- Advanced
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Why Pondicherry became a refuge: cause and effect
Trace the chain from French rule to the arrival of Bharati and Sri Aurobindo, and judge which statements about the refuge are sound.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
At the advanced level, a question is rarely 'who was Bharati?'. It is more likely to ask why he was in Pondicherry, what followed from that, or how his stay connects with Sri Aurobindo's. That calls for cause-and-effect thinking. In this lesson you build the chain that explains why so many thinkers gathered in a small town on the Coromandel coast.
The chain
From French rule to a town of ideas
- French possession Pondicherry lay outside British India
- British Indian law stops at the border Nationalists wanted by the British could find shelter
- Bharati arrives in 1908 A Tamil poet and journalist continues his work
- Sri Aurobindo arrives in 1910 A leader of the Bengal movement turns to yoga and philosophy
- A meeting place of ideas Poetry, journalism and philosophy share one small town
- A lasting institution The Ashram takes shape in 1926
Who came, from where and when
| Person | Came from | Year | What they did there |
|---|---|---|---|
| Subramania Bharati | The Tamil country | 1908 | Wrote Panchali Sabatham and Kuyil Pattu; patriotic songs |
| Sri Aurobindo | Bengal | 1910 | Yoga and philosophy; Arya from 1914; Savitri |
| V. V. S. Aiyar | The Tamil country | Around the same years | A Tamil nationalist who also found shelter in the town |
| Mirra Alfassa, the Mother | France | Met Sri Aurobindo in 1914 | Led the Ashram that took shape in 1926 |
Notice a point of logic. French rule is the underlying cause of the refuge. The nationalists' wish to escape arrest is the immediate cause of each arrival. The Ashram, Auroville and the town's reputation are effects that came much later. A question may ask you to classify a statement as cause or effect.
Same refuge, different paths
The two men who came to the same French town took different paths. Bharati kept to journalism and poetry and wrote for the Tamil people, so his work stayed public and political in tone. Sri Aurobindo, after the Alipore case ended in acquittal, gave up open politics and turned inward to yoga and philosophy, writing at length in English. The town thus sheltered two kinds of work: the poet who sang to a people, and the thinker who studied the nature of life. The effects were different too. Bharati's songs and the poets who followed him, such as Bharathidasan, strengthened Tamil literature in the town, while the work of Sri Aurobindo and the Mother created the Ashram and later Auroville.
Worked examples
Worked example 1. Which was a cause, and which an effect: (i) Pondicherry was French; (ii) Sri Aurobindo wrote Savitri there. Working: the French status of the town made the refuge possible, so (i) is a cause. Savitri was written because he stayed and turned to yoga, so (ii) is an effect. Answer: (i) cause; (ii) effect.
Worked example 2. Could Bharati have first met Sri Aurobindo in Pondicherry before 1908? Working: Bharati arrived in 1908 and Sri Aurobindo only in 1910, so a first meeting in Pondicherry before 1908 is impossible. Answer: no.
Worked example 3. 'The Ashram was started before Sri Aurobindo moved to Pondicherry.' Judge. Working: he came in 1910 and the Ashram took shape in 1926, sixteen years later. Answer: false.
Worked example 4. 'After the merger of 1954, the town could no longer shelter anyone from British law.' Is this a fair judgement? Working: by 1954 British rule had ended in 1947, so the old reason for the refuge no longer existed. The question tests whether you see that the refuge belongs to the colonial period. Answer: fair; the refuge was a feature of the colonial period.
Underlying cause: French rule. Immediate cause: escape from arrest. Effect: a town of poets and thinkers, then an Ashram.
Key takeaways
- French rule outside British India was the underlying cause of the refuge; escape from arrest was the immediate cause of each arrival.
- Bharati came in 1908 and Sri Aurobindo in 1910; the Ashram took shape sixteen years after his arrival.
- The refuge belongs to the colonial period.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which statement correctly identifies the underlying cause of the refuge?
- Pondicherry had a great harbour
- Bharati was born there
- Pondicherry was a French possession outside British India
- The Ashram was founded there
Show answer
Answer: C. The status of the town as French territory made the refuge possible.
-
2. How many years after Sri Aurobindo's arrival did the Ashram take shape?
- 16
- 10
- 26
- 42
Show answer
Answer: A. 1926 minus 1910 equals 16.
-
3. Which of the following is an effect, not a cause?
- French rule
- Escape from arrest
- The wish to avoid police
- The Ashram and Auroville
Show answer
Answer: D. The Ashram and Auroville grew out of the stay of Sri Aurobindo and the Mother.
-
4. Which pair is in the correct order of arrival?
- Sri Aurobindo, then Bharati
- Bharati, then Sri Aurobindo
- The Mother, then Bharati
- Auroville, then Sri Aurobindo
Show answer
Answer: B. Bharati came in 1908 and Sri Aurobindo in 1910.
-
5. Which statement is NOT supported by the chain?
- The refuge existed because the town was outside British India
- Sri Aurobindo arrived before Bharati
- Bharati wrote major works there
- The Ashram took shape later
Show answer
Answer: B. He arrived in 1910, after Bharati in 1908.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.