- Practice
- About 16 min
- 5 practice questions
Centre-State relations, emergencies and amendment
Explain legislative, administrative and financial relations between the Centre and States, the official language provisions, the three kinds of emergency, and how the Constitution is amended.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Describe the three lists of the Seventh Schedule and what happens in a conflict.
- Name the commissions that studied Centre-State relations.
- Recall the official language provisions and the classical languages named in the textbook.
- Compare the three emergencies (Articles 352, 356, 360).
- Explain the procedure and types of amendment under Article 368.
India is a federal country, so the Constitution must say clearly what the Union does, what the States do, what happens in a crisis, and how the rules themselves can be changed. This lesson brings those provisions together.
Centre-State relations
Legislative relations. Parliament can make laws for the whole or any part of India, including Union Territories. The Seventh Schedule has three lists. Originally they had 97 (Union), 66 (State) and 47 (Concurrent) items; the textbook gives the present counts as 100, 61 and 52 (counts change whenever the lists are amended). Parliament alone legislates on the Union List and the State Legislature on the State List; both can legislate on the Concurrent List, but if their laws conflict, the law of Parliament prevails. The 42nd Amendment, 1976 moved five subjects from the State List to the Concurrent List: education, forests, weights and measures, protection of wild animals and birds, and administration of justice (constitution and organisation of courts other than the Supreme Court and High Courts).
Administrative relations. A State's executive power covers only its own territory and subjects. The Union has executive power over matters on which Parliament alone makes laws and over rights given by treaties and agreements. Financial relations are in Articles 268-293, Part XII. Both levels levy taxes; some taxes collected by the Centre are shared with the States on the recommendation of the Finance Commission (Article 280), appointed by the President.
- Rajamannar Committee (1969): three members, appointed by the Tamil Nadu Government under Dr. P.V. Rajamannar.
- Sarkaria Commission (1983): appointed by Prime Minister Indira Gandhi; the textbook says 180 of its 247 recommendations were implemented.
- National Commission to Review the Working of the Constitution (2000): headed by M.N. Venkatachaliah.
- Punchhi Commission (April 2007): three members, headed by former Chief Justice M.M. Punchhi, on the roles of different levels of government.
Official language
Part XVII, Articles 343 to 351 deal with the official language. The Eighth Schedule first recognised 14 languages; it now lists 22. In 2004 the Government of India created a category of classical languages. The textbook names the first six: Tamil (2004), Sanskrit (2005), Telugu (2008), Kannada (2008), Malayalam (2013) and Odia (2014). More languages have been given the status since the book was printed.
Emergency provisions
Three kinds of emergency
-
National (Art. 352)
- War, external aggression or armed rebellion, or imminent threat
- War/aggression: 'external'; armed rebellion: 'internal'
- Declared in 1962, 1971 and 1975
-
State / President's Rule (Art. 356)
- State government cannot be carried on as per the Constitution (on the Governor's report)
- Beyond one year only with a National Emergency in force and the Election Commission certifying difficulty in holding elections
- Maximum three years; first imposed in Punjab, 1951
-
Financial (Art. 360)
- Financial stability or credit of India in danger
- Salaries, even of Supreme Court and High Court judges, can be cut
- Never declared so far
Amendment of the Constitution
Article 368 in Part XX gives Parliament the power to amend the Constitution. A Bill can be introduced in either House of Parliament (not in a State Legislature). It must pass each House by a majority of the total membership and by two-thirds of members present and voting; the President must then give assent. The textbook lists three ways: by simple majority of Parliament, by special majority, and by special majority plus ratification by at least half of the State Legislatures (strictly, simple-majority changes are made under other Articles, outside Article 368). The 42nd Amendment is called the 'mini Constitution' because of how much it changed.
352 - National; 356 - State (President's Rule); 360 - Financial; 368 - Amendment; 280 - Finance Commission.
Worked example 1: whose law prevails? (made-up case)
Case: A State law on forest protection says one thing; a later Parliament law on the same subject says another. Reasoning: Step 1 - forests moved to the Concurrent List in 1976. Step 2 - on a Concurrent subject both may legislate, but in a conflict Parliament's law prevails. Answer: The Parliament law prevails to the extent of the conflict.
Worked example 2: does the amendment pass? (made-up numbers)
Case: A House has a total membership of 500. On the day of voting 420 are present and vote: 300 for, 120 against. Working: Condition 1 - majority of total membership: more than 500 / 2 = 250; 300 > 250, met. Condition 2 - two-thirds of present and voting: 2/3 x 420 = 280; 300 > 280, met. Answer: It passes this House. (Had only 270 voted for, condition 2 would fail since 270 < 280.)
Key takeaways: The Seventh Schedule divides subjects into Union, State and Concurrent Lists, and Parliament's law prevails in a Concurrent conflict. Financial relations are in Articles 268-293, with the Finance Commission under Article 280. Rajamannar, Sarkaria and Punchhi studied Centre-State relations. Part XVII covers official language; 22 languages are in the Eighth Schedule. Emergencies: 352 national, 356 state, 360 financial. Article 368 sets the amendment procedure with a special majority.
Check your understanding
-
1. On a subject in the Concurrent List, if a State law conflicts with a law of Parliament:
- the State law prevails
- both laws are cancelled
- the Governor decides
- the law of Parliament prevails
Show answer
Answer: D. Both may legislate on Concurrent subjects, but in case of conflict the law made by Parliament prevails.
-
2. Which committee on Centre-State relations was appointed by the Tamil Nadu Government in 1969?
- Rajamannar Committee
- Sarkaria Commission
- Punchhi Commission
- Swaran Singh Committee
Show answer
Answer: A. The Tamil Nadu Government appointed the three-member Rajamannar Committee in 1969. Sarkaria (1983) and Punchhi (2007) were set up by the Union Government.
-
3. Under which Article can a Financial Emergency be declared?
- Article 352
- Article 356
- Article 360
- Article 368
Show answer
Answer: C. Article 360 provides for Financial Emergency; it has never been declared. 352 is National Emergency, 356 President's Rule, 368 amendment.
-
4. Which subject was NOT moved from the State List to the Concurrent List by the 42nd Amendment?
- Education
- Police
- Forests
- Weights and measures
Show answer
Answer: B. The five subjects moved were education, forests, weights and measures, protection of wild animals and birds, and administration of justice. Police stayed in the State List.
-
5. A House of 540 members votes on an amendment Bill: 450 present and voting, 290 in favour. Under the special majority rule, the Bill:
- passes, since 290 is more than half of 540
- passes, since 290 is more than half of 450
- fails, since 290 is less than two-thirds of 450 (300)
- fails, since 290 is less than two-thirds of 540 (360)
Show answer
Answer: C. Both conditions are needed. 290 > 270 (half of 540), so the first is met. Two-thirds of 450 = 300, and 290 < 300, so the second fails. The Bill fails.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.