- Practice
- About 16 min
- 5 practice questions
The League of Nations: structure, work and failure
Describe how the League of Nations was formed, its five bodies and objectives, the disputes it settled, the violations it could not stop, and why it failed.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Name the five bodies of the League of Nations and say what each did.
- State the League's two objectives and its method of sanctions.
- Describe its three successes and the violations it failed to stop.
- Explain the causes of its failure.
For the first time, countries tried to keep world peace through a permanent international body. The League of Nations did not prevent the next world war, but it was the forerunner of the United Nations, and studying why it failed explains much about the 1930s.
Formation and structure
The League's Covenant (its constitution) was worked out at the Paris Peace Conference and included in each peace treaty, largely due to pressure from President Wilson; the ideas of Britain and America shaped it. The League was formed in 1920. Its secretariat was at Geneva, and its first Secretary General was Sir Eric Drummond of Britain. Every member had one vote and decisions had to be unanimous, so even small nations in effect had a veto.
The League of Nations (1920)
-
Assembly
- Every member country represented
-
Council
- The executive
- Permanent members at first: Britain, France, Italy, Japan, the USA
-
Secretariat
- At Geneva
- First Secretary General: Sir Eric Drummond (Britain)
-
Permanent Court of Justice
- At The Hague
- Fifteen judges
-
International Labour Organisation
- A secretariat and a general conference
- Four representatives from each country
Note: the USA was named a permanent member of the Council but never joined the League, so its seat stayed empty.
Objectives
The League had a two-fold objective: to avoid war and maintain peace, and to promote international cooperation in economic and social affairs. It would act as conciliator and arbitrator, settling disputes early. If war broke out anyway, members were to apply sanctions to the aggressor - economic first, then military. This idea that all members act together against an aggressor is called collective security.
From the start three great powers were missing: the USA (never joined), Germany (defeated) and Russia. Germany joined in 1926 and Russia in 1934; Germany resigned in 1933 and Russia was expelled in 1939.
Successes, 1920-1925
| Year | Dispute | League's decision |
|---|---|---|
| 1920 | Sweden and Finland over the Aaland Islands | The islands went to Finland |
| 1921 | Poland and Germany over the frontier in Upper Silesia | Frontier settled successfully |
| 1925 | Greece invaded Bulgaria | Ceasefire ordered; Greece blamed and made to pay reparations |
By the Locarno Treaty (1925), Germany, France, Belgium, Britain and Italy guaranteed peace in western Europe; afterwards Germany joined the League with a permanent Council seat. Two years later the USA and Russia began to take part in its non-political work.
Violations it could not stop
- Disarmament: a commission set up in 1925 led to a conference only in February 1932. Germany's demand for equality of arms with France was rejected, and Hitler withdrew Germany from the conference and the League.
- Manchuria: Japan attacked Manchuria in September 1931; when the League condemned it, Japan resigned.
- Ethiopia: when Italy attacked Ethiopia the League applied sanctions, and Italy resigned in 1937.
- Passive witness: the League took no part in the crises over the Rhineland, Austria, Czechoslovakia and Poland.
- Last act: in December 1939 it expelled Russia for attacking Finland. The Assembly never met again, and the League was dissolved in 1946.
Causes of failure
- It looked like an organisation of the victors of the First World War.
- It had no military force of its own, so it could not enforce its decisions.
- Its founders underestimated the power of nationalism.
- Collective security could not be applied in practice.
- When Italy, Japan and Germany, ruled by dictators, defied it, only Britain and France were major powers able to act.
The League could judge but not enforce: without an army, without the USA, and needing unanimous votes, it relied on members who would not act together.
Worked example 1: success or failure?
Question: Classify the Aaland Islands case and the Manchurian crisis. Working: In 1920 both Sweden and Finland accepted the League's ruling, so the dispute ended peacefully. In 1931 Japan ignored the League's condemnation and left, so the aggression went unpunished. Answer: Aaland Islands - success; Manchuria - failure. Note the pattern: the League worked with smaller states but not against determined great powers.
Worked example 2: why did unanimity weaken the League?
Question: Suppose the Council has members P, Q, R, S and T, and four vote for sanctions while one votes against. What happens? Working: Every decision had to be unanimous. Four out of five is not unanimous. Answer: No decision is taken; one member's 'no' acts as a veto. This made quick, firm action very hard.
Key takeaways: Formed in 1920 with five bodies (Assembly, Council, Secretariat at Geneva, Permanent Court of Justice at The Hague, ILO), the League aimed to prevent war and promote cooperation through arbitration and sanctions. It settled the Aaland Islands (1920), Upper Silesia and Greece-Bulgaria (1925) disputes, but failed against Japan (1931), Italy and Germany. Lacking an army, the USA's membership and real collective security, it was dissolved in 1946.
Check your understanding
-
1. Where was the secretariat of the League of Nations located?
- The Hague
- Paris
- New York
- Geneva
Show answer
Answer: D. The secretariat was at Geneva. The Permanent Court of Justice sat at The Hague, and the Covenant was drawn up at the Paris Peace Conference.
-
2. The first Secretary General of the League, Sir Eric Drummond, came from
- Britain
- France
- the USA
- the Netherlands
Show answer
Answer: A. Sir Eric Drummond, the first Secretary General, was from Britain.
-
3. Which dispute did the League settle by awarding the islands to Finland?
- Upper Silesia
- Manchuria
- The Aaland Islands
- Corfu
Show answer
Answer: C. In 1920 Sweden and Finland disputed the Aaland Islands; the League ruled that they should go to Finland.
-
4. Why was Russia expelled from the League in December 1939?
- For refusing to pay its fees
- For attacking Finland
- For attacking Manchuria
- For leaving the disarmament conference
Show answer
Answer: B. The League's last decisive action was expelling Russia for its attack on Finland in December 1939. Japan attacked Manchuria; Germany left the disarmament conference.
-
5. Which is NOT given in the chapter as a cause of the League's failure?
- It had no military force of its own
- It was seen as a club of the war's victors
- Its founders underestimated nationalism
- It had too many permanent members from Asia
Show answer
Answer: D. The chapter lists the lack of an army, the image of a victors' organisation, underestimated nationalism and unworkable collective security. Japan was the only Asian permanent member, and this is not given as a cause.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.