• Practice
  • About 13 min
  • 5 practice questions

Who appoints, who advises, who answers

Trace the lines of appointment, advice and responsibility among the President, Lieutenant Governor, Chief Minister, ministers and Assembly.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

A favourite question type asks 'who appoints whom' or 'to whom is X responsible'. These are simple if you draw the three lines separately: appointment, advice and responsibility. In this lesson we draw them for Puducherry and then practise. For fine points on shared powers we say check the current legal position.

Three lines

Appointment, advice, responsibility
OfficeAppointed byAdvises or aidsAnswerable to
Lieutenant GovernorThe PresidentReceives aid and advice of the council of ministers on matters within the Assembly's powersThe President
Chief MinisterThe President, under the 1963 ActHeads the councilThe Assembly
Other ministersThe President on the Chief Minister's adviceRun departmentsThe Assembly, collectively
SpeakerElected by the AssemblyPresidesThe Assembly
MembersElected by votersMake lawsVoters

Line of appointment

  1. President Appoints the Lieutenant Governor and the Chief Minister
  2. Chief Minister Advises on other ministers
  3. Ministers Appointed on that advice
  4. Assembly Holds the council responsible
Who leads to whom

A short note on disagreement

In any Union Territory with a legislature, the administrator and the elected ministers may sometimes see a matter differently. The law provides ways of settling this, with a role for the President. Court rulings have also discussed where the line falls. Because such rulings can change the picture, an exam answer should state only the principle: the Lieutenant Governor represents the President, while the ministers answer to the Assembly; for the present position, check the current legal position.

Traps

  • Do not say the Lieutenant Governor is responsible to the Assembly. The Lieutenant Governor is the President's appointee.
  • Do not say the Chief Minister is elected directly by the voters; the post is held by the person appointed from among those with the Assembly's support.
  • Do not confuse the Speaker (presides over the Assembly) with the Chief Minister (heads the council).

Worked example 1: who answers to whom?

Question: to whom is the council of ministers collectively responsible? Working: collective responsibility is to the elected house, the Legislative Assembly. The answer is the Assembly, not the Lieutenant Governor.

Worked example 2: who appoints a minister?

Question: how is an ordinary minister appointed in Puducherry? Working: on the advice of the Chief Minister, by the President. So the Chief Minister's advice is part of the process, but the formal appointment is the President's.

Worked example 3: the Speaker

Question: 'The Speaker is appointed by the Lieutenant Governor.' Right or wrong? Working: wrong. The Assembly elects its own Speaker from among its members. This protects the independence of the presiding officer.

Practice with a chain. Write the chain on paper: voters elect members; members elect a Speaker; the President appoints the Chief Minister; the Chief Minister advises on ministers; ministers answer to the Assembly; the Lieutenant Governor, appointed by the President, receives their aid and advice. Then close the page and rebuild it. Each time a link is wrong, note which question type would have caught you: appointment, advice or responsibility. Most errors come from moving a link from one line to another, for instance making the Lieutenant Governor answer to the Assembly. Keep the three lines apart and the chain rebuilds itself.

Appointed by the President: Lieutenant Governor and Chief Minister. Elected by the Assembly: Speaker. Answerable to the Assembly: the ministers.

Key takeaways: keep the three lines apart: appointment, advice, responsibility. The Speaker is elected by the Assembly and ministers answer to it.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. The Speaker is chosen by:

    1. The President
    2. The Lieutenant Governor
    3. The Assembly
    4. The Chief Minister
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Members elect the Speaker.

  2. 2. The ministers are answerable to:

    1. The Collector
    2. The Assembly
    3. The High Court
    4. The Speaker alone
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Collective responsibility is to the Assembly.

  3. 3. The Lieutenant Governor is appointed by:

    1. The voters
    2. The Speaker
    3. The Chief Minister
    4. The President
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Article 239.

  4. 4. Other ministers are appointed on the advice of:

    1. The Speaker
    2. The High Court
    3. The Chief Minister
    4. The municipal chairperson
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The Chief Minister advises on ministers.

  5. 5. Which statement is correct?

    1. The Lieutenant Governor represents the President
    2. The Lieutenant Governor is elected by the Assembly
    3. The Speaker heads the council of ministers
    4. The Chief Minister is the head of a state
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The Lieutenant Governor is the President's appointee.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery