
- Lack of them keeps people poor
-
Urban bias
- Colleges and big hospitals mostly in cities
- Villages have fewer and smaller facilities
-
Regional bias
- Some states much better served than others
-
Weak infrastructure
- Too few teachers, doctors and hospital beds
-
Population growth
- More people need more schools and hospitals
-
Status of women
- Low female literacy harms women's and children's health
-
Costly private services
- Private schools and hospitals are often beyond a common person's reach
-
Low public spending
- The textbook says only about 3% of GDP is spent on them
-
New communicable diseases
- Diseases such as COVID-19 and HIV/AIDS need costly care
Poverty
Poverty and lack of education and health form a vicious circle: poor families cannot pay for schooling and treatment, and without them they stay poor. The textbook gives the share of people below the poverty line as 21.9% (it links this to 2011). To raise living standards the government must put these services within everyone's reach.
Urban and regional bias
Facilities are concentrated in cities. A village may have a school up to senior secondary level and a primary health centre for basic care, but for college or serious illness people must travel to a city. Facilities also differ between states: the textbook names Maharashtra, Delhi and Punjab among the better-served and Chhattisgarh, Odisha and Uttar Pradesh among those that need more. Since these services are people's right and the government's responsibility, it must invest so that all regions are well served.
Weak infrastructure and population growth
There are too few teachers, doctors and hospital beds for the population. The textbook gives a student-teacher ratio in primary education of 26:1 for India, higher than in several other countries it lists, and a doctor-patient ratio of 1:834 for 2022. It also gives India's average annual population growth as 1.7%, which keeps adding to the demand for schools and hospitals.
Worked example 1: student-teacher ratio (made-up school)
Question: A primary school has 390 pupils and 10 teachers. (a) Find its student-teacher ratio. (b) How many teachers would it need to reach 26:1? (c) To reach 20:1? Working: (a) 390 ÷ 10 = 39, so 39:1. (b) 390 ÷ 26 = 15 teachers, so 5 more. (c) 390 ÷ 20 = 19.5, so 20 teachers (round up, since half a teacher is impossible), 10 more. Meaning: A lower ratio means more attention for each child, and reaching it needs public money for more teachers.
Status of women
Low female literacy lowers women's social and economic status. A woman who has not been educated may not understand or speak freely about her health problems, and may find it harder to care for herself and her child. An educated mother can look after her own and her family's health better, so investing in girls' education also improves health.
Costly private services, low spending and new diseases
Private schools and hospitals aim at profit; some have better facilities than government ones, but many are too costly for ordinary families. The textbook states that experts recommend spending at least 6% of GDP on education and health, while only about 3% is spent. New communicable diseases such as COVID-19 and HIV/AIDS are costly to treat privately, so public hospitals must be ready for them.
Worked example 2: the spending gap (made-up GDP)
Question: Take an imaginary GDP of ₹2,00,000 crore. Using the textbook's figures of about 3% now and a recommended 6%, how much more would have to be spent? Working: 3% of 2,00,000 = ₹6,000 crore. 6% of 2,00,000 = ₹12,000 crore. Extra = 12,000 − 6,000 = ₹6,000 crore, i.e. spending would have to double.
Education and health build human capital; when the poor, villages and weaker regions cannot get them, public investment must fill the gap.
Key takeaways: The textbook gives nine reasons for more public investment in education and health: poverty, urban bias, regional bias, weak infrastructure, high population growth, the low status of women, costly private services, low government spending and new communicable diseases. Its figures (26:1 student-teacher ratio, 1:834 doctor-patient ratio in 2022, about 3% of GDP spent) show the size of the gap.
Check your understanding
-
1. What does 'urban bias' in education and health mean?
- Villages have better hospitals than cities
- All states are equally served
- Facilities are concentrated in cities, so rural people must travel for them
- Private hospitals are cheaper
Show answer
Answer: C. Colleges and large hospitals are mostly in cities, so rural people must go to cities for higher education and serious treatment.
-
2. A school has 520 pupils. How many teachers does it need for a 26:1 ratio?
- 20
- 26
- 13
- 494
Show answer
Answer: A. 520 ÷ 26 = 20 teachers. Check: 20 × 26 = 520.
-
3. Why does educating girls also improve family health, according to the lesson?
- Educated women never fall ill
- It reduces the number of hospitals needed to zero
- It increases private hospital fees
- An educated mother can better understand and look after her own and her child's health
Show answer
Answer: D. The textbook links low female literacy with poor care of health; an educated mother can take better care of herself and her child.
-
4. According to the textbook, roughly what share of GDP does the government spend on education and health?
- About 6%
- About 3%
- About 26%
- About 53.89%
Show answer
Answer: B. The textbook says only about 3% of GDP is spent, against a recommended level of at least 6%.
-
5. Why are private schools and hospitals not enough on their own?
- They are often too costly for ordinary families
- They never have good facilities
- They are run by the government
- They do not exist in India
Show answer
Answer: A. Private providers aim at profit, and many charge more than common people can pay, so public facilities are needed.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.