• Practice
  • About 13 min
  • 5 practice questions

The Chief Minister and the Council of Ministers

Explain why the Chief Minister is the real executive, describe the Chief Minister's powers in relation to ministers, the Governor and the legislature, and the role and size of the State Council of Ministers.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Distinguish the Governor (nominal executive) from the Chief Minister (real executive).
  • List the Chief Minister's powers under three heads.
  • Explain collective responsibility and the 15% limit on ministers.
  • Describe the Cabinet and cabinet committees.

In a parliamentary system the person who holds the formal title is not always the person who runs the government. In a State, the Governor is the nominal executive - the head of the State - while the Chief Minister is the real executive - the head of the government.

Appointment and term

Article 164(1) says the Chief Minister is appointed by the Governor. His term is not fixed: he stays as long as he has the support of a majority of the Legislative Assembly, and must resign if he loses it. Normally he serves the Assembly's five-year term.

Powers of the Chief Minister

The Chief Minister's powers

  • Council of Ministers
    • Recommends who is appointed minister
    • Allocates and reshuffles portfolios
    • Presides over meetings
    • Guides and coordinates all ministers
  • The Governor
    • Advises on appointing the Advocate General
    • State Election Commissioner
    • State PSC, State Planning Commission and State Finance Commission members
  • State Legislature
    • Advises on summoning and proroguing sessions
    • Announces government policy in the House
    • Introduces bills
    • May recommend dissolution of the Assembly

The Council of Ministers

Article 163(1) provides a Council of Ministers with the Chief Minister at its head to aid and advise the Governor, except where he must act in his discretion. Ministers are collectively responsible to the State Legislature (the Legislative Assembly). All ministers must be members of the State Legislature; a non-member must win a seat within six months. If the Assembly passes a no-confidence motion, the whole ministry must resign. Article 164(1A) limits the number of ministers, including the CM, to 15% of the total members of the Legislative Assembly.

  • Frames and implements State policies and decides the legislative programme.
  • Controls financial policy and the tax structure; finalises the Budget (Annual Financial Statement).
  • Makes important appointments of Heads of Departments.
  • Handles disputes with other States.
  • Each minister supervises and coordinates his own department.

The Cabinet, a smaller body of Cabinet Ministers only, is the nucleus of the Council and the real centre of authority. It works through cabinet committees: standing (permanent) and ad hoc (temporary).

Governor = head of the State (nominal). Chief Minister = head of the government (real). Ministers: at most 15% of the Assembly, collectively responsible to it.

Worked example 1: the Tamil Nadu ceiling

Question: The Tamil Nadu Legislative Assembly has 234 elected members. What is the largest Council of Ministers allowed? Working: 15% of 234 = 0.15 x 234 = 35.1. The number cannot exceed 35.1, so the largest whole number allowed is 35, including the Chief Minister. Note: the textbook gives the figure as 36; by the 15% rule the ceiling works out to 35.

Worked example 2: a minister who is not an MLA (made-up case)

Case: On 1 January, Ms. Lakshmi, who is not a member of the State Legislature, is sworn in as a minister. By 15 July she has not won a seat. Working: Six months from 1 January runs to 30 June. 15 July is beyond that. Answer: She cannot continue as minister; she should have secured a seat in the Legislature within six months.

Key takeaways: The Governor is the nominal executive and the Chief Minister the real one. The CM is appointed by the Governor (Art. 164(1)), stays while he has the Assembly's majority, leads the ministers, advises the Governor on key appointments and guides the legislature. The Council of Ministers (Art. 163) is collectively responsible to the Assembly, capped at 15% of its members (Art. 164(1A)), and its Cabinet works through standing and ad hoc committees.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. In a State, the real executive authority is:

    1. the Governor
    2. the Chief Minister and the Council of Ministers
    3. the Speaker
    4. the Chief Justice of the High Court
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The Governor is the nominal head; real executive power lies with the Chief Minister and the Council of Ministers.

  2. 2. The State Council of Ministers is collectively responsible to:

    1. the Governor
    2. the President
    3. the Parliament
    4. the State Legislative Assembly
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Ministers are collectively responsible to the State Legislature (the Legislative Assembly), which can remove them by a no-confidence motion.

  3. 3. Under Article 164(1A), the number of ministers in a State, including the Chief Minister, cannot exceed:

    1. 15% of the total members of the Legislative Assembly
    2. 10% of the Assembly
    3. one-third of the Assembly
    4. one-sixth of the Legislative Council
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Article 164(1A) caps the Council of Ministers at 15% of the total strength of the Legislative Assembly.

  4. 4. If a State has a Legislative Assembly of 200 members, the largest Council of Ministers allowed by the 15% rule is:

    1. 20
    2. 25
    3. 30
    4. 40
    Show answer

    Answer: C. 15% of 200 = 0.15 x 200 = 30, including the Chief Minister.

  5. 5. Cabinet committees that are permanent in nature are called:

    1. ad hoc committees
    2. standing committees
    3. select committees
    4. joint committees
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The textbook names two types: standing (permanent) and ad hoc (temporary).

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery