- Practice
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Federalism: meaning, types and features
Define federalism and contrast it with unitary government, distinguish 'coming together' from 'holding together' federations, and list the features by which a federal government can be recognised.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Define federalism and give the origin of the word.
- Contrast federal and unitary government using Belgium and Sri Lanka.
- Distinguish coming-together and holding-together federations with examples.
- List the features of a federal government.
Lesson 2 showed that Belgium divided power between its central and regional governments while Sri Lanka kept all power at the centre. The first arrangement is called federalism; the second, unitary government. This lesson explains what federalism means and how to recognise it.
What is federalism?
In a federal system, the supreme power of a country is divided between a central government and state (provincial) governments. The centre, as the joint government of the whole country, deals with matters of national importance; the states deal with day-to-day and regional matters. In a unitary system there is only one level of real authority, and other units work under it and follow its instructions.
According to the textbook, Belgium earlier had provincial governments without independent powers; constitutional amendments divided power among central, state and local governments, so Belgium adopted a federal structure. Sri Lanka kept a unitary structure, and the Tamils wanted a federal one.
- The word comes from the Latin 'foedus', meaning a treaty or agreement.
- The textbook notes that a federal government was first introduced in the USA in 1789.
- Montesquieu described a federation as an arrangement in which several similar states agree to become members of a larger state.
- Professor Dicey described federalism as a system meant to balance national unity with the rights of the provinces.
Federal and unitary government
-
Federal
- Two or more levels of government
- Each level has its own powers from the Constitution
- States are not mere agents of the centre
- Example in the textbook: Belgium after its reforms
-
Unitary
- One level holds the real power
- Other units work under it
- Centre can instruct provincial governments
- Example in the textbook: Sri Lanka
Two ways federations are formed
| Type | How it is formed | Examples in the textbook |
|---|---|---|
| Coming together | Independent states join to form a bigger unit and give it sovereign power, keeping their own identity | USA, Switzerland, Australia |
| Holding together | A large country divides power between the centre and its units to run it well; the centre is usually stronger | India, Canada, Belgium, Spain |
How to recognise a federal government
- Government at two levels, central and state; often a third, local level as well.
- Each level's powers, including financial powers, are laid down in the constitution.
- A written constitution reduces disputes over the division of powers.
- The constitution is supreme; both levels must act according to it.
- The two levels cooperate for the country's security and development.
- Subjects are divided: national subjects (such as defence) with the centre, regional subjects with the states.
- An independent and impartial judiciary settles disputes between the centre and the states.
- Changing the constitution needs the agreement of both levels.
- Some federations have separate constitutions for the states (the textbook names the USA); India has a single constitution for both.
- Many federations have dual citizenship (of the state and of the country); India, the textbook's own example of a holding-together federation, has single citizenship.
Federalism = power divided by the constitution between a central government and state governments, each with its own powers, with an independent judiciary as umpire.
Worked example 1: federal or unitary?
Question: In a made-up country, 'Varanya', the national government can abolish any provincial government by a simple order, and provinces have no powers of their own in the constitution. Is it federal? Reasoning: Check the features - in a federation each level gets powers from the constitution, and neither can abolish the other on its own. Here the provinces work entirely under the centre. Answer: Varanya is unitary.
Worked example 2: which type of federation?
Question: Classify (a) separate colonies that agreed to unite into one federal nation, and (b) a large country that, after independence, created states and gave them constitutional powers. Reasoning: In (a) independent units come together; in (b) one country divides power to hold itself together. Answer: (a) coming together, like the USA, Switzerland or Australia; (b) holding together, like India.
Key takeaways: Federalism divides supreme power between the centre and states by the constitution; unitary government keeps it with one level. The word comes from 'foedus' (agreement); the textbook dates the first federal government to the USA in 1789. Federations either come together (USA, Switzerland, Australia) or hold together (India, Canada, Belgium, Spain). Their features include two or more levels, a written and supreme constitution, division of subjects and an independent judiciary.
Check your understanding
-
1. The word 'federalism' comes from the Latin word 'foedus', which means:
- king
- treaty or agreement
- people
- division
Show answer
Answer: B. Foedus means a treaty or agreement - a federation rests on an agreement to share power.
-
2. Which of these is a 'holding together' federation according to the textbook?
- USA
- Switzerland
- Australia
- India
Show answer
Answer: D. The textbook gives India, Canada, Belgium and Spain as holding-together federations; USA, Switzerland and Australia came together.
-
3. Before its reforms, how does the textbook describe Sri Lanka's structure of government?
- Unitary
- Federal
- Confederal
- Monarchy
Show answer
Answer: A. All power lay with the central government, a unitary structure. The Tamils wanted a federal one.
-
4. Which feature helps settle disputes between the centre and the states in a federation?
- A strong army
- Dual citizenship
- An independent and impartial judiciary
- A single political party
Show answer
Answer: C. An independent judiciary interprets the constitution and acts as umpire between the levels of government.
-
5. According to the textbook, in which country was a federal government first introduced?
- India
- USA
- Belgium
- Switzerland
Show answer
Answer: B. The textbook says federal government was first introduced in the USA in 1789.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.