• Practice
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

The King who Limped, part 2: limping courtiers, the dog case and the king's test

Follow the rest of the play: the courtiers who copy the king's limp, how the king finds the dog's true owner, why one neighbour goes to prison, and how the king exposes the flatterers and rewards the honest.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Explain why some courtiers limp and two do not.
  • Retell how the king settles the quarrel over the dog.
  • Explain why the first neighbour is sent to prison.
  • Describe how the king reveals his test and rewards the honest.

The second half of the play is where the king's plan works. Watch two things happening at once: the king judging the neighbours, and the king judging his own courtiers.

Hats and limps

The Chancellor remarks that the old king wore a crown. The new king asks whether anyone could wear a crown in 'this blazing sun', though it is pouring with rain. No one corrects him. The Chancellor quietly sends for a hat, and soon he and the Prime Minister are wearing bowler hats too. When the courtiers come forward to kiss the king's hand, the Prime Minister limps up like the king and says he has cramp. The Chancellor copies him exactly and claims rheumatism. The Second Lady limps too and claims a sprained ankle. The king wonders aloud whether he has come to a palace or a convalescent home. The First Lady and the Courtier walk normally. She says she has always been healthy; he answers politely, and the king remarks that he seems to be a young man with a mind of his own.

Whose dog?

The king asks for advice. The Prime Minister wants both men put in prison; the Chancellor says for breaking the peace. The Courtier says he would first listen to them, and the king agrees. The first neighbour says he found the dog starving in the street three months ago and has kept it since. The second says his brother gave it to him last August, but the brother is dead and cannot be a witness. The first neighbour claims he has never told a lie in his life. No one knows either man, so there is no evidence.

The Courtier suggests the king keep the dog himself, but the king prefers cats and, more importantly, says he has no right to a dog that is not his. He asks the First Lady, 'the lady who did not limp'. She suggests cutting the dog in two and giving each man half. The king calls it a splendid idea. The first neighbour agrees at once, if the king thinks fit. The second cries out that he does not agree: let the other man have the dog rather than see it harmed. The king says it is now clear who the owner is.

Justice

The first neighbour, thinking he has won, asks to take 'his' dog home. Instead the king sends him to prison, for two reasons: he broke the peace by fighting in the street, and he tried to steal a dog that was not his. The real owner is the man who loved the dog too much to let it be hurt. The king sends him home with the dog and tells him to collect a bone from the palace kitchen, but not a chicken bone, which is bad for the little dog. The Chancellor says the late king would have punished both men and had the dog destroyed; the new king replies, meaningfully, that he is not the late king.

The test revealed

The king puts down his hat and walks up to the Chancellor without a limp. Asked again about his rheumatism, the Chancellor stammers that the pain is going off. The king explains: they limped because he limped, wore bowler hats because he did, and called a rainy day sunny because he said so. They are sycophants: people who flatter the powerful to win favour. When the Prime Minister says it is usual to agree with the king, the king answers that something usual is not necessarily sensible or right. He put on the limp and the hat to find honest people, and found two. The Courtier becomes Prime Minister, and the First Lady becomes chief Lady-in-waiting. The Second Lady is sent home to rest her 'sprained ankle', and the bowler hats go to the town museum. The courtiers are left staring in amazement as the curtain falls.

Two tests in one scene

  1. The limp and the hat Who will copy the king? Three courtiers do.
  2. The rainy 'sunny day' No flatterer dares to correct the king.
  3. Divide the dog The false owner agrees; the true owner refuses.
  4. Judgement Liar to prison; dog to its loving owner.
  5. Reward The honest Courtier and First Lady are promoted.

Worked example 1: how was the owner found?

Question: How did the king return the dog to the right owner? Working: a real owner loves the animal and cannot bear it harmed; a false claimant cares only about winning. The 'divide the dog' idea tests this. Answer: he agreed to cut the dog in two; the man who refused, preferring to give the dog away rather than see it hurt, was clearly the true owner, so the king gave the dog to him.

Worked example 2: the 'blazing sun'

Question: Why does the king speak of a 'blazing sun' when it is pouring? Working: the Courtier saw rain from the window, so the king's remark is plainly false. Anyone honest would correct it. Answer: it is another trap. The flatterers accept it and even put on hats against the 'sun', proving they will agree with anything the king says.

Two tests, one lesson: a true owner will not let his dog be harmed, and a true servant will not pretend to limp.

Key takeaways: the Prime Minister, Chancellor and Second Lady copy the king's limp and hat; the First Lady and Courtier stay honest. The 'divide the dog' test reveals the true owner, and the liar goes to prison. The king exposes the sycophants and promotes the honest pair.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Why did the Prime Minister and the Chancellor walk with a limp?

    1. They had hurt themselves on the steps
    2. They were copying the king to flatter him
    3. They were very old
    4. The king ordered them to limp
    Show answer

    Answer: B. They imitated the king's limp to please him, and made up excuses of cramp and rheumatism.

  2. 2. Who did NOT limp before the king?

    1. The Second Lady and the Chancellor
    2. The Prime Minister and the Courtier
    3. The First Lady and the Courtier
    4. All of them limped
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The First Lady and the Courtier walked normally; the king later calls them the two honest people.

  3. 3. How did the second neighbour show that he was the real owner?

    1. He refused to let the dog be cut in two and offered to give it up
    2. He showed a receipt
    3. He called his brother as a witness
    4. He agreed to divide the dog
    Show answer

    Answer: A. He could not bear the dog to be harmed and would rather lose it, which shows true love for his dog.

  4. 4. For which two reasons was the first neighbour sent to prison?

    1. For lying to the Chancellor and stealing a hat
    2. For refusing to bow and for shouting
    3. For hurting the dog and the page
    4. For breaking the peace by fighting and for trying to steal the dog
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The king named both reasons: fighting in the street broke the peace, and he tried to take a dog that was not his.

  5. 5. How was the First Lady rewarded?

    1. She was given the dog
    2. She was made chief Lady-in-waiting
    3. She was made Prime Minister
    4. She was sent home to rest
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The king made her chief Lady-in-waiting for her honesty, hoping it would mean less gossip in the palace.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery