• Practice
  • About 16 min
  • 5 practice questions

Answering questions and discussing In the Flood: Was Chenna unkind? Should we keep pets?

Write clear answers to comprehension questions on the story, argue both sides of whether Chenna was unkind to his dog, and build a balanced for-and-against piece on keeping animals as pets.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Write short, complete answers to comprehension questions in your own words.
  • Give reasons on both sides of a discussion question about the story.
  • Organise a for-and-against argument with a clear conclusion.
  • Avoid common mistakes in story answers.

The book's exercises on this story ask comprehension questions about what happens and two discussion questions: whether Chenna Paraya was unkind to his dog, and whether animals and birds should be kept as pets. This lesson shows how to answer both kinds well, with models written for this lesson.

Writing a good comprehension answer

Four steps to a short answer

  1. Read the question word Where, why, when, how or who: it tells you what kind of answer to give.
  2. Find the event Recall the part of the story it refers to.
  3. Answer in a full sentence Begin with the subject; do not start with 'Because'.
  4. Add one detail A reason or fact from the story makes the answer complete.

Worked example 1: model answers

  1. How long was the dog alone? Working: the family left by catamaran; the dog stayed through days and nights until the hut sank. Answer: The dog was left alone on the roof for days and nights, from the time the family escaped until the hut sank and he died.
  2. Did anyone help the dog? Working: list who came: boats, a boatman at the coconut tree, two men, thieves. None took him. Answer: No. Several boats passed and people even noticed him, but nobody took him to safety.
  3. Why did the thieves hit the dog? Working: what did the dog do to them? Answer: The dog bit one of them on the leg when he climbed onto the roof, so the other thief struck the dog on the belly with a pole.

Discussion 1: Was Chenna Paraya unkind to his dog?

A discussion question has no single 'right' answer. You earn credit by giving reasons from the story on both sides and then reaching a fair conclusion.

Two sides of the question

  • He was not unkind
    • He did pull the dog out of the hut with the family
    • The rescue was hurried and the hut was sinking
    • No one, not only Chenna, noticed the dog
    • He came back after the flood to look for him
  • He was careless
    • He forgot a loyal animal in the rush
    • He stayed for bananas but left the dog
    • He did not return during the flood
    • He prodded the body with his toe, unsure it was his dog

Model conclusion: 'Chenna was not cruel, because he never meant to leave the dog and he returned to search for him. But he was careless: in saving himself, his family and even his haystack, he forgot the one creature who stayed loyal to him. His cold reaction at the end shows how little the dog's sacrifice meant to him.'

Discussion 2: Should animals and birds be kept as pets?

Arguments in our own words. Use some from each side.
For keeping petsAgainst keeping pets
Pets give company and affection, especially to children and old people.Caged birds and chained animals lose their freedom.
Caring for a pet teaches responsibility and kindness.Many owners neglect pets once the novelty wears off.
Dogs guard homes and farms, as Chenna's dog did.In emergencies, as in the story, pets may be abandoned.
Rescued animals get food, shelter and treatment.Wild birds and animals belong in nature, not in homes.

Worked example 2: a balanced paragraph

'Keeping pets has clear benefits. A dog or cat gives warmth and company, and looking after it teaches children to be responsible. Yet pets can suffer when owners treat them as toys: they are left alone, unfed, or abandoned in a crisis, as the dog in In the Flood was. Wild birds in cages are denied the freedom they were born for. In my view, domestic animals such as dogs and cats may be kept as pets by people ready to care for them all their lives, but wild birds and animals should be left free.' Working: the paragraph opens with one side, turns with 'Yet', uses the story as evidence, and ends with a clear, reasoned opinion.

Discussion answer = reasons for + reasons against + your conclusion with a 'because'.

Common mistakes to avoid: starting an answer with 'Because'; copying long lines from the book instead of using your own words; giving only one side in a discussion; and adding events that are not in the story, such as claiming Chenna threw the dog out. Key takeaways: answer the exact question word in a full sentence with a detail; in a discussion, weigh both sides and conclude.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Which is the best answer to 'How did Chenna Paraya leave the village?'

    1. Because of the flood.
    2. He left on a catamaran whose boatmen heard his call for help.
    3. Quickly.
    4. He swam to Ambalapuzha with the dog.
    Show answer

    Answer: B. A good answer is a full sentence that answers 'how' with a detail from the story: he left on a catamaran after calling the boatmen. The dog was not with him.

  2. 2. Which point supports the view that Chenna was NOT unkind to his dog?

    1. He prodded the body with his toe
    2. He stayed for his bananas
    3. He came back after the flood to look for the dog
    4. He never thought of the dog again
    Show answer

    Answer: C. His return to search for the dog shows he cared. The prodding and staying for bananas are points on the other side; never thinking of the dog again is untrue.

  3. 3. What makes a discussion answer strong?

    1. Reasons on both sides and a clear conclusion
    2. Only one side, repeated
    3. Copying the story
    4. A list of new words
    Show answer

    Answer: A. A discussion question is about weighing views. Reasons for and against, followed by a reasoned conclusion, show clear thinking.

  4. 4. Which is an argument AGAINST keeping animals as pets?

    1. Pets give company
    2. Pets teach responsibility
    3. Dogs guard houses
    4. Pets may be neglected or abandoned, especially in a crisis
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Neglect and abandonment are harms to the animal, which argue against keeping pets. The other three are benefits.

  5. 5. Which sentence about the story would be a mistake in an answer?

    1. The dog bit a thief on the leg.
    2. The hut finally sank.
    3. Chenna deliberately threw the dog into the water.
    4. Several boats passed the dog.
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The story never says Chenna threw the dog out; the dog was simply not noticed in the hurry. Adding events that are not in the story is a common error.

Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.

Next lesson → Final self-assessment: In the Flood

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery