- Advanced
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Constitutional status and the making of the state: what each change meant
Read the changes from Presidency to Part A state to Tamil Nadu in terms of legal power: who decides boundaries and names, and what Parliament can and cannot do.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
At this level the question is not only what happened but under what power it happened. Examiners ask who may alter a state's area or name, whether a state's consent is required, and how such laws differ from constitutional amendments. This lesson reads the formation story through those powers.
Articles 3 and 4: the power over states
Article 3 allows Parliament, by law, to form a new state, increase or reduce the area of a state, alter its boundaries and alter its name. A bill for this purpose can be introduced only on the recommendation of the President, and if it affects the area, boundaries or name of a state, the President refers it to that state's legislature for its views within a stated time. The President and Parliament are not bound by those views. Article 4 says that a law made under Article 3 is not to be treated as an amendment of the Constitution under Article 368, so it needs only a simple majority.
| Question | Answer |
|---|---|
| Who can rename a state? | Parliament, by ordinary law under Article 3 |
| Must the state legislature agree? | It is consulted, but its view is not binding |
| Special majority needed? | No, a simple majority is enough because of Article 4 |
| Who must recommend the bill? | The President |
| Is it an Article 368 amendment? | No |
How the renaming of Madras State was done in law
- President's recommendation Needed before such a bill is introduced
- State's views The state legislature may be asked for views
- Parliament passes an Act Simple majority
- Name takes effect 14 January 1969
Status in 1950 and the meaning of Part A
The Constitution as adopted divided states into Parts A, B and C. Madras was a Part A state: a former British province with an elected legislature and a Governor, in the same class as other major states. Part B states were former princely states or unions, and Part C states were smaller territories under closer control of the Centre. The classification was removed by the 1956 reorganisation, which left only states and Union Territories.
Why 1953 and 1956 differ
The 1953 separation of Andhra State was achieved by a special law for that purpose. The 1956 changes were wider: the States Reorganisation Act and an accompanying constitutional amendment changed the classification and redrew many borders at once. Hence it is correct to say that 1953 produced one new state from Madras State, while 1956 redrew the whole country. Tamil Nadu's area, as a result, became mainly the Tamil speaking region.
Worked example 1: statement question
Question: statements: (i) Parliament can rename a state by ordinary law. (ii) The state legislature's disagreement stops the renaming. (iii) A law under Article 3 is an amendment under Article 368. Which are correct? Working: (i) is correct. (ii) is wrong, because the views are not binding. (iii) is wrong because of Article 4. Only (i) is correct.
Worked example 2: assertion and reason
Assertion: the renaming of Madras State did not need a two-thirds majority. Reason: laws under Article 3 are not constitutional amendments under Article 368. Working: the assertion is true. The reason is true and explains it, through Article 4. So both are true and the reason is the correct explanation.
Worked example 3: sequence with a gap
Question: if X is the number of years between the start of the Constitution and the renaming, and Y between the reorganisation and the renaming, find X minus Y. Working: X is 1969 minus 1950, which is 19. Y is 1969 minus 1956, which is 13. X minus Y is 6, which is the gap between 1950 and 1956.
Article 3: Parliament renames and redraws. Article 4: not an Article 368 amendment. Views of the state: asked, not binding.
Key takeaways: Parliament holds the power over names and borders, the President's recommendation is required, the state is consulted but cannot veto, and Article 4 removes the special majority.
Check your understanding
-
1. A bill under Article 3 to rename a state is introduced:
- Only on the recommendation of the President
- By the state Governor alone
- Only after a referendum in the state
- Only by the Chief Minister
Show answer
Answer: A. Article 3 requires the President's recommendation.
-
2. The views of the state legislature on such a bill are:
- Binding on Parliament
- Obtained, but not binding on Parliament
- Never asked
- Decisive if two-thirds agree
Show answer
Answer: B. The President refers the bill to the state for its views, which Parliament may disregard.
-
3. The special two-thirds majority is not needed for the renaming because:
- Article 368 does not exist
- The Governor may overrule it
- Parliament acts in a joint sitting
- Article 4 says such laws are not Article 368 amendments
Show answer
Answer: D. Article 4 ends the need for the Article 368 procedure.
-
4. Madras in 1950 was a state of which class?
- Part A
- Part B
- Part C
- Part D
Show answer
Answer: A. Madras was among the Part A states.
-
5. X is the years between 1950 and 1969, Y between 1953 and 1969. X minus Y is:
- 16
- 19
- 3
- 13
Show answer
Answer: C. 19 minus 16 is 3, the gap between 1950 and 1953.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.