- Practice
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Salient features: a written, borrowed, rigid and flexible Constitution
Explain why India's Constitution is written and the largest in the world, list the provisions borrowed from other countries, and describe the three ways of amending it.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain why India needs a written constitution, unlike England.
- Recall how the Constitution grew from 8 to 12 Schedules.
- Match borrowed provisions with the countries they came from.
- Explain why the Constitution is both rigid and flexible.
The PSEB textbook lists many salient (main) features of India's Constitution. This lesson covers the first group: its written form and size, its sources, and how it can be changed.
1. A written constitution
India's Constitution is written. It was adopted on 26 November 1949 and came into force on 26 January 1950. Because India has a federal system, with power shared between the Centre and the States, a written constitution is essential to avoid disputes between them. By contrast, the constitution of England is unwritten: it grew over a long time out of traditions and conventions. A written constitution brings more transparency and clarity to government.
2. The largest constitution in the world
India's is the longest and most detailed written constitution in the world. As originally adopted it had 395 Articles and 8 Schedules. Many amendments have extended it, adding new articles and Schedules; it now has 12 Schedules.
| Schedule | Added by | Year | Subject |
|---|---|---|---|
| 9th | 1st Amendment | 1951 | Protects certain laws (such as land reform laws) from challenge |
| 10th | 52nd Amendment | 1985 | Anti-defection law |
| 11th | 73rd Amendment | 1992 | Powers of Panchayati Raj institutions |
| 12th | 74th Amendment | 1992 | Urban local bodies (Municipalities) |
The 42nd Amendment (1976) also added two new Parts, IV-A (Fundamental Duties) and XIV-A (Tribunals).
3. Many sources
Before writing our Constitution, the Constituent Assembly studied the constitutions of many countries and the Acts passed by the British Government for India, and took the best features of each. The main structure follows Britain: its unwritten traditions were given written form in ours.
| Feature | Source |
|---|---|
| Parliamentary system, law-making procedure, privileges of Parliament, rule of law | Britain |
| Fundamental Rights, judicial review, structure and powers of the Supreme Court, post of Vice-President | USA |
| Federal structure | Canada (and the Government of India Act, 1935) |
| Directive Principles of State Policy | Ireland |
| Emergency powers | Germany (and the Government of India Act, 1935) |
| Fundamental Duties | former USSR |
| Republic | France |
| Concurrent List | Australia |
| Procedure of constitutional amendment | South Africa |
4. Both rigid and flexible
A flexible constitution can be changed easily, by a simple majority. A rigid one needs a difficult procedure. India's is both, because different parts are changed in different ways.
Three ways of changing the Constitution
-
Simple majority of Parliament
Most flexible
- Articles 2, 3 and 4: new States, change of names and boundaries
-
Special majority of both Houses
Majority of total membership and two-thirds of members present and voting
- Most other provisions
-
Special majority plus approval of at least half the States
Most rigid
- Articles 54 and 55: election of the President
- Articles 73 and 162: extent of executive power of Union and States
An amendment bill may be introduced in either House, and both Houses have equal power over it. But Parliament cannot change the basic structure of the Constitution; what forms part of that basic structure is decided by the Supreme Court. The textbook notes that a Supreme Court decision of 1980 held judicial review to be part of the basic structure.
Written, the largest in the world (395 Articles and 8 Schedules at first, 12 Schedules now), drawn from many sources, and partly rigid, partly flexible - but its basic structure cannot be changed.
Worked example 1: which method?
Question: Parliament wants to change the way the President is elected. Which method must it use? Reasoning: Step 1 - the election of the President is in Articles 54 and 55. Step 2 - these need a special majority of both Houses and approval of at least half the States. Answer: The most rigid method: special majority plus ratification by at least half the States.
Worked example 2: counting Schedules
Question: The Constitution began with 8 Schedules and now has 12. How many were added, and name them. Working: 12 - 8 = 4: the 9th (1951), 10th (1985), 11th (1992) and 12th (1992).
Key takeaways: India's Constitution is written (England's is not) and is the largest in the world: 395 Articles and 8 Schedules at first, 12 Schedules now. It borrowed features from Britain, the USA, Canada, Ireland, Germany, the USSR, France, Australia and South Africa. It is partly flexible and partly rigid, with three ways of amendment, but Parliament cannot change its basic structure.
Check your understanding
-
1. From which country were the Directive Principles of State Policy adopted?
- USA
- Britain
- Canada
- Ireland
Show answer
Answer: D. The textbook's list of sources gives Ireland for the Directive Principles of State Policy.
-
2. Why is a written constitution especially necessary for India?
- Because India is a federation, and it avoids disputes between Centre and States
- Because England asked for it
- Because India has no traditions
- Because unwritten rules are illegal
Show answer
Answer: A. In a federal system power is divided between the Centre and the States; writing it down clearly helps avoid disputes between them.
-
3. Which Schedule, added by the 52nd Amendment in 1985, deals with the anti-defection law?
- 9th
- 11th
- 10th
- 12th
Show answer
Answer: C. The 10th Schedule on anti-defection was added in 1985. The 9th came in 1951, and the 11th and 12th (local bodies) in 1992.
-
4. Which change can Parliament make by a simple majority?
- Changing the method of electing the President
- Forming a new State or changing a State's name or boundaries
- Changing the basic structure of the Constitution
- Changing the executive powers of the States
Show answer
Answer: B. Articles 2, 3 and 4, on forming new States and changing names and boundaries, can be changed by a simple majority. The election of the President and executive powers need States' approval too; the basic structure cannot be changed.
-
5. Who decides what is included in the basic structure of the Constitution?
- The President
- The Lok Sabha
- The Prime Minister
- The Supreme Court
Show answer
Answer: D. Parliament cannot change the basic structure, and what it includes is decided by the Supreme Court, which, as the textbook notes, held judicial review to be part of it in 1980.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.