Three statuses compared
FeatureProtectorate (1950)Associate state (1974)State (1975)
Ruler or headChogyalChogyal as constitutional headGovernor appointed by the President
Constitution of India appliesNoOnly through the terms of associationYes, fully, with Article 371F
Defence and external affairsIndiaIndiaUnion subjects, as for any state
Constitutional textTreatyArticle 2A, Tenth ScheduleArticle 371F, First Schedule

Associate state and state

  • Associate state
    • Article 2A and old Tenth Schedule
    • Joined by terms of association
    • Not in the First Schedule as a state
  • State
    • Article 371F
    • Listed in the First Schedule
    • Fully under the Constitution
Why the numbering changed

Protectorate: treaty, outside the Constitution. Associate state: 35th Amendment, Article 2A, old Tenth Schedule. State: 36th Amendment, First Schedule, Article 371F.

Key takeaways: each status had its own legal base. The Thirty-sixth Amendment removed what the Thirty-fifth added. The Tenth Schedule of 1974 and that of 1985 are unrelated.