| Feature | Protectorate (1950) | Associate state (1974) | State (1975) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ruler or head | Chogyal | Chogyal as constitutional head | Governor appointed by the President |
| Constitution of India applies | No | Only through the terms of association | Yes, fully, with Article 371F |
| Defence and external affairs | India | India | Union subjects, as for any state |
| Constitutional text | Treaty | Article 2A, Tenth Schedule | Article 371F, First Schedule |
Associate state and state
-
Associate state
- Article 2A and old Tenth Schedule
- Joined by terms of association
- Not in the First Schedule as a state
-
State
- Article 371F
- Listed in the First Schedule
- Fully under the Constitution
Protectorate: treaty, outside the Constitution. Associate state: 35th Amendment, Article 2A, old Tenth Schedule. State: 36th Amendment, First Schedule, Article 371F.
Key takeaways: each status had its own legal base. The Thirty-sixth Amendment removed what the Thirty-fifth added. The Tenth Schedule of 1974 and that of 1985 are unrelated.