• Practice
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

Ideas in The Discovery of Moon: science and belief, people and machines

Think about the main ideas of the lesson: how evidence replaces old beliefs, the case for sending people or machines, the writer's purpose and tone, and where a factual text from the past needs updating; then practise on an original passage.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • State the main ideas of the lesson with reasons.
  • Argue both sides of 'people or robots in space' using the lesson's points.
  • Describe the writer's purpose and tone.
  • Notice which statements in an older factual text have been overtaken by later events.

A factual lesson still has ideas behind it. The writer chooses what to tell and in what order, and he ends with a remark about poets that is not a fact at all. Board questions on such a lesson often ask for its central idea, a comparison, or your own opinion with reasons. This lesson prepares you for those.

Idea 1: evidence replaces belief

The thread running through the lesson is that careful observation corrects old beliefs. Before 1969 people could only look at the moon and imagine. After the landings and the robot missions, scientists had soil, rocks and instrument readings. These showed a dry, airless, cratered world. The writer's words for this are strong: research shattered traditional beliefs. A good answer to 'Have the traditional beliefs about the moon proved true?' says no, and gives the evidence: no water, no air, no life, and conditions that no person could survive unprotected.

Idea 2: people or machines?

The lesson places the American and Soviet methods side by side and gives the Soviet reasons in detail. It does not say which side was right, so you may form your own view. Use the points below.

Should people or robots explore space?

  • For sending people
    • People can make quick decisions on the spot
    • They can choose interesting rocks by eye
    • Human journeys inspire the whole world
    • The lesson says the Apollo flights gave wonderful information
  • For sending robots
    • The lesson says a robot did the work as well as a person
    • Much less expensive
    • No human life in danger
    • A machine can stay for months in heat and cold

Idea 3: wonder survives knowledge

The last paragraph adds a human touch. Science tells us the moon is a dusty rock, yet poets still praise its beauty. The writer is not mocking the poets. He suggests that facts and feelings can live side by side: we can know about craters and still enjoy moonlight.

The writer's purpose and tone

  • Purpose: to inform young readers about how the moon was explored and what was learnt.
  • Tone: factual and admiring. Words such as 'great event', 'successful expedition' and 'wonderful information' show his admiration.
  • Order: events first (the landings), then results (what was found), then a list of facts, then a light-hearted ending.

Reading an older factual text

Factual writing is true as of when it was written. The lesson says that research has gone on for over three decades and that there is no longer any programme to explore the moon further. Since it was written, several countries have sent new missions to the moon. India's Chandrayaan-1 (2008) helped detect signs of water in the form of molecules bound in the soil, and Chandrayaan-3 landed near the moon's south pole on 23 August 2023. So when you read 'no water', understand it as 'no liquid water, no lakes or rivers': the traces found later are tiny amounts held in rock and ice in cold, shaded craters. The lesson's main picture of a dry, airless world remains correct.

Worked example 1: central idea

Question: Write the central idea of the lesson in about 40 words. Working: combine the three parts: the journeys, the findings, the ending. Answer: The lesson describes how the USA landed astronauts on the moon in 1969 while the USSR sent robots, and how this research replaced old beliefs with facts about a dry, airless satellite, though poets still love the moon's beauty.

Worked example 2: an unseen passage

Practice passage (written for this lesson): Rehana's grandmother believed that the dark patches on the moon were an old woman spinning thread. One evening Rehana pointed a small telescope at the moon and showed her the patches up close: wide, flat plains of dark rock. Her grandmother looked for a long time. 'So it is rock,' she said at last, 'but it is still the prettiest rock in the sky.' (Names and events are made up.)

  1. What old belief did the grandmother hold? Working: find the first sentence. Answer: that the dark patches were an old woman spinning thread.
  2. What evidence changed it? Working: look for what the telescope showed. Answer: through the telescope the patches were seen to be flat plains of dark rock.
  3. How does the ending match the end of The Discovery of Moon? Working: both endings accept the facts but keep a sense of beauty. Answer: like the poets in the lesson, the grandmother accepts the scientific fact but still admires the moon.

Evidence shatters old beliefs; it does not have to shatter wonder.

Key takeaways: the lesson's ideas are that evidence corrects belief, that people and machines each have advantages in exploration, and that knowledge and wonder can live together. Its tone is factual and admiring. Read its 'latest' statements as true of the time it was written.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Have the traditional beliefs about the moon proved true, according to the lesson?

    1. Yes, research confirmed all of them.
    2. Only the belief that it has rivers proved true.
    3. The lesson does not discuss beliefs.
    4. No, research shattered many of them.
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The writer says research over three decades shattered many traditional beliefs, showing a desolate place with no water or air.

  2. 2. Which word best describes the writer's tone in most of the lesson?

    1. Angry and bitter
    2. Factual and admiring
    3. Sad and hopeless
    4. Sarcastic and mocking
    Show answer

    Answer: B. He gives facts and uses admiring words such as 'great event' and 'wonderful information'. There is no anger or mockery.

  3. 3. Which point is an argument FOR sending people rather than robots?

    1. People can make quick decisions on the spot.
    2. Robots cost less.
    3. No human life is put in danger with robots.
    4. A robot can do experiments as well as a person.
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Quick human judgement favours sending people. The other three points are the reasons the lesson gives for the Soviet choice of robots.

  4. 4. Which statement in the lesson has been overtaken by later events?

    1. The moon is the earth's only natural satellite.
    2. The moon has no light of its own.
    3. There is no longer any programme for further exploration of the moon.
    4. The moon rises about 50 minutes later each day.
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Since the lesson was written, several countries, including India with its Chandrayaan missions, have sent new missions to the moon. The other statements remain true.

  5. 5. What does the last paragraph of the lesson suggest?

    1. Poets should stop writing about the moon.
    2. Scientific facts and a love of the moon's beauty can exist together.
    3. Scientists are wrong about the moon.
    4. Lovers know more about the moon than scientists.
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The writer notes that despite the 'dull' facts, poets and lovers still praise the moon. He suggests facts and feelings can live side by side, not that either side is wrong.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery