- Practice
- About 16 min
- 5 practice questions
Comparing powers and surds without a calculator
Order powers like 2^300 and 3^200 by matching exponents, order surds of different orders using the LCM of their indices, and compare sums of surds by squaring.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
"Which is the largest?" and "Arrange in ascending order" are favourite question types because the numbers are far too big to calculate. Each has a quick method that turns the comparison into one between small numbers. This lesson gives you three such methods.
Method 1: make the exponents equal
For a base greater than 1, a larger exponent gives a larger value, and with equal exponents a larger base gives a larger value. So when the exponents differ, rewrite the powers with a common exponent using the HCF of the exponents.
Worked example 1. Compare 2^300 and 3^200. The HCF of 300 and 200 is 100. 2^300 = (2^3)^100 = 8^100 and 3^200 = (3^2)^100 = 9^100. Since 9 > 8, 3^200 is larger, even though its exponent is smaller.
With three powers, use the HCF of all three exponents. For 2^60, 3^40 and 5^20, the HCF is 20: 2^60 = 8^20, 3^40 = 9^20 and 5^20 stays. So 3^40 > 2^60 > 5^20.
Watch out for bases between 0 and 1. Then a larger exponent gives a smaller value: (1/2)^3 = 1/8 is less than (1/2)^2 = 1/4.
Method 2: surds of different orders
To compare √3, ∛4 and ⁴√6, write them with fractional exponents: 3^(1/2), 4^(1/3), 6^(1/4). The LCM of the root orders 2, 3 and 4 is 12. Raise each to the power 12, which keeps the order unchanged because all are positive.
| Surd | Raised to the power 12 | Value |
|---|---|---|
| √3 | 3^6 | 729 |
| ∛4 | 4^4 | 256 |
| ⁴√6 | 6^3 | 216 |
So √3 > ∛4 > ⁴√6. The same idea works with any number of surds: find the LCM of the orders, raise every surd to that power, and compare the whole numbers you get.
Method 3: compare sums of surds by squaring
To compare √5 + √3 with √6 + √2, square both. (√5 + √3)^2 = 8 + 2√15 and (√6 + √2)^2 = 8 + 2√12. The rational parts are equal, so compare √15 with √12. Since 15 > 12, √5 + √3 is larger. Squaring is safe because both sides are positive.
A useful pattern follows: when two pairs of numbers have the same sum, the sum of square roots is larger for the pair whose numbers are closer together. Here 5 and 3 (differing by 2) beat 6 and 2 (differing by 4), because their product, 15, is larger than 12.
Worked example 3: a quick ordering
Question: Arrange 2^48, 3^36 and 5^24 in ascending order. Working: The HCF of 48, 36 and 24 is 12. So 2^48 = 16^12, 3^36 = 27^12 and 5^24 = 25^12. Since 16 < 25 < 27, the order is 2^48 < 5^24 < 3^36. Answer: 2^48, 5^24, 3^36.
Powers: equalise exponents with the HCF, then compare bases. Surds of different orders: raise all to the LCM of the orders. Sums of surds: square both and compare what remains.
Common traps
- Judging by the exponent alone: 2^300 has the larger exponent but is the smaller number.
- Forgetting to reverse the order for a base between 0 and 1.
- Assuming √a + √b = √(a + b) and comparing √8 with √8. Always square properly.
Key takeaways: never calculate huge powers; convert them so that either the bases or the exponents match. For roots, use the LCM of the orders. For sums of roots, square both sides and compare the surd parts.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which of these is the greatest?
- 3^36
- 5^24
- 2^48
- 6^12
Show answer
Answer: A. The HCF of the exponents 36, 24, 48 and 12 is 12. So 3^36 = 27^12, 5^24 = 25^12, 2^48 = 16^12 and 6^12 = 6^12. The largest base is 27, so 3^36 is the greatest.
-
2. Which is the greatest of √2, ∛3 and ⁶√6?
- √2
- ⁶√6
- ∛3
- All are equal
Show answer
Answer: C. The LCM of 2, 3 and 6 is 6. Raise each to the power 6: (√2)^6 = 2^3 = 8, (∛3)^6 = 3^2 = 9 and (⁶√6)^6 = 6. The largest is 9, so ∛3 is the greatest.
-
3. Which is the smallest of √3, ∛5 and ⁴√10?
- √3
- ⁴√10
- They are equal
- ∛5
Show answer
Answer: D. The LCM of 2, 3 and 4 is 12. Raise each to the power 12: 3^6 = 729, 5^4 = 625 and 10^3 = 1000. The smallest is 625, so ∛5 is the smallest.
-
4. Which is larger: √10 + √3 or √8 + √5?
- √10 + √3
- √8 + √5
- Both are equal
- Cannot be decided
Show answer
Answer: B. Square both: (√10 + √3)^2 = 13 + 2√30 and (√8 + √5)^2 = 13 + 2√40. Since √40 > √30, √8 + √5 is larger.
-
5. Which is the greatest of (0.5)^(1/2), (0.5)^2, (0.5)^3 and (0.5)^4?
- (0.5)^(1/2)
- (0.5)^3
- (0.5)^4
- (0.5)^2
Show answer
Answer: A. The base 0.5 is between 0 and 1, so the smallest exponent gives the greatest value. (0.5)^(1/2) is about 0.707, while (0.5)^2 = 0.25, (0.5)^3 = 0.125 and (0.5)^4 = 0.0625.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.