- Practice
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
The state executive: match the article and spot the trap
Match each executive office to its article, and avoid the usual traps about who appoints, who removes and who is answerable.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Questions on the state executive are mostly 'match the article' or 'who does what'. The article numbers sit close together (153 to 167), so they blur. This lesson gives you a method for sorting them and shows the traps that catch careless candidates.
A number ladder
| Article | Subject |
|---|---|
| 153 | There shall be a Governor for each state |
| 154 | Executive power of the state vested in the Governor |
| 155 | Appointment of the Governor by the President |
| 156 | Term of office: pleasure of the President, normally five years |
| 163 | Council of Ministers to aid and advise the Governor |
| 164 | Chief Minister appointed by the Governor; other ministers on his advice |
| 165 | Advocate General |
| 174 | Sessions of the Assembly; Governor summons and dissolves |
| 213 | Governor's power to issue ordinances when the Assembly is not in session |
Order to remember the ladder
- 153 Exists
- 154 Powers vested
- 155 Appointed
- 156 Term
- 163 Advised
- 164 Ministers
Say it as a sentence: exists, vested, appointed, term, advised, ministers gives 153, 154, 155, 156, 163, 164.
Trap 1: who removes the Governor
Options often say the Chief Minister or the Assembly removes the Governor. The Governor holds office during the pleasure of the President. No state authority can remove the Governor. The Governor may resign or be transferred by the President.
Trap 2: the Governor's discretion
Students think the Governor decides everything. In truth the Governor acts on ministerial advice except where the Constitution allows discretion. For Sikkim, Article 371F gives a special responsibility to the Governor for peace and for equitable arrangements that help all sections of the people. This is one of the few places where the Governor has a duty independent of the ministers' advice. In an exam, treat it as a particular feature of Sikkim.
Trap 3: the ordinance
An ordinance made under Article 213 is a temporary law. It must be placed before the Assembly when it meets and ceases to operate at the end of six weeks from the date the Assembly reassembles, unless it is passed or withdrawn earlier. Candidates swap this with the six-month gap between sessions. These are different rules.
Trap 4: collective against individual
The Council of Ministers is collectively responsible, so if the Assembly passes a no-confidence motion, the whole Council resigns. A single minister can still be dropped by the Chief Minister for his or her own failure, but the question 'to whom is the Council collectively responsible?' has only one answer: the Legislative Assembly.
Worked example 1: match the article
Question: the Advocate General of a state is provided for in (a) Article 163 (b) Article 164 (c) Article 165 (d) Article 213. Working: 163 is advice by ministers, 164 is the Chief Minister, 213 is ordinances. 165 deals with the Advocate General. Answer: (c).
Worked example 2: ordinance time limit
Question: the Assembly reassembles on 1 March and an ordinance has not been passed or withdrawn. When does it cease to operate? Working: six weeks is forty-two days. Counting from 1 March, thirty days take us to 31 March and twelve more days to 12 April. The ordinance ceases at the end of that six-week period, around 12 April, unless the Assembly disapproves it earlier.
Worked example 3: who answers
Question: 'The Chief Minister of Sikkim is directly responsible to (a) the President (b) the Governor alone (c) the Legislative Assembly (d) the High Court.' Working: in the parliamentary system the executive answers to the elected house. Answer: (c).
Exists 153, vested 154, appointed 155, term 156, advised 163, ministers 164, Advocate General 165, ordinances 213.
Key takeaways: learn the ladder as a sentence, remember that the Governor is removed only by the President's pleasure, and keep the six-week ordinance rule apart from the six-month gap between sessions.
Check your understanding
-
1. The Advocate General is provided for in:
- Article 165
- Article 153
- Article 163
- Article 213
Show answer
Answer: A. Article 165 provides for the Advocate General of a state.
-
2. The Governor's power to issue ordinances is in:
- Article 164
- Article 165
- Article 174
- Article 213
Show answer
Answer: D. Article 213 gives the Governor the ordinance-making power when the Assembly is not in session.
-
3. An ordinance ceases to operate, if not approved, after the Assembly reassembles, within:
- six days
- six months
- six weeks
- one year
Show answer
Answer: C. It ceases at the end of six weeks from reassembly of the Assembly unless disapproved earlier.
-
4. A Governor holds office:
- during the pleasure of the Chief Minister
- during the pleasure of the President
- for a fixed term, removable only by the Assembly
- as long as the High Court allows
Show answer
Answer: B. Article 156 says the Governor holds office during the pleasure of the President.
-
5. Article 164 deals with:
- the Advocate General
- the Chief Minister and other ministers
- the Speaker
- the High Court
Show answer
Answer: B. Article 164 provides that the Chief Minister is appointed by the Governor and other ministers on the Chief Minister's advice.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.