- Practice
- About 13 min
- 5 practice questions
The Supreme Court and its jurisdiction
Describe the Supreme Court's origin, composition, appointment and qualifications of judges, and its original, appellate, advisory and miscellaneous jurisdiction and power of judicial review.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain what an integrated and independent judiciary means.
- State how Supreme Court judges are appointed, their qualifications and retirement age.
- Classify cases under original, appellate and advisory jurisdiction.
- Explain judicial review with examples.
The judiciary is the third organ of government. It protects the rights and freedoms of citizens and interprets the laws and the Constitution. India's judiciary is independent of the legislature and executive, and integrated: a single hierarchy of courts for the whole country, with the Supreme Court, the guardian of the Constitution, at the top.
Origin and composition
The Supreme Court at New Delhi was inaugurated on 28 January 1950. It succeeded the Federal Court of India, set up under the Government of India Act, 1935. In 1950 it had 8 judges including the Chief Justice; Parliament has increased the number by law since then. The Court sits permanently at New Delhi, but may also sit elsewhere in India if the Chief Justice decides so with the President's approval.
Judges: appointment, qualifications, tenure
- The Chief Justice and other judges are appointed by the President; for other judges, the President acts in consultation with the collegium headed by the Chief Justice.
- Qualifications: citizen of India, and either a High Court judge for at least 5 years, or a High Court advocate for at least 10 years, or a distinguished jurist in the President's opinion.
- Ad hoc (temporary) judges can also be appointed.
- Judges hold office up to 65 years of age, may resign in writing to the President, and can be removed only by Parliament, through the procedure the Constitution lays down.
Jurisdiction and powers
Jurisdiction of the Supreme Court
-
Original
- Union vs one or more States
- Disputes between States
- Writs to enforce Fundamental Rights
-
Appellate
- Final court of appeal
- Civil, criminal and constitutional cases from High Courts
- With High Court's certificate on a substantial question of law
-
Advisory
- President may refer a question of law or fact of public importance (Art. 143)
-
Miscellaneous
- Its law binds all courts in India
- Makes rules of practice with President's approval
-
Judicial review
- Can declare unconstitutional laws void
Judicial review is the power of the judiciary to declare a law unconstitutional. The Supreme Court uses it in disputes between the Centre and States, to interpret doubtful provisions of the Constitution, to protect Fundamental Rights, and to strike down laws passed by legislatures that are not in accordance with the Constitution.
Original = the case starts in the Supreme Court. Appellate = it comes up from a High Court. Advisory = the President asks for an opinion.
Worked example 1: which jurisdiction? (made-up cases)
Case A: Two States disagree about sharing a river's water and the matter goes straight to the Supreme Court. Case B: A person loses a criminal case in the Madras High Court and appeals to the Supreme Court. Case C: The President asks the Supreme Court for its opinion on whether a proposed law would be constitutional. Reasoning: A begins in the Supreme Court (dispute between States) - original. B comes up from a High Court - appellate. C is a reference by the President - advisory. Answers: original, appellate, advisory.
Worked example 2: is he qualified? (made-up case)
Cases: Mr. Joseph, an Indian citizen, has practised as an advocate in a High Court for 7 years. Ms. Farida, an Indian citizen, has been a High Court judge for 6 years. Reasoning: Joseph - 7 years is less than the 10 years needed as an advocate, and he has not been a judge, so he does not qualify on that test (unless the President considers him a distinguished jurist). Farida - 6 years as a High Court judge is more than the 5 years needed. Answer: Farida is qualified; Joseph is not yet.
Key takeaways: The Supreme Court, inaugurated on 28 January 1950 in succession to the Federal Court, heads an integrated, independent judiciary. Its judges are appointed by the President (with the collegium), need 5 years as a High Court judge or 10 years as an advocate or must be a distinguished jurist, and retire at 65. It has original, appellate, advisory and miscellaneous jurisdiction, and the power of judicial review.
Check your understanding
-
1. The Supreme Court of India succeeded which court?
- The Privy Council
- The Federal Court of India
- The Calcutta High Court
- The Sadar Diwani Adalat
Show answer
Answer: B. The Supreme Court, inaugurated on 28 January 1950, succeeded the Federal Court set up under the Government of India Act, 1935.
-
2. Up to what age do Supreme Court judges hold office?
- 60 years
- 62 years
- 65 years
- 70 years
Show answer
Answer: C. Supreme Court judges hold office until they reach 65 years of age.
-
3. A dispute between the Union Government and a State comes directly to the Supreme Court under its:
- original jurisdiction
- appellate jurisdiction
- advisory jurisdiction
- miscellaneous jurisdiction
Show answer
Answer: A. Cases that begin in the Supreme Court, such as Centre-State disputes, fall under original jurisdiction.
-
4. The power of the judiciary to declare a law unconstitutional is called:
- advisory jurisdiction
- impeachment
- a writ of mandamus
- judicial review
Show answer
Answer: D. Judicial review is the power to examine laws and declare those against the Constitution void.
-
5. How many judges, including the Chief Justice, did the Supreme Court have in 1950?
- 6
- 7
- 8
- 10
Show answer
Answer: C. At the commencement of the Constitution, the Supreme Court had 8 judges including the Chief Justice; Parliament has raised the number since.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.