• Advanced
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

From protectorate to state: what each status meant in law

Distinguish protectorate, associate state and full state in legal terms, and say what the 1974 and 1975 amendments did to the Constitution.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

At the foundation and practice levels you learned the order of Sikkim's statuses and the amendment numbers. Advanced questions ask what each status meant in law and what each amendment did to the text of the Constitution. They are often framed as statements to judge or as assertion and reason. This lesson sets out the legal content so that you can reason, not just recall.

1950: a protectorate

Under the 1950 treaty between India and Sikkim, Sikkim kept its own ruler, the Chogyal, and its own internal administration. India took responsibility for defence, external affairs and strategic communications. Sikkim was not part of India, and the Indian Constitution did not apply to it. For examination purposes this is the key contrast with later steps: a protectorate is outside the constitutional structure of India.

1974: associate state

After the political agitation of 1973 and the elections of 1974, the Government of Sikkim Act, 1974 made the Chogyal a constitutional head and set up a responsible government answerable to an elected Assembly. In the same year, the Thirty-fifth Amendment of the Indian Constitution inserted Article 2A and a Tenth Schedule. Article 2A said that Sikkim would be associated with the Union on the terms and conditions set out in the Tenth Schedule. 'Associate state' was a special position with closer ties to India than a protectorate, but it was not a full state, and it was not listed among the states in the First Schedule.

1975: the Thirty-sixth Amendment

The Thirty-sixth Amendment, which took effect on 16 May 1975, did four connected things. It added Sikkim to the First Schedule as the 22nd state. It omitted Article 2A and the old Tenth Schedule, since the associate position no longer existed. It added Article 371F with special provisions. And it extended the Constitution fully to the new state. The Tenth Schedule number was later reused: in 1985 a new Tenth Schedule was inserted by the Fifty-second Amendment to deal with disqualification for defection. The old and new Tenth Schedules are unrelated.

Three statuses compared
FeatureProtectorate (1950)Associate state (1974)State (1975)
Ruler or headChogyalChogyal as constitutional headGovernor appointed by the President
Constitution of India appliesNoOnly through the terms of associationYes, fully, with Article 371F
Defence and external affairsIndiaIndiaUnion subjects, as for any state
Constitutional textTreatyArticle 2A, Tenth ScheduleArticle 371F, First Schedule

Associate state and state

  • Associate state
    • Article 2A and old Tenth Schedule
    • Joined by terms of association
    • Not in the First Schedule as a state
  • State
    • Article 371F
    • Listed in the First Schedule
    • Fully under the Constitution
Why the numbering changed

Reading a question on statuses

When a question mentions a status, ask three things: who was the head, which document governed the relationship, and whether the Constitution of India applied. A protectorate answers 'Chogyal, treaty, no'. An associate state answers 'Chogyal as constitutional head, Article 2A and the old Tenth Schedule, partly'. A state answers 'Governor, the Constitution with Article 371F, fully'. Using these three questions you can usually eliminate two options at once, even if you cannot recall the year.

Worked problem 1: a statement question

Statements: (1) The Thirty-fifth Amendment inserted Article 2A. (2) The Thirty-sixth Amendment retained Article 2A and added Article 371F. Working: statement 1 is true. Statement 2 is false because the Thirty-sixth Amendment omitted Article 2A. So only statement 1 is correct.

Worked problem 2: the reused Schedule

Question: why is it wrong to say the Tenth Schedule has always been about defection? Working: the first Tenth Schedule of 1974 set out the terms of Sikkim's association. It was omitted in 1975. The present Tenth Schedule dates from 1985 and concerns disqualification for defection. The two share a number but nothing else.

Worked problem 3: assertion and reason

Assertion: the Constitution of India did not apply to Sikkim before 1974. Reason: Sikkim was a protectorate with its own ruler. Working: both are true and the reason explains the assertion. A protectorate lies outside the constitutional structure.

Protectorate: treaty, outside the Constitution. Associate state: 35th Amendment, Article 2A, old Tenth Schedule. State: 36th Amendment, First Schedule, Article 371F.

Key takeaways: each status had its own legal base. The Thirty-sixth Amendment removed what the Thirty-fifth added. The Tenth Schedule of 1974 and that of 1985 are unrelated.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Statements: (1) Article 2A was inserted by the Thirty-fifth Amendment. (2) Article 2A continues in the Constitution today.

    1. 2 only
    2. Both 1 and 2
    3. 1 only
    4. Neither 1 nor 2
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Article 2A was inserted in 1974 and omitted in 1975.

  2. 2. Assertion (A): The Tenth Schedule added in 1974 and the one added in 1985 deal with the same subject. Reason (R): Both were inserted by the Thirty-fifth Amendment.

    1. A is true, but R is false
    2. Both A and R are false
    3. A is false, but R is true
    4. Both A and R are true, and R explains A
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The 1974 Schedule set out the terms of Sikkim's association; the 1985 one, added by the Fifty-second Amendment, concerns defection. Both statements are false.

  3. 3. Which feature belongs to a protectorate, not to a state?

    1. The Constitution of India did not apply
    2. Listed in the First Schedule
    3. Governor appointed by the President
    4. Article 371F applies
    Show answer

    Answer: A. A protectorate stood outside the Constitution.

  4. 4. The Thirty-sixth Amendment did all of the following EXCEPT:

    1. add Article 371F
    2. omit the old Tenth Schedule
    3. list Sikkim as a state in the First Schedule
    4. retain Article 2A
    Show answer

    Answer: D. It omitted Article 2A, so it did not retain it.

  5. 5. Which pair is correctly matched?

    1. Thirty-sixth Amendment - 1950
    2. Protectorate treaty - 1975
    3. Article 371F - 1974
    4. Government of Sikkim Act - 1974
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The Act belongs to 1974. The treaty is 1950, the Thirty-sixth Amendment and Article 371F are 1975.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery