- Practice
- About 16 min
- 5 practice questions
Non-Cooperation, the Swarajists, Simon Commission and the Nehru Report
Understand the programme of the Non-Cooperation Movement and why it was withdrawn after Chauri Chaura, the Swaraj Party and dyarchy, Gandhi's constructive programme, the boycott of the Simon Commission and the Nehru Report.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- List the main points of the non-cooperation programme and explain why Gandhi withdrew it.
- Explain dyarchy and the difference between pro-changers and no-changers.
- Describe the constructive programme, the Simon boycott and the Nehru Report.
Non-cooperation was Gandhi's first all-India movement. Its sudden end divided the Congress, and the years that followed tested how Indians should work against colonial rule: inside the councils, through village work, or through protest.
The Non-Cooperation Movement
The Congress approved non-cooperation at a special session in Calcutta in September 1920, and it was passed at the Nagpur session in December 1920, chaired by Salem C. Vijayaraghavachariar. The programme included:
- Giving up titles and honorary offices
- Not taking part in government functions
- Lawyers suspending practice; disputes settled by private arbitration
- Boycott of government schools by children and parents
- Boycott of the legislatures created by the 1919 Act
- Refusing civil or military posts
- Boycott of foreign goods and spreading Swadeshi
Foreign cloth was burnt in bonfires wherever Gandhi went; thousands left government jobs, students left their studies and lawyers gave up practice. The Prince of Wales's visit was successfully boycotted. In February 1922 Gandhi announced a no-tax campaign at Bardoli.
On 5 February 1922, at Chauri Chaura near Gorakhpur (present-day Uttar Pradesh), a procession provoked by the police turned violent. The outnumbered police shut themselves in the station; the crowd set it on fire and 22 policemen died. Gandhi immediately withdrew the movement, because it had broken his rule of non-violence.
Pro-changers, no-changers and the Swaraj Party
Dyarchy, introduced by the 1919 Act, split provincial powers. Reserved subjects (finance, defence, police, justice, land revenue, irrigation) stayed with the British; transferred subjects (local self-government, education, public health, public works, agriculture, forests, fisheries) went to Indian ministers. It ended with provincial autonomy in 1935.
Two views in the Congress after 1922
-
Pro-changers
- Led by Motilal Nehru and C.R. Das
- Contest elections, enter the councils
- Wreck dyarchy from within
- Formed the Swaraj Party, 1 January 1923
-
No-changers
- Vallabhbhai Patel, C. Rajaji and others
- Continue non-cooperation
- Stay out of the councils
Swarajists won many seats in the Imperial Legislative Assembly and provincial councils and used them to spread nationalist ideas. In Bengal they refused to take charge of transferred subjects. The party declined after C.R. Das died in 1925.
The constructive programme
After Chauri Chaura, Gandhi felt people had to be trained for non-violent struggle. He promoted khadi, Hindu-Muslim unity and the abolition of untouchability, urged Congressmen to train the youth as soldiers of Swaraj, made khaddar compulsory for Congress members, and the All India Spinners' Association was formed.
Boycott of the Simon Commission
On 8 November 1927 Britain announced the Indian Statutory Commission of seven members under Sir John Simon. It had no Indian member, so Indians felt denied the right to shape their own constitution. The Congress, the Muslim League and others boycotted it; everywhere it went it met black flags and the cry 'Go Back Simon'. In a police assault on protesters in Lahore, Lala Lajpat Rai was badly injured and died a few days later.
The Nehru Report, 1928
The boycott brought parties together. An all-party conference in 1928 asked a committee under Motilal Nehru to outline a constitution. The Nehru Report recommended dominion status; joint and mixed electorates; reserved seats for Muslims at the centre and where they were a minority, and for Hindus in the North-West Frontier Province; and fundamental rights with universal adult franchise. Jinnah proposed that one-third of central seats be reserved for Muslims, supported by Tej Bahadur Sapru, but this was defeated; his later Fourteen Points were also rejected. The textbook says Jinnah, once hailed as an ambassador of Hindu-Muslim unity, afterwards changed his stand and began to argue for a separate nation for Muslims.
Chauri Chaura (5 Feb 1922) ended Non-Cooperation; Swarajists entered the councils (1923); the all-white Simon Commission (1927) united Indians in protest; the Nehru Report (1928) asked for dominion status.
Worked example 1: sorting subjects under dyarchy
Question: Under dyarchy, who controlled (a) police, (b) education, (c) land revenue, (d) public health? Answer: (a) British - reserved; (b) Indian ministers - transferred; (c) British - reserved; (d) Indian ministers - transferred. Notice that the British kept money and force (finance, police, revenue), so Indian ministers had responsibility without real power.
Worked example 2: why withdraw a successful movement?
Question: Non-cooperation was succeeding. Why did Gandhi call it off? Answer: For Gandhi, non-violence was the heart of satyagraha, not just a tactic. Chauri Chaura showed that people were not yet trained for it, so he stopped the movement and turned to the constructive programme to prepare them.
Key takeaways: non-cooperation boycotted titles, courts, schools, councils and foreign goods; Chauri Chaura ended it; the Swarajists worked inside the councils; the constructive programme trained people; the Simon boycott and the Nehru Report united Indians, though the communal question stayed unresolved.
Check your understanding
-
1. Who chaired the Nagpur session of the Congress in December 1920?
- Motilal Nehru
- C.R. Das
- Salem C. Vijayaraghavachariar
- Jawaharlal Nehru
Show answer
Answer: C. Salem C. Vijayaraghavachariar presided over the Nagpur session that passed the non-cooperation programme.
-
2. Why did Gandhi withdraw the Non-Cooperation Movement?
- The British accepted all demands
- Violence at Chauri Chaura, where 22 policemen died
- Gandhi fell ill
- The Khilafat was restored
Show answer
Answer: B. The burning of the Chauri Chaura police station on 5 February 1922 broke the rule of non-violence.
-
3. Which was a TRANSFERRED subject under dyarchy?
- Police
- Finance
- Land revenue
- Education
Show answer
Answer: D. Education was transferred to Indian ministers; police, finance and land revenue were reserved for the British.
-
4. Why was the Simon Commission boycotted?
- It had no Indian member
- It proposed independence
- It was led by Gandhi
- It was set up by the Congress
Show answer
Answer: A. It was an all-white commission, so Indians felt denied the right to decide their own constitution.
-
5. Which of these did the Nehru Report recommend?
- Separate electorates for all communities
- Complete independence at once
- Dominion status and universal adult franchise
- One-third of central seats for Muslims
Show answer
Answer: C. It recommended dominion status, joint and mixed electorates, fundamental rights and universal adult franchise. Jinnah's one-third amendment was defeated.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.