• Practice
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

Taxes, crisis and the thinkers of the Enlightenment

Describe the taxes the peasants paid, the rise of an educated middle class, and how Voltaire, Rousseau and Montesquieu turned people against the old order.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Anger alone does not make a revolution; people also need ideas that tell them a different world is possible. In eighteenth-century France the anger came from heavy taxes and an empty treasury, and the ideas came from writers of the Enlightenment. This lesson looks at both.

An economy resting on the peasants

France's economy was mainly agricultural, and the peasants carried most of the tax load. The textbook divides taxes into direct taxes (on land, income and property) and indirect taxes (charged on goods such as salt and tobacco). Two dues weighed especially on the peasant:

Two dues the peasants paid
TaxPaid toWhat it was
TitheThe ChurchOne-tenth of a person's yearly income or produce. It began as a voluntary gift but became compulsory.
TailleThe StateA tax fixed by the king that changed from year to year and followed local custom; the textbook says it also reached everyday goods like salt and tobacco.

An old French saying, quoted in the textbook, summed up the situation: the clergy pray for everyone, the nobles fight for everyone, and the common people pay for everyone. Only the Third Estate was taxed.

A rising, reading middle class

Within the Third Estate a middle class of merchants, lawyers, officials and other educated people was growing. Many believed that knowledge could solve France's problems. Information sheets were printed regularly and later collected into encyclopedias. These readers knew about the American Revolution; leaders such as Benjamin Franklin stayed in Paris and met French thinkers.

The eighteenth century is called the Age of Reason. The French philosophers argued that people were born to be happy, not to suffer, and that reason could sweep away prejudice. They trusted the laws of Nature and the power of reason more than tradition. The English thinker John Locke had already argued for a society based on freedom and equal laws and opportunities.

Three thinkers who shaped the Revolution

The thinkers and their main ideas

  • Voltaire (1694-1778)
    • Mocked the high-handedness of clergy and nobles
    • Attacked religious intolerance and superstition
    • His writings 'fed the fire' of revolt
  • Rousseau (1712-1778)
    • Against arbitrary, tyrannical rule
    • Popular sovereignty: power belongs to the people
    • Wrote 'The Social Contract'
    • A ruler stays only while the people trust him
  • Montesquieu (1689-1755)
    • Rejected the Divine Right of Kings
    • Favoured constitutional monarchy
    • Power divided among legislature, executive and judiciary

Rousseau pictured a 'State of Nature' in which people had been free, and said freedom was lost when wealth and property appeared. In The Social Contract he argued that government must rest on an agreement with the people and guarantee them freedom and equality. His most famous line opens that book:

Man is born free, and everywhere he is in chains.

— Jean-Jacques Rousseau, The Social Contract (1762)

Montesquieu proposed dividing the powers of government among a legislature (makes laws), an executive (carries them out) and a judiciary (judges disputes), so that no single person holds all power. The textbook notes that the United States put this model into practice after its War of Independence. India's Constitution also separates these three organs.

From grievance to revolt

  1. Empty treasury Wars, army and Versailles cost too much
  2. Heavy taxes on the Third Estate Tithe, taille and many others
  3. Educated middle class reads new ideas Encyclopedias, the American example
  4. Thinkers question king and privilege Voltaire, Rousseau, Montesquieu
  5. Demand for change in 1789

Worked example 1: matching a thinker to an idea

Question: A student writes: 'Laws should be made by one body, enforced by another and judged by a third.' Whose idea is this? Working: Look for the thinker linked with dividing power. Rousseau is linked with popular sovereignty and the social contract; Voltaire with attacks on the clergy and nobles. The separation of legislature, executive and judiciary is Montesquieu's. Answer: Montesquieu.

Worked example 2: tithe or taille?

Question: A peasant hands over one sack of grain in every ten to the parish. Which due is this, and who receives it? Working: One-tenth of produce paid to the Church is the tithe; the taille was a state tax whose amount the king fixed and changed. Answer: The tithe, paid to the Church.

Key takeaways: The Third Estate, and above all the peasants, paid the tithe to the Church, the taille to the state and many other taxes. An educated middle class, aware of the American Revolution, read the Enlightenment writers. Voltaire attacked privilege, Rousseau taught that power belongs to the people, and Montesquieu called for a division of powers.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. To whom was the tithe paid?

    1. The king
    2. The nobles
    3. The Church
    4. The town council
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The tithe was one-tenth of a person's yearly income or produce, paid to the Church. The taille was the tax paid to the state.

  2. 2. Which thinker wrote 'The Social Contract' and taught that power belongs to the people?

    1. Rousseau
    2. Voltaire
    3. Montesquieu
    4. John Locke
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Rousseau developed the idea of popular sovereignty in 'The Social Contract'. Montesquieu is known for dividing powers and Voltaire for attacking the clergy and nobles.

  3. 3. Montesquieu proposed that the powers of government be divided among which three bodies?

    1. King, Church and nobles
    2. Clergy, nobility and commoners
    3. Army, police and courts
    4. Legislature, executive and judiciary
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Montesquieu wanted law-making, law-enforcing and judging to be in separate hands so that no one could become a tyrant. The three estates are a social division, not a division of government power.

  4. 4. Why is the eighteenth century called the 'Age of Reason'?

    1. Because the Church controlled all education
    2. Because thinkers argued that reason, not tradition or prejudice, should guide society
    3. Because France won every war it fought
    4. Because the king allowed elections every year
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Enlightenment writers held that people were born to be happy and that reason could destroy prejudice. That trust in reason gives the century its name.

  5. 5. Which outside event, according to the textbook, encouraged educated French people to think change was possible?

    1. The Russian Revolution
    2. The First World War
    3. The American Revolution
    4. The Industrial Revolution in India
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The American Revolution came before 1789, and American leaders such as Benjamin Franklin stayed in Paris and met French thinkers. The Russian Revolution (1917) and the First World War came much later.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery