• Practice
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

Plants also Breathe and Feel, part 2: the unity of life, what the crescograph showed and Bose's love for India

Understand the second half of the lesson: how a tired wireless receiver set Bose thinking, his idea of unity among living and non-living things, what the book says the crescograph proved, and his faith in his countrymen.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Explain what clue led Bose from physics back to plant life.
  • Explain the old and the new 'world-picture' and Bose's idea of unity.
  • List the uses of the crescograph as the book gives them.
  • Describe Bose's love for his country and his message to Indians.

With his salary struggle over, Bose began the work that made him famous worldwide. This half of the lesson explains how one small observation grew into a big idea, how he proved it, and what he believed about India.

Part 4: a tired machine

Bose had loved plant and animal life since boyhood, and his physics brought him back to it. He noticed that his wireless receiver seemed to get 'tired' after long use, and then got back its power after a 'rest'. A non-living machine behaving like a tired living body: this, the writer says, was food for thought, the kind of thought that leads to great discoveries.

Part 5: one world or many sciences?

How the picture of the world changed

  1. Middle Ages The world was seen as one beautiful whole created by God, everything with its place.
  2. Galileo and Newton Their discoveries changed this picture.
  3. Separate sciences Each branch was studied in detail on its own.
  4. Bose He saw a unity again: living and non-living things behave alike.
The history the lesson outlines.

Bose suggested that the animal, plant and mineral worlds have much in common, and that plants and even metals could become 'tired', 'depressed' or 'happy'. People laughed. The writer reminds us that people cling to old beliefs and dislike changing them.

Part 6: the proof

Bose answered the laughter with evidence. He designed and built the crescograph, which recorded his findings very exactly. According to the book, it magnifies the movement of plant tissue ten thousand times and records how plants react to manure, noise and other stimuli (things that cause a reaction).

What the book says the crescograph showed.
Use of the crescographWhat it means
Records the growth of plantsGrowth too slow for the eye becomes visible.
Magnifies movement of plant tissue (ten thousand times, says the book)Tiny movements can be measured exactly.
Records reactions to manures, noise and other stimuliPlants respond to what happens around them.
Shows plants react to light rays and wireless wavesThe book calls this a keen sight.
Shows plants are capable of feelingThe book says plants have hearts and can feel.

A science note: the book's words 'hearts', 'sight' and 'feel' are a way of saying that plants respond sensitively. Plants have no heart, eyes or nervous system like animals; scientists today describe these as responses of plant cells and tissues to stimuli such as light, touch, heat and chemicals. Bose's lasting achievement was to measure such responses with great precision.

Part 7: Bose and India

Bose had deep faith in the intelligence of Indians and was sure they could do great things now, as their ancestors had done. The book says that at a convocation of the University of Mysore in November 1927 he spoke of India's past glory and said it came from action, not idleness. He believed no single person could be truly happy until happiness had been won for all, and he wanted his countrymen to keep undying hope and faith in the future.

New words

Meanings with example sentences written for this lesson.
WordMeaningOur own example
stimulus (plural stimuli)anything that causes a reactionBright light is a stimulus that makes the eye's pupil smaller.
capablehaving the ability to do somethingShe is capable of solving the puzzle alone.
glorygreat fame and honourThe glory of the old fort still draws visitors.
undyinglasting for ever; never fadingHe had an undying love for his village.
give upstop tryingDo not give up after one failed attempt.

Worked example 1: the clue

Question: What observation started Bose's famous work? Working: look for the 'food for thought' in the lesson. It was the receiver that got tired and recovered after rest, behaviour we expect from living things. Answer: his wireless receiver showed signs of tiredness after long use and recovered after rest, which suggested that living and non-living things may respond alike.

Worked example 2: how can one be glorious?

Question: According to Bose's speech as reported in the lesson, how can a people become glorious? Working: the speech contrasts action with idleness and says India's past glory came from action. Answer: through action and hard work, not idleness.

Bose's method: notice a strange fact, form a bold idea, build an exact instrument, prove it.

Key takeaways: a tired wireless receiver led Bose to see unity between living and non-living things. People laughed, so he built the crescograph to prove his ideas. He believed in India's people, valued action over idleness and wanted happiness for all.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. What did Bose notice about his wireless receiver?

    1. It worked better at night.
    2. It showed signs of tiredness after long use and recovered after rest.
    3. It could detect plant growth.
    4. It stopped working in the rain.
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The receiver seemed to get tired and regain its power after rest, like a living body. This was the food for thought that led to his discovery.

  2. 2. Whose discoveries, according to the lesson, changed the old world-picture?

    1. Galileo and Newton
    2. Darwin and Einstein
    3. Aryabhata and Bose
    4. Edison and Marconi
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The lesson says the discoveries of Galileo and Newton changed the medieval picture of the world as one unity, and science split into separate branches.

  3. 3. What, according to the book, does the crescograph record?

    1. Changes in the weather
    2. The heartbeat of animals
    3. Earthquakes
    4. The growth of plants and their reactions to stimuli
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The book says it records the growth of plants, magnifies the movement of their tissue and records reactions to manures, noise and other stimuli.

  4. 4. How did people first react when Bose said plants and metals could become tired or happy?

    1. They gave him an award.
    2. They built a laboratory for him.
    3. They laughed and did not take him seriously.
    4. They asked him to write a book.
    Show answer

    Answer: C. People laughed at him because they did not like giving up old beliefs. He then proved his ideas with the crescograph.

  5. 5. According to Bose's Mysore speech in the lesson, what was responsible for India's past glory?

    1. Wealth and trade
    2. Luck
    3. Foreign help
    4. Action and not idleness
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The book says he declared that action, not idleness, was responsible for India's glory in the past.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery