- Foundation
- About 13 min
- 5 practice questions
Comparing two deposits: which earns more?
Compare deposits that differ in principal, rate or time, find the rate that gives equal interest, and decide between a monthly and an annual quote.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
A common question asks which of two plans is better, or what rate would make two plans equal. You do not always need to compute the full amounts. Because interest depends on principal × rate × time, you can often compare these products directly. This lesson gives a calm, step-by-step way to do it.
Compare the product P × R × T
SI = PRT ÷ 100, and the division by 100 is the same for every plan. So the plan with the larger product P × R × T earns more interest. If the products are equal, the interest is equal.
For plans with the same time, compare P × R. For plans with the same principal, compare R × T. The 100 cancels.
Worked example 1: two deposits
Same time, so compare P × R
-
Plan A
- ₹ 5,000 at 8% for 3 years
- P × R = 5,000 × 8 = 40,000
- Interest ₹ 1,200
-
Plan B
- ₹ 6,000 at 6% for 3 years
- P × R = 6,000 × 6 = 36,000
- Interest ₹ 1,080
Plan A: ₹ 5,000 at 8% for 3 years. Plan B: ₹ 6,000 at 6% for 3 years. Same time, so compare P × R: A = 5,000 × 8 = 40,000 and B = 6,000 × 6 = 36,000. Plan A earns more. Actual interest: A = ₹ 1,200 and B = ₹ 1,080, so A earns ₹ 120 more.
Worked example 2: the rate that makes them equal
₹ 3,000 at 8% earns the same interest in the same time as ₹ 4,000 at what rate? P × R must match: 3,000 × 8 = 4,000 × R, so R = 24,000 ÷ 4,000 = 6%.
Worked example 3: monthly or annual?
Which is the better rate for the lender: 1.5% per month or 17% per annum? Convert: 1.5% per month = 18% per annum, which is more than 17%. So the monthly quote gives more to the lender. For a borrower, it is the dearer one.
Worked example 4: working back from the difference
Two equal sums are lent at 5% and 7% for 2 years, and the difference in their interest is ₹ 400. The rate gap is 2% for 2 years, which is 4% of one sum. So 4% of P = 400 and P = 400 ÷ 0.04 = ₹ 10,000 for each sum.
| What differs | What to compare |
|---|---|
| Principal only | P |
| Rate only | R |
| Time only | T |
| More than one | The product P × R × T |
Worked example 5: three numbers, one winner
Plan A: ₹ 1,000 at 9% for 3 years. Plan B: ₹ 1,200 at 6% for 4 years. The products P × R × T are 1,000 × 9 × 3 = 27,000 and 1,200 × 6 × 4 = 28,800. Plan B earns more. In rupees, A earns ₹ 270 and B earns ₹ 288, so B is better by ₹ 18. Notice that the plan with the higher rate lost, because the other plan had more money working for longer.
Common slips
- Comparing only the rates and ignoring that the principals differ.
- Mixing a monthly rate with an annual rate without converting.
- Forgetting to say which plan is better; always state it in words.
Key takeaways
- Interest is proportional to P × R × T, so compare products.
- Equal interest means equal products.
- Convert rates to the same unit before comparing.
- A rate gap multiplied by time and by the sum gives the difference in interest.
Check your understanding
-
1. ₹ 8,000 at 5% for 2 years and ₹ 5,000 at 8% for 2 years. Which statement is true?
- Both are equal
- First is higher
- Second is higher
- First by ₹ 100
Show answer
Answer: A. The products P × R are 8,000 × 5 = 40,000 and 5,000 × 8 = 40,000, so the interest is equal (₹ 800 each).
-
2. Which is the higher rate for a lender: 1.5% per month or 17% per annum?
- 17% per annum
- They are equal
- 1.5% per month
- Cannot say
Show answer
Answer: C. 1.5% per month = 18% per annum, which is more than 17%.
-
3. ₹ 3,000 at 8% earns the same interest in the same time as ₹ 4,000 at what rate?
- 5%
- 6%
- 8%
- 10.67%
Show answer
Answer: B. 3,000 × 8 = 4,000 × R, so R = 6%.
-
4. Interest on ₹ 2,000 at 6% for 5 years compared with ₹ 3,000 at 4% for 4 years. The difference in interest is
- ₹ 20
- ₹ 60
- ₹ 600
- ₹ 120
Show answer
Answer: D. First: 2,000 × 6 × 5 ÷ 100 = ₹ 600. Second: 3,000 × 4 × 4 ÷ 100 = ₹ 480. Difference = ₹ 120.
-
5. Two equal sums are lent at 5% and 7% for 2 years, and the interest differs by ₹ 400. Each sum is
- ₹ 5,000
- ₹ 20,000
- ₹ 10,000
- ₹ 8,000
Show answer
Answer: C. Rate gap 2% for 2 years is 4% of the sum. 0.04 × P = 400, so P = ₹ 10,000.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.