- Practice
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
What a tax is, why we pay it, and the canons of taxation
Define a tax as a compulsory payment without direct return, explain why governments tax, and apply the canons of equity, certainty, economy, convenience, productivity and elasticity.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Define a tax and explain its main features.
- Give reasons why governments raise taxes.
- Explain six canons of taxation with examples.
The textbook notes that the word 'tax' comes from 'taxation', meaning an estimate. Taxation is the way governments finance their spending by imposing charges on citizens and companies. Its importance grew with the idea of the welfare state, a state that takes responsibility for its people's well-being.
Definition and features
A tax is a compulsory payment to the government without expectation of a direct return or benefit to the taxpayer.
The economist Prof. Seligman gave a similar definition: in his words, as the textbook quotes him, a tax is a compulsory contribution from a person to the government to meet the expenses incurred in the common interest of all, without reference to special benefits conferred. So a tax has three features: it is compulsory; it pays for common purposes; and the taxpayer gets no direct, special benefit in return.
Why taxes?
Taxes pay for economic infrastructure (transport, sanitation, public safety, education, health care), defence, scientific research, culture and the arts, public works and the running of government itself. They also fund welfare such as pensions for the elderly, unemployment benefits and public transport. A government's ability to raise taxes is called its fiscal capacity. When spending exceeds tax revenue, the government borrows and builds up debt, and part of future taxes goes to service that debt.
Canons of taxation
Every tax has advantages and disadvantages, so a country uses a tax system: a collection of different taxes. Since Adam Smith, economists have listed principles, called canons, for a good tax system.
Canons of taxation
-
Equity
- The cardinal principle
- The rich pay more because they have more ability to pay
-
Certainty
- Tax rules announced in advance
- Each taxpayer can work out what they owe
-
Economy
- Simple taxes keep the cost of collection low
- Cost of collecting = taxpayer's cost + collector's cost
-
Convenience
- Collected when the person has money to pay
-
Productivity
- A few taxes that bring in enough revenue, rather than many small ones
-
Elasticity
- Revenue rises automatically as incomes grow
Worked example 1: name the canon
Question: Which canon is followed in each case? (a) The tax on a farmer's crop income is collected after the harvest is sold. (b) The government publishes the tax rules for the year in advance. (c) A tax yields more revenue automatically as people's incomes rise. Reasoning: (a) Collecting when the payer has money: convenience. (b) Known in advance: certainty. (c) Revenue grows with income: elasticity. Answer: (a) convenience, (b) certainty, (c) elasticity.
Worked example 2: the canon of economy (made-up figures)
Question: Tax A raises ₹100 crore and costs ₹2 crore to collect (taxpayers' and collectors' costs together). Tax B raises ₹100 crore but costs ₹15 crore to collect. Find the net revenue of each. Which follows the canon of economy better? Working: A: 100 − 2 = ₹98 crore. B: 100 − 15 = ₹85 crore. Answer: Tax A, because a much smaller share of what it raises is lost in the cost of collection.
Key takeaways: A tax is compulsory, serves common purposes and gives no direct return. Taxes fund infrastructure, welfare and government. A good tax system follows the canons of equity, certainty, economy, convenience, productivity and elasticity.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which feature makes a payment a tax?
- It is voluntary
- It is paid only for a specific service received
- It is compulsory and has no direct return to the payer
- It is paid only by companies
Show answer
Answer: C. A tax is a compulsory payment to the government without expectation of a direct return or benefit.
-
2. Which canon does the textbook call the cardinal principle of taxation?
- Equity
- Certainty
- Elasticity
- Economy
Show answer
Answer: A. All economists agree that equity is the cardinal principle: the rich, who are more able to pay, should pay more.
-
3. A government's ability to raise taxes is called its:
- Monetary policy
- Foreign policy
- Buffer stock
- Fiscal capacity
Show answer
Answer: D. The textbook calls a government's ability to raise taxes its fiscal capacity.
-
4. Choosing a few taxes that raise large revenue, rather than many small ones, follows the canon of:
- Convenience
- Productivity
- Certainty
- Equity
Show answer
Answer: B. The canon of productivity says the government should choose a few taxes that fetch enough revenue.
-
5. A tax raises ₹50 crore and costs ₹5 crore to collect (made-up). What share of the revenue is lost in collection?
- 5%
- 45%
- 10%
- 50%
Show answer
Answer: C. 5 ÷ 50 × 100 = 10 per cent. The lower this share, the better the tax meets the canon of economy.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.