- Practice
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
Statement and conclusion questions: what definitely follows
Decide which conclusions follow from given statements by drawing the least-overlap picture and asking whether any picture breaks the conclusion; ignore real-world knowledge.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
In a statement-and-conclusion question you get two or three statements and some conclusions. The task is to decide which conclusions follow. 'Follow' has a strict meaning: the conclusion must be true in every possible picture that fits the statements. A conclusion that is merely possible, or true in the real world, does not follow. This lesson gives a drawing method and the traps to avoid.
Treat the statements as true
Take the statements as given, even when they are absurd. If a statement says 'All cats are dogs', accept it for the question and ask only what it leads to. Your knowledge of the world must not decide the answer; the statements alone must.
Three picture rules
| Statement | Picture | What you can say for sure |
|---|---|---|
| All A are B | Circle A entirely inside circle B | Some B are A; but NOT 'all B are A' |
| Some A are B | Circles overlap at least a little | Some B are A |
| No A is B | Two separate circles | No B is A |
The break test
- Draw the picture so that the statements hold with as little overlap as possible.
- Try to place things so that the conclusion is false.
- If you can, the conclusion does not follow. If you cannot, it follows.
Worked example 1: Rekha tests two conclusions
Statements: All pens are tools. Some tools are metal. Conclusions: I. Some pens are metal. II. Some tools are pens.
- Step 1: draw pens inside tools. Draw metal overlapping tools, but put the overlap in the part of tools outside the pens.
- Step 2: both statements hold in this picture, yet no pen is metal. So conclusion I can be broken: it does not follow.
- Step 3: conclusion II: because all pens are tools, any pen is a tool. In every picture, some tools are pens (taking the groups as non-empty, as such questions do). It follows.
- Result: only II follows.
Worked example 2: Salim and the 'all' trap
Statements: Some students prefer night study. All who prefer night study feel sleepy in the morning. Conclusions: I. Some students feel sleepy in the morning. II. All students feel sleepy in the morning.
- Step 1: the students who prefer night study exist (statement 1) and all of them feel sleepy (statement 2). So at least one student feels sleepy.
- Step 2: conclusion I follows in every picture.
- Step 3: for II, draw some students outside the night-study group, and nothing forces them to be sleepy. The picture holds, so II is broken.
- Result: only I follows. 'Some' in the statement cannot become 'all' in the conclusion.
Worked example 3: ignoring real life
Statements: All cats are dogs. All dogs are birds. Conclusion: All cats are birds. In reality none of this is true, but the picture is circle cats inside circle dogs inside circle birds. So cats are inside birds, and the conclusion follows. Only the statements count.
Traps
- Reversing 'All A are B' into 'All B are A'. It does not follow.
- Turning 'some' into 'all'.
- Using real-world facts to accept or reject a conclusion.
- Choosing a conclusion because it 'seems likely'. Likely is not definite.
A conclusion follows only if no picture that fits the statements can break it.
Key takeaways
- Accept the statements as true and use only them.
- Draw least-overlap pictures and try to break each conclusion.
- 'All A are B' does not give 'All B are A'.
- 'Some' never becomes 'all'.
Check your understanding
-
1. Statement: All books are objects. Which conclusion follows?
- All objects are books
- Some objects are books
- No object is a book
- Some books are not objects
Show answer
Answer: B. Books lie inside objects, so there are objects that are books. The reverse, 'all objects are books', does not follow.
-
2. Statement: Some doctors are teachers. Which conclusion follows?
- All doctors are teachers
- All teachers are doctors
- No teacher is a doctor
- Some teachers are doctors
Show answer
Answer: D. 'Some doctors are teachers' means the circles overlap, so some teachers are doctors. The 'all' conclusions do not follow.
-
3. Statements: All A are B. All B are C. Which conclusion follows?
- All A are C
- All C are A
- Some C are not B
- No A is C
Show answer
Answer: A. A lies inside B and B lies inside C, so A lies inside C. The reverse does not follow.
-
4. A statement is false in real life. How should it be treated?
- As false, so the question is invalid
- As a reason to skip the question
- As true, for the purpose of the question
- As true only if it seems likely
Show answer
Answer: C. Such questions test reasoning from the given statements. Your outside knowledge is not allowed to decide the answer.
-
5. Statements: Some pens are red. All red things are costly. Which conclusion follows?
- All pens are costly
- No pen is costly
- All costly things are pens
- Some pens are costly
Show answer
Answer: D. The red pens are costly, so some pens are costly. 'All pens' goes too far, because other pens need not be red.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.