- Practice
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
Local government: tiers, amendments and the commissions
Fix the tiers, schedules, amendments and commissions of rural and urban local government, and meet the typical trap statements.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Local government questions mix numbers: 73 and 74, 11 and 12, 243 with a letter, five years. A table and a few memory hooks will make them manageable.
The big comparison
| Point | Rural (panchayats) | Urban (municipalities) |
|---|---|---|
| Amendment | 73rd, in force 24 April 1993 | 74th, in force 1 June 1993 |
| Part of Constitution | Part IX | Part IXA |
| Schedule of subjects | Eleventh Schedule, 29 subjects | Twelfth Schedule, 18 subjects |
| Tamil Nadu law for rural bodies | Tamil Nadu Panchayats Act, 1994 | Separate state laws for corporations and municipalities |
| Bodies in Tamil Nadu | Village Panchayat, Panchayat Union, District Panchayat | Municipal Corporation, Municipality, Town Panchayat |
| Term | Five years (Article 243E) | Five years |
| Election body | State Election Commission (243K) | State Election Commission (243ZA) |
| Finance | State Finance Commission (243I) every five years | Same commission serves (243Y) |
Where to put each fact
-
Rural
- 73rd Amendment
- Part IX
- Eleventh Schedule
- Gram Sabha
-
Urban
- 74th Amendment
- Part IXA
- Twelfth Schedule
- Ward committees in big cities
Typical traps
- Trap: the 74th Amendment is on panchayats. No; the 73rd.
- Trap: Eleventh Schedule for municipalities. No; that is for panchayats.
- Trap: the Election Commission of India conducts village panchayat polls. No; the State Election Commission.
- Trap: Tamil Nadu has a two-tier rural system. It has three tiers.
- Trap: a panchayat dissolved early may stay without elections for a year. The election must be held within six months.
- Trap: the Gram Sabha is a body of elected members only. It is made of all the registered voters of the village.
Extra points worth knowing
The Constitution requires reservation of seats for Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes in proportion to their population, and not less than one-third of the seats for women (Article 243D). A District Planning Committee is provided under Article 243ZD to join the plans of panchayats and municipalities in a district.
Worked example 1: sort
Question: sort these into rural or urban: Eleventh Schedule, Part IXA, Gram Sabha, Municipal Corporation. Working: Eleventh Schedule is rural. Part IXA is urban. Gram Sabha is rural. Municipal Corporation is urban.
Worked example 2: dissolution
Question: a panchayat is dissolved on 1 March. By what date must a fresh election be held? Working: within six months, so before 1 September.
Worked example 3: counting subjects
Question: how many more subjects are in the Eleventh Schedule than the Twelfth? Working: 29 minus 18 is 11.
Worked example 4: tier count
Question: how many tiers of rural local government does Tamil Nadu have, and name the middle one. Working: three; the middle is the Panchayat Union.
Worked example 5: assertion check
Question: a statement says that panchayat elections in Tamil Nadu are conducted by the Election Commission of India because it conducts the election to the Assembly. Is this correct? Working: the first part is true for the Assembly under Article 324, but the conclusion is false. Panchayat and municipal elections are conducted by the State Election Commission. Be careful when a true fact is used to support a false claim.
A revision routine
Copy the big comparison table on to one page and cover one column at a time. Say the rural column, then check, then the urban column. Do this on three separate days. The facts that keep failing, usually the Schedule numbers or the amendment numbers, should be written on a card and revised each morning. This simple repetition works better than reading the lesson many times.
73rd, Part IX, Eleventh Schedule, 29: villages. 74th, Part IXA, Twelfth Schedule, 18: towns.
Key takeaways: use the table to sort every fact into rural or urban, remember that the State Election Commission runs local polls, and that the maximum delay after dissolution is six months.
Check your understanding
-
1. The Twelfth Schedule deals with:
- Panchayats
- Municipalities
- Languages
- Land reform
Show answer
Answer: B. The Twelfth Schedule lists 18 subjects for urban bodies.
-
2. How many subjects are in the Eleventh Schedule?
- 29
- 18
- 20
- 32
Show answer
Answer: A. The Eleventh Schedule lists 29 subjects for panchayats.
-
3. Which commission is formed every five years to review local body finance?
- State Election Commission
- Public Service Commission
- State Finance Commission
- Law Commission
Show answer
Answer: C. Article 243I.
-
4. Fresh elections after early dissolution of a panchayat must be held within:
- Six months
- One year
- Three years
- Two months
Show answer
Answer: A. Article 243E.
-
5. Which pair is correctly matched?
- Part IX - municipalities
- 73rd Amendment - municipalities
- Twelfth Schedule - panchayats
- Part IXA - municipalities
Show answer
Answer: D. Part IXA came with the 74th Amendment and deals with urban bodies.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.