- Practice
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
Small producers under globalisation and the need for fair globalisation
Explain why cheap imports hurt small producers, list the other problems small units face, and describe what fair globalisation means and what a fair policy of globalisation should include.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain how globalisation hurt many small producers and traders.
- List the other difficulties that weaken small units.
- Say what fair globalisation means.
- List the features of a fair policy of globalisation and how a government can protect local producers.
So far globalisation has looked mostly like good news: more choice, more investment, stronger big companies. The textbook now turns to those who lost out. Many small producers and traders could not survive the competition, and some workers lost their jobs. This leads to the chapter's final question: is globalisation good or bad, and how can it be made fair?
Impact on small producers and traders
The textbook says globalisation has adversely affected small producers and traders. Local producers whose products were similar to imported ones often could not match the imports in price and quality, and lost their business. The book tells the story of a small toy maker in a Punjab village (a hypothetical case) whose sales fell after cheap imported toys reached even village fairs. Below is a different, made-up case that shows the same chain of events.
Worked example 1: a made-up case of rising competition
Case (imaginary): Navdeep runs a small workshop near Jalandhar that makes steel water bottles. He employs eight workers and sells each bottle for ₹180. After import restrictions are relaxed, imported bottles of a similar kind start selling in local shops for ₹140. Reasoning step by step: (1) Buyers compare prices and many switch to the ₹140 bottle. (2) Navdeep's sales fall, so he produces fewer bottles. (3) With less work he keeps only three workers; five lose their jobs. (4) If he cannot earn normal profit, he may shut the unit. What it shows: consumers gain a cheaper choice, but the small producer and his workers lose, which is exactly the uneven impact the textbook describes.
According to the textbook, toys, tyres, batteries, sewing-machine parts, auto parts and sanitary products are among the industries where small manufacturers were hit hard. But imports were not the only cause. Small units also suffered from:
- Too little working capital (money to run day-to-day production).
- Costly bank loans.
- Lack of infrastructure such as power and roads.
- Poor marketing facilities.
- Weak bargaining power against big buyers and suppliers.
These problems forced many units either to shut down or to shrink, and many workers became jobless.
How cheap imports can hurt a small unit
- Cheap imports arrive Similar goods at lower prices
- Buyers switch Local sales fall
- Output is cut Fewer goods made
- Jobs are lost Workers laid off
- Unit may close No normal profit
The need for fair globalisation
Globalisation is often blamed for benefiting mainly the developed nations while developing and underdeveloped countries suffer. The textbook's answer is that a fair policy of globalisation can benefit every nation. Fair globalisation means that all countries benefit equally. The evidence, the book notes, is that this has not happened: countries with more skills and wealth have used the new opportunities best, while many others have not shared the benefits. What is needed is globalisation that creates opportunities, above all for employment, for everyone and shares its benefits better. In a developing country like India, the government should watch the process and make policies that protect the interests of different groups.
Fair globalisation: opportunities, especially jobs, for all, and benefits shared fairly among all countries and people.
A fair policy of globalisation should
- Not harm the interests of poor nations.
- Make proper use of the resources of all nations.
- Not be exploitative.
- Rest on mutual understanding and cooperation among nations.
- Ensure that goods and services are properly available in all countries.
- Ensure equal opportunities of employment for people in every country.
- Let underdeveloped and developing nations with similar interests form groups to protect their rights in the WTO against dominant countries.
Worked example 2: protecting local producers
Question: Using ideas from this chapter, suggest two ways a government could help small producers like Navdeep without shutting out trade completely. Reasoning: (1) Trade policy: a moderate import tax (a trade barrier, Lesson 2) narrows the price gap so that the local product can compete. (2) Support for the problems listed above: cheaper credit for working capital, better infrastructure and marketing help strengthen the unit itself. A third idea from the fair-globalisation list is for developing countries to work together in the WTO so that trade rules do not harm them.
Key takeaways: Globalisation hurt many small producers and traders, who could not match cheap imports and also faced shortages of working capital, costly loans, poor infrastructure and marketing, and weak bargaining power; many units closed and workers lost jobs. Fair globalisation means every country and group gains, especially through jobs. A fair policy is non-exploitative, cooperative, uses all nations' resources, gives equal job opportunities and lets developing nations protect their rights in the WTO.
Check your understanding
-
1. Why did many small producers lose business after globalisation, according to the chapter?
- Imports were completely banned
- They could not compete with cheaper imported goods of similar kind
- Consumers stopped buying all goods
- The government bought all their products
Show answer
Answer: B. When restrictions on imports were removed, similar goods came in at lower prices. Producers who could not match them in price and quality lost their buyers.
-
2. Which of these is a problem of small units that the textbook lists besides cheap imports?
- Expensive bank loans
- Too many buyers
- Too much working capital
- Very strong bargaining power
Show answer
Answer: A. The textbook lists inadequate working capital, expensive bank loans, lack of infrastructure, poor marketing facilities and weak bargaining power. The other options describe the opposite of these problems.
-
3. Made-up numbers: a workshop had 12 workers. After imports cut its sales, it kept only 5. How many workers lost their jobs?
- 5
- 17
- 7
- 12
Show answer
Answer: C. Workers who lost jobs = workers before − workers kept = 12 − 5 = 7.
-
4. What does fair globalisation mean in the textbook?
- Only developed countries should gain
- Every country should close its borders
- Only MNCs should be allowed to trade
- All countries should benefit equally, with opportunities such as jobs for all
Show answer
Answer: D. Fair globalisation means all countries are equally benefited and opportunities, especially for employment, are created for all, with the benefits shared better.
-
5. Which of these fits a fair policy of globalisation?
- Rich nations should set all WTO rules alone
- Developing nations with similar interests should form groups to protect their rights in the WTO
- Policies should exploit the resources of poor nations
- Employment opportunities should be kept for a few countries
Show answer
Answer: B. The textbook says underdeveloped and developing nations with similar interests should form a group to protect their rights against dominant countries in the WTO. The other options are exploitative or unequal, which a fair policy avoids.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.