• Advanced
  • About 16 min
  • 5 practice questions

Rajasthan's economy as a system: aridity, water and the east-west divide

See Rajasthan's economy as one system driven by dryness, old rocks and sun, trace a product through the three sectors, and use assertion-reason reasoning on economy statements.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Earlier courses gave you the facts of Rajasthan's economy. At the advanced level a question seldom asks you to name a thing; it asks why a thing is where it is, or whether a stated reason really explains a fact. To answer, you need to see the economy as one system in which three physical features explain most of what you meet: a dry climate across much of the state, very old rocks full of minerals, and plenty of sun, wind and open land.

The east-west divide

The Aravalli range runs from the south-west to the north-east of the state and divides it into two very different halves. To its north-west lies the Thar desert, with sandy soil, thin rainfall and sparse vegetation. To its east and south-east lie better-watered plains and plateaus with alluvial and black soils, rivers such as the Chambal and the Banas, and denser farming.

A common trap concerns why the west is dry. Many students answer that the Aravalli blocks the monsoon. The accepted explanation is the opposite: the Arabian Sea branch of the south-west monsoon blows roughly parallel to the Aravalli, and the range is low and broken, so it does not force the moist air to rise and rain out. The winds pass along it and go on without shedding much rain on the desert side.

Gifts and costs

Each gift of the state has a cost that comes from the same land
FeaturePhysical causeActivity it supportsSectorMatching cost
Very old rocks of the Aravalli regionAncient folded rocks that carry ores and building stoneMining of copper, zinc, lead, marble and sandstonePrimary (the mine); secondary (smelting, cutting)Dust, loss of hills and groundwater pressure
Sun, wind and open land in the westClear skies, flat sparse landSolar and wind powerSecondary (generating power)Long transmission lines and uneven output
Hardy grasses and shrubs on dry landLow rain means little but tough vegetationCamels, sheep, goats and desert cattlePrimaryFodder shortage in drought years
Forts, palaces, fairs and craftsHistory and culture, not climateHotels, guides, handicraftsTertiary and secondarySeasonal income and strain on water

A fifth thread runs through the whole table: water. Where it is scarce, as in the west, the economy leans on mining, livestock and hardy crops; where it is available, as in canal-fed districts and the south-east, farming becomes intensive.

A product crosses sectors

Questions often hide the sector in the stage of the activity. Limestone cut from a quarry is primary; cement made from it is secondary; the truck that carries the cement is a service. The same applies to wool: shearing sheep is primary, spinning and weaving it is secondary, and selling the carpet to a visitor is tertiary.

Following one stone through the economy

  1. Quarry Cutting marble or sandstone from the ground takes from nature - primary
  2. Cutting and polishing Slabs are shaped and finished, which changes a raw material into a product - secondary
  3. Transport Trucks carry slabs to builders - a service, tertiary
  4. Sale and use Dealers, contractors and designers add services - tertiary
Ask which stage the question describes before you choose a sector

Four tools for hard economy questions

  1. Find the physical cause. Most correct reasons are about rainfall, water, soil, rock or distance.
  2. Name the stage. Decide whether the activity takes, makes or serves.
  3. Test absolute words. 'Only', 'all', 'no' and 'always' usually make a statement false, because Rajasthan has exceptions in every region.
  4. Test the reason separately. In an assertion-reason question, judge the assertion first, then the reason, and only then ask whether the reason actually explains the assertion.

The four standard answers to an assertion-reason question are: both true and the reason explains; both true but the reason does not explain; assertion true and reason false; assertion false and reason true. The commonest trap is the second, where both sentences are true facts but one has nothing to do with the other.

Worked example 1: a reason that sounds right

Question: Assertion: western Rajasthan receives little rain. Reason: the Aravalli range blocks the monsoon winds. Working: The assertion is true. The reason is the popular but wrong explanation: the winds run roughly parallel to the range, so it does not block them. Answer: assertion true, reason false.

Worked example 2: classify the stages

Question: Classify (i) cutting sandstone in a quarry, (ii) carving it into a lattice screen, (iii) a driver delivering it to a building site. Working: (i) takes from the ground, primary. (ii) changes a raw material into a finished article, secondary. (iii) is a service, tertiary. Answer: primary, secondary, tertiary.

Worked example 3: a statement that does not follow

Question: 'Because Rajasthan is dry, farming plays no part in its economy.' Is the reasoning sound? Working: The word 'no' is absolute. Canal water in the north-west and rivers in the south-east support large farming areas, and dryland crops such as bajra grow even in the west. Answer: unsound.

Ask three things of any economy question: which half of the state, which stage of activity, and what physical cause links them.

Key takeaways: the Aravalli divides a dry north-west from a better-watered east and south-east; the dry west is explained by monsoon winds running along the range, not blocked by it; old rocks give minerals, clear skies give solar and wind power; and water supply predicts how intensive the economy is.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Which explanation for the dryness of western Rajasthan is accepted?

    1. The Aravalli is a very tall wall that stops all monsoon clouds
    2. The Arabian Sea branch of the monsoon runs roughly parallel to the Aravalli, so little rain is shed
    3. The Bay of Bengal branch ends before reaching the region
    4. The Thar desert is far from every sea, so no monsoon reaches it at all
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The winds run along the low, broken Aravalli instead of being forced up, so they pass on without raining out. The range is not a high wall.

  2. 2. Quarrying marble, cutting it into slabs and delivering the slabs are respectively:

    1. secondary, secondary, primary
    2. primary, tertiary, secondary
    3. tertiary, primary, secondary
    4. primary, secondary, tertiary
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Quarrying takes from the ground (primary), cutting makes a finished article (secondary), delivery is a service (tertiary).

  3. 3. Which of these is a service activity?

    1. Mining copper ore
    2. Weaving woollen blankets
    3. A guide taking visitors around a fort
    4. Grazing camels on dry land
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Guiding is a service, so tertiary. Mining and grazing are primary and weaving is secondary.

  4. 4. Assertion: Rajasthan has a large potential for solar power. Reason: The state has many clear sunny days and large areas of open, sparsely used land.

    1. Both the assertion and the reason are true, and the reason explains the assertion
    2. Both are true, but the reason does not explain the assertion
    3. The assertion is true but the reason is false
    4. The assertion is false but the reason is true
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Both are true and the second is exactly why solar plants suit the state, particularly in the west.

  5. 5. Which statement about the Aravalli range is correct?

    1. It runs from the south-west to the north-east and divides the state into a dry north-west and a better-watered east and south-east
    2. It runs from east to west across the middle of the state
    3. It lies wholly in the Thar desert and carries no minerals
    4. It is a young range formed in the recent geological past
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The Aravalli runs south-west to north-east. It is among the oldest fold mountains and is rich in minerals, so the other statements are wrong.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery