- Practice
- About 16 min
- 5 practice questions
Land under pressure, who owns the land, and labour
Explain the harm to soil and groundwater from intensive farming and stubble burning, describe how land is distributed, and define labour with its features and sources in the village.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain why land cannot be destroyed, yet its quality can be.
- Describe the effects of chemical fertilisers, falling groundwater and stubble burning.
- Describe the unequal distribution of land and the problem of small, scattered holdings.
- Define labour in economics, list its features and say who provides labour in farming.
Modern methods raised the village's harvests, but they came at a price. This lesson looks at the damage the textbook describes, then at who owns the land and who does the work on it.
Indestructibility of land, and damage to its quality
Land is a natural resource and cannot be destroyed; people can only change its shape or use, turning a plot into a garden, a forest or an artificial lake. Its quality, however, can be harmed. The textbook warns that heavy use of chemical fertilisers may raise yields at first but reduces soil fertility over time, so yields gradually fall. Continuous pumping by tube wells is lowering the water table: Punjab's farmers have to dig their tube wells deeper every year, and the textbook calls falling groundwater a serious problem in Punjab. Its conclusion is that the future of farming depends on caring for the environment.
Stubble: from useful residue to a problem
Multiple cropping created a new challenge: managing farm waste. When crops were harvested by traditional methods, the leftover residue, called stubble, was used as fuel, fodder and husk. Now farmers have very little time between the rice harvest and wheat sowing, and with no quick way to clear the residue many burn it. Burning causes serious air pollution and harms the ecology of the field: the topsoil heats up, bacteria, fungi and friendly insects die, and important minerals are lost, so soil quality falls year after year.
Stubble burning and a better alternative
- Rice harvested Residue (stubble) left in the field
- Little time before wheat sowing No quick way to clear it
- Burning Air pollution; soil life and minerals destroyed
- Better: mix it in A machine such as a rotavator works stubble into the soil, returning nutrients
The alternative the textbook gives is to mix the stubble into the soil with machines such as a rotavator. The nutrients in the residue then go back into the soil and help the next crop, so less chemical fertiliser is needed, the air stays cleaner and the soil does not deteriorate.
The textbook also calls Punjab the 'Food Basket' of the country because of its large share of India's wheat and rice.
Who owns the land?
Not everyone who works in farming in the village has enough land. A small number of families own most of the land, a larger group own medium-sized fields, many own very small fields, and some families own no farm land at all. These landless families earn their living by working on other people's fields and do not earn enough from farming. Many small fields are also scattered, because land has been divided again and again (fragmentation), so scientific cultivation and irrigation are hard to use on them. Farmers with large holdings, by contrast, can afford improved irrigation and machines for sowing and harvesting.
| Group in the village | Land | How they earn |
|---|---|---|
| A few large farmers | Most of the land; holdings of 10 hectares or more | Own farming with machines; also lend money |
| Medium farmers | Medium-sized fields | Own farming; some surplus to sell |
| Small farmers | Very small, often scattered fields | Own farming, often with family labour; may need loans |
| Landless families | No farm land | Work as labourers on others' fields |
The textbook adds that most Indian farmers have small holdings and that land is immobile: a farmer cannot carry scattered plots together. Land cannot produce anything by itself either; it must be combined with labour and capital such as a plough, seeds, fertiliser and water.
Labour
In economics, labour means all human effort, physical or mental, done for the sake of monetary gain.
Labour is the only active factor of production. A student playing a game for pleasure, or a mother caring for her child out of affection, is not doing labour in this sense. A cricket coach training players or a nurse looking after a child in hospital is, because the work is done for payment. Its features are: it is the only active factor; its supply can be increased or decreased; in India it is available in abundance; it can be bought and sold (that is, hired); and it is mobile.
Who provides labour on the village's farms
- Small farmers' families Cultivate their own fields themselves
- Landless labourers Work on large farms for wages
- Small farmers who lost land Gave up land to repay loans and now work for others
- Migrant labourers Come from other states such as Bihar and Uttar Pradesh
Wages may be paid in cash or in kind (such as wheat or rice), and they vary by region, crop and task. A labourer may be hired by the day, for one task such as sowing or harvesting, or for the whole year. Work in the village is plentiful at sowing and harvest; in other seasons labourers go to nearby places to work as rickshaw pullers, watchmen (chowkidars), hawkers or construction helpers. This is seasonal unemployment. The textbook ends by stressing that land and capital become productive only with the help of labour.
Worked example 1: is it labour?
Question: Which are labour in economics: (a) a carpenter making a cupboard for a customer, (b) the same carpenter making a toy for his daughter, (c) a tractor ploughing a field, (d) a hired accountant checking a firm's books? Reasoning: Labour is human effort for monetary gain. (c) is a machine, so it is capital at work, not labour. (b) is done out of affection. Answer: (a) and (d).
Worked example 2: wages in kind (made-up numbers)
Question: A harvest labourer is paid 20 kg of wheat a day for 10 days. If wheat sells at ₹25 per kg, what is the cash value of the wages? Working: Wheat earned = 20 × 10 = 200 kg; value = 200 × 25 = ₹5,000. Answer: ₹5,000, paid in kind rather than in cash.
Key takeaways: Land cannot be destroyed, but its fertility and groundwater can be. Stubble burning harms air and soil; mixing stubble in is better. Land is unequally owned and many holdings are small and scattered. Labour is human effort for pay, the only active factor, and in the village it comes from family farmers, landless and migrant labourers, who often face seasonal unemployment.
Check your understanding
-
1. What does the textbook say happens when chemical fertilisers are used heavily over many years?
- Yields keep rising for ever
- Soil fertility falls and yields gradually decrease
- The water table rises
- The land becomes larger
Show answer
Answer: B. Yields may rise at first, but heavy chemical use reduces soil fertility, so yields fall over time.
-
2. Why do many farmers burn stubble after the rice harvest?
- It is the law
- It makes rice grow faster
- There is little time before sowing wheat and no quick way to clear the residue
- It adds groundwater
Show answer
Answer: C. Farmers are in a hurry to prepare the field for wheat and lack a quick way to manage the residue, so they burn it.
-
3. Which of these is labour in the economic sense?
- A nurse attending to a child in a hospital
- A boy playing cricket for fun
- A mother feeding her baby
- A tractor ploughing a field
Show answer
Answer: A. Labour is human effort for monetary gain. The nurse is paid; play and a mother's care are not for money, and a tractor is capital, not human effort.
-
4. Labourers who come from other states to work on Punjab's farms are called:
- Landlords
- Entrepreneurs
- Seasonal farmers
- Migrant labourers
Show answer
Answer: D. The textbook calls workers from states such as Bihar and Uttar Pradesh who move to the village for farm work migrant labourers.
-
5. A labourer finds farm work only at sowing and harvest and pulls a rickshaw in other months. This shows:
- Seasonal unemployment
- Multiple cropping
- Fragmentation of land
- Working capital
Show answer
Answer: A. Work that disappears outside particular seasons is seasonal unemployment, which the textbook describes for farm labourers.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.