• Practice
  • About 14 min
  • 5 practice questions

Replacement problems: finding the amount and starting from a mixture

Solve harder replacement questions: find the quantity drawn, start from a mixture, replace with a liquid other than water, and check the answer.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

The standard replacement formula covers a vessel of pure liquid from which a fixed amount is drawn and replaced by water, again and again. Harder questions turn the formula around (find the amount drawn), start from a mixture instead of a pure liquid, or replace with something other than water. The tool is the same: after each step, every component that was in the vessel is reduced by the same fraction.

The fraction that remains

If a vessel holds V litres and x litres of the mixture are drawn out and replaced, the fraction of the ORIGINAL liquid that survives one step is (V − x) ÷ V = 1 − x/V. After n steps it is (1 − x/V)^n. This holds for every original component, whether it was milk or water, as long as what is poured in is something new.

x/V (fraction drawn)After 1 stepAfter 2 stepsAfter 3 steps
1/21/21/41/8
1/43/49/1627/64
1/54/516/2564/125
1/109/1081/100729/1000

Worked example 1: finding the amount drawn

A vessel holds 40 L of pure milk. A quantity is removed and replaced by water, and the same is done again. The milk left is 22.5 L. Find the quantity drawn each time. The surviving fraction is 22.5 ÷ 40 = 9/16 = (1 − x/40)². So 1 − x/40 = 3/4, giving x/40 = 1/4 and x = 10 L. Check: 40 × 3/4 = 30, then 30 × 3/4 = 22.5.

Worked example 2: a mixture to start with

A vessel has 80 L of milk and water in the ratio 3 : 1, so milk = 60 L and water = 20 L. Sixteen litres of the mixture are drawn out and replaced with water. The fraction kept is 1 − 16/80 = 4/5. Milk = 60 × 4/5 = 48 L. Water = 20 × 4/5 + 16 = 32 L. The new ratio is 48 : 32 = 3 : 2. If the same operation is repeated, milk = 48 × 4/5 = 38.4 L and water = 80 − 38.4 = 41.6 L.

Every component originally in the vessel is multiplied by (1 − x/V) at each step. Only what is added is new.

— Rule to remember

Worked example 3: replacing with something other than water

A 50 L solution contains 20% alcohol, so alcohol = 10 L. Ten litres are drawn out and replaced with pure alcohol. The fraction kept is 1 − 10/50 = 4/5, so alcohol kept = 10 × 4/5 = 8 L. Adding 10 L of pure alcohol gives 18 L in 50 L, which is 18 ÷ 50 = 36%. Here the new liquid is alcohol, so it is added to the alcohol total instead of subtracted from the water.

Working from the final ratio

Sometimes the question gives the final ratio of milk to water after one replacement. Let the vessel start with pure milk, V = 50 L, and end with milk : water = 3 : 2. Milk is 3/5 of 50 = 30 L, so the surviving fraction is 30 ÷ 50 = 3/5 and x/V = 2/5, giving x = 20 L. For two replacements, take the square root of the surviving fraction first.

A useful mental check: the milk left always decreases with each step, but never reaches zero in a finite number of steps. If your answer for milk is larger than the milk in the previous step, an error has crept in. Also, the total in the vessel never changes in a replacement problem, because what goes out is exactly what comes in.

Key takeaways

  • Original liquid left after n steps = V × (1 − x/V)^n, where x is drawn each time.
  • Turn the formula around by dividing the final amount by V, then taking an n-th root.
  • From a mixture, apply the same fraction to each component separately.
  • When the added liquid is not water, add it to its own total after applying the fraction.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. A vessel holds 64 L of pure milk. Sixteen litres are removed and replaced with water, and this is done a second time. How much milk is left?

    1. 32 L
    2. 36 L
    3. 40 L
    4. 48 L
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Fraction kept each time = 1 − 16/64 = 3/4. Milk = 64 × 3/4 × 3/4 = 36 L.

  2. 2. A vessel holds 50 L of pure milk. A quantity x is removed and replaced with water once, and the milk : water ratio becomes 3 : 2. What is x?

    1. 10 L
    2. 15 L
    3. 20 L
    4. 25 L
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Milk left = 3/5 × 50 = 30 L. So 1 − x/50 = 3/5, giving x = 20 L.

  3. 3. A 100 L vessel has milk : water = 4 : 1. Twenty litres of the mixture are removed and replaced with water. How much water does it now contain?

    1. 20 L
    2. 24 L
    3. 30 L
    4. 36 L
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Water = 20 L at first. Fraction kept = 1 − 20/100 = 4/5, so 20 × 4/5 = 16 L stays. Adding 20 L of water gives 16 + 20 = 36 L.

  4. 4. A 50 L solution has 20% alcohol. Ten litres are removed and replaced with pure alcohol. What is the new percentage of alcohol?

    1. 28%
    2. 30%
    3. 36%
    4. 40%
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Alcohol = 10 L. After removing 10 L of the solution it keeps 4/5 of 10 = 8 L. Adding 10 L alcohol gives 18 L in 50 L = 36%.

  5. 5. A vessel holds 81 L of pure milk. One third of the vessel is removed and replaced with water, and this is done three times in all. How much milk is left?

    1. 24 L
    2. 27 L
    3. 36 L
    4. 54 L
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Fraction kept each time = 2/3. Milk = 81 × (2/3)³ = 81 × 8/27 = 24 L.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery