• Practice
  • About 18 min
  • 5 practice questions

Proving results from Euclid's axioms and postulates

See how Euclid built theorems from definitions, axioms and postulates, follow proofs such as the equilateral triangle construction and 'two lines meet in at most one point', and write short proofs of your own.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Explain what a theorem (proposition) is and how it differs from an axiom.
  • Name the axiom or postulate used at each step of a short proof.
  • Follow a proof by contradiction, such as Theorem 5.1.

With definitions, axioms and postulates in place, Euclid could start proving. Each new result was deduced from the starting assumptions and from results already proved, and then used to prove more. This lesson shows how such proofs look, so that you are ready for the theorems in the chapters on lines, angles and triangles.

Theorems: proved statements

A statement that is proved is called a proposition or theorem. According to the textbook, Euclid deduced 465 propositions in a logical chain. Unlike axioms, theorems are never just accepted: each must be justified, step by step, by definitions, axioms, postulates or earlier theorems.

How geometry is built

  1. Undefined terms Point, line, plane
  2. Definitions Segment, circle, right angle ...
  3. Axioms and postulates Accepted without proof
  4. Theorems Proved by deductive reasoning
  5. More theorems Proved using the earlier ones

Every step in a proof must have a reason: a definition, an axiom, a postulate, or a result proved earlier. 'It looks true in the figure' is not a reason.

— Rule of proof

Worked example 1: the whole is longer than a part

Point B lies between points A and C on a line. Prove that AC > AB. Proof: the segment AC coincides with AB and BC placed end to end, so by Axiom 4 AC = AB + BC. So AB is a part of the whole AC, and by Axiom 5 (the whole is greater than the part) AC > AB. Note the hidden assumption: there is only one line through A and C, so B really lies on the same segment.

Worked example 2: a point dividing a segment

Point P lies between A and B with AP = 2PB. Prove that AB = 3PB. Proof: AB coincides with AP and PB together, so AB = AP + PB (Axiom 4). Since AP = 2PB, replace AP by 2PB: AB = 2PB + PB = 3PB. For instance, if PB = 2.5 cm then AP = 5 cm and AB = 7.5 cm.

Worked example 3: Euclid's first proposition

The very first result in the Elements shows that an equilateral triangle can be built on any line segment. Take any segment PQ.

  1. Using Postulate 3, draw a circle with centre P and radius PQ.
  2. Again by Postulate 3, draw a circle with centre Q and radius QP.
  3. Let the two circles cross at a point R. Join PR and QR (Postulate 1).
  4. PR = PQ, because both are radii of the first circle.
  5. QR = QP, because both are radii of the second circle.
  6. PR and QR are both equal to PQ, so by Axiom 1 PR = QR = PQ, and triangle PQR is equilateral.

Euclid assumed, without saying so, that the two circles actually meet. Spotting hidden assumptions like this is part of reading a proof carefully.

Proof by contradiction: Theorem 5.1

Theorem 5.1: Two distinct lines cannot have more than one point in common.

— Theorem

Proof: let l and m be two distinct lines. Suppose, just for the moment, that they had two different points in common, say A and B. Then there would be two different lines, l and m, both passing through the two distinct points A and B. But Axiom 5.1 says only one line passes through two distinct points. The supposition clashes with an axiom, so it must be false. Therefore two distinct lines have at most one point in common.

The shape of a proof by contradiction

  1. Suppose the opposite Assume the lines share two points.
  2. Reason from it Then two lines pass through two points.
  3. Reach a clash This contradicts Axiom 5.1.
  4. Conclude The supposition is false; the theorem is true.

Worked example 4: true or false, with reasons

StatementTrue or falseReason
Infinitely many lines can pass through a single point.TrueThrough one point you can draw lines in every direction.
Two distinct points can have two different lines through both.FalseAxiom 5.1: exactly one line passes through them.
A circle of radius 4 cm can be drawn with its centre anywhere.TruePostulate 3: any centre and any radius.
Two distinct lines can meet at two points.FalseTheorem 5.1: at most one common point.

Key takeaways: theorems (propositions) are statements proved from definitions, axioms, postulates and earlier theorems, and Euclid built 465 of them in a chain; each step of a proof needs a stated reason; Euclid's first proposition constructs an equilateral triangle using Postulate 3 and Axiom 1; and Theorem 5.1, proved by contradiction from Axiom 5.1, says two distinct lines share at most one point.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. What is a theorem?

    1. A statement accepted without proof
    2. A term left undefined
    3. A statement proved using definitions, axioms, postulates and earlier results
    4. A drawing that shows a result
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Axioms and postulates are accepted without proof; theorems (propositions) must be proved from them by deductive reasoning.

  2. 2. In the construction of an equilateral triangle on segment PQ, which postulate allows the two circles to be drawn?

    1. Postulate 3
    2. Postulate 1
    3. Postulate 2
    4. Postulate 5
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Postulate 3 says a circle can be drawn with any centre and any radius, so circles with centres P and Q and radius PQ can be drawn.

  3. 3. In that construction, why is PR = QR?

    1. They coincide
    2. The whole is greater than the part
    3. All right angles are equal
    4. Both equal PQ, and things equal to the same thing are equal
    Show answer

    Answer: D. PR = PQ (radii of one circle) and QR = PQ (radii of the other). Both equal the same thing, PQ, so by Axiom 1 they are equal to each other.

  4. 4. Theorem 5.1 is proved by supposing two distinct lines share two points. This leads to a contradiction with

    1. Postulate 4 about right angles
    2. the axiom that only one line passes through two distinct points
    3. the axiom that the whole is greater than the part
    4. Postulate 3 about circles
    Show answer

    Answer: B. If two distinct lines shared two points, two lines would pass through two distinct points, contradicting Axiom 5.1 (a unique line through two points).

  5. 5. C lies between A and B, and AC = 3 cm, CB = 4 cm. Using Axiom 4, AB is

    1. 1 cm
    2. 7 cm
    3. 12 cm
    4. 5 cm
    Show answer

    Answer: B. AB coincides with AC and CB placed end to end, so AB = AC + CB = 3 + 4 = 7 cm.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery