- Advanced
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
Organic policy as cause and effect
Trace the chain from fragile mountains to organic policy to market value, weigh the gains against the costs, and answer statement and assertion-reason questions on organic Sikkim.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
At the advanced level, an examiner no longer asks only when Sikkim became organic. The question asks why it was a sensible choice, what it changed and what it cost. To answer such questions you need to think in chains of cause and effect. This lesson builds the chain for organic farming and then practises the question forms that test it.
The chain of reasoning
From mountain to market
- Steep, young, thin soil Land loses soil and water quickly
- Chemical inputs risk run-off Fertiliser and pesticide can reach streams that feed the Teesta
- Organic policy Compost, manure, rotation and certification replace chemicals
- Cleaner soil and water Soil structure and streams are protected over time
- Market value Certified produce can fetch a better price and supports tourism
Notice that the chain does not say yields rise. Organic farming protects land and water and may earn a premium price, but quantity can fall at first. The word premium and the word protects are safe. The words always higher yield are not.
Gains and costs side by side
| Gains | Costs or limits |
|---|---|
| Protects fragile slopes and streams | Yield may fall while soil recovers |
| Certified produce can sell at a better price | Certification needs records, checks and money |
| Fits small, mixed farms and shade crops such as large cardamom | Compost and manure need more labour |
| Supports a clean image for tourism and local food | Farmers need markets that pay for the extra effort |
| Reduces dependence on bought chemicals | Pests and diseases, such as chirke and furkey in cardamom, still need management |
In 2018, Sikkim's organic policy received an international award, the Future Policy Award, from a body connected with the Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations. Treat this as a recognition of policy, not as a claim about every farm; check the exact wording before using it in an answer.
Question forms at this level
An assertion-reason question gives two sentences, A and R, and asks whether each is true and whether R explains A. Check A alone first, then R alone, then ask 'because of R, does A happen?'. A two-statement question asks which of two claims is correct; test each against what you know and watch for absolute words such as always, only and all.
When you meet an organic-farming question in a mixed paper, check which of four things it wants: the fact, the date, the method or the reason. Examiners also like to join two of them, for example asking for the date and a reason in the same sentence. Prepare short answers of one line for each, and practise saying them in your own words. If you can explain the chain to a friend without looking at your notes, you know it well enough for the exam.
Worked examples
Example 1. Assertion A: Organic farming suits the steep slopes of Sikkim. Reason R: Chemicals can wash off steep slopes into rivers. Both are true, and R explains A, because avoiding chemicals protects the streams that run down the slopes. Answer: both true, R explains A.
Example 2. Statement 1: Sikkim was declared fully organic in January 2016. Statement 2: Organic farming always increases yield in the first year. Statement 1 is true. Statement 2 uses the word always and is false, because yields may fall at first. Answer: only statement 1.
Example 3. A farm's income is yield times price. Before the change it sold 50 quintals at 2,000 rupees. After the change it sells 45 quintals at 2,400 rupees. Before: 50 times 2,000 is 100,000 rupees. After: 45 times 2,400 is 108,000 rupees. Income rose by 8,000 rupees, even though the yield fell. This is the logic of the premium price.
Chain: steep land -> run-off risk -> organic policy -> protected soil and water -> premium and tourism. Beware 'always higher yield'.
Key takeaways: Reason in chains. Organic policy protects land and water and can raise price, but it can lower yield and needs certification and labour. Test absolute words in statements.
Check your understanding
-
1. Assertion A: Organic farming suits the steep terraces of Sikkim. Reason R: Avoiding chemical fertilisers reduces the chance of chemicals washing into streams on steep land. Choose the correct option.
- Both A and R are true, but R does not explain A
- Both A and R are true, and R explains A
- A is true, but R is false
- A is false, but R is true
Show answer
Answer: B. Both are true, and R explains why organic farming suits steep land.
-
2. Statement 1: Organic farming in Sikkim relies on compost and manure. Statement 2: Organic farming always gives a higher yield than chemical farming in the first year. Which is correct?
- Only statement 2 is correct
- Both statements are correct
- Neither statement is correct
- Only statement 1 is correct
Show answer
Answer: D. Statement 1 is true. Statement 2 is false because yields can fall at first.
-
3. A farm sells 40 quintals at 2,500 rupees. After changing to organic methods it sells 36 quintals at 3,000 rupees. What is the change in income?
- An increase of 8,000 rupees
- A decrease of 8,000 rupees
- An increase of 18,000 rupees
- No change
Show answer
Answer: A. Before: 40 times 2,500 is 100,000. After: 36 times 3,000 is 108,000. Income rises by 8,000 rupees.
-
4. Assertion A: Certification is necessary in an organic state. Reason R: Buyers cannot see from the produce itself how it was grown. Choose the correct option.
- Both A and R are true, but R does not explain A
- A is true, but R is false
- Both A and R are true, and R explains A
- A is false, but R is true
Show answer
Answer: C. Both are true; because buyers cannot see the method, certification gives them a reason to trust the claim.
-
5. Which is the safest conclusion about the cost of going organic?
- It always raises yield
- It makes certification unnecessary
- It can lower yield at first and needs labour and certification
- It removes all pests permanently
Show answer
Answer: C. Organic farming brings real costs: lower early yield, more labour and the need for certification.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.