- Practice
- About 18 min
- 5 practice questions
Classifying transactions and the effect of wrong classification
Classify mixed lists of expenditure and receipts, explain the reasoning in each case, and work out how treating capital items as revenue (or the reverse) changes profit and the balance sheet.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Classify a mixed list into capital, revenue and deferred revenue expenditure and capital and revenue receipts.
- Give a reason for each classification.
- Work out the effect of a wrong classification on profit and on the balance sheet.
Exam questions usually give a list and ask you to classify each item with a reason. The reason matters as much as the label, because the same word, such as repairs or advertising, can be capital in one case and revenue in another.
A quick decision path
Classifying an item of expenditure
- Is it goods the business deals in? Yes: revenue (purchases)
- Does it acquire an asset or get it ready for use? Yes: capital
- Does it increase capacity or earning power for years? Yes: capital
- Is it large, revenue in nature, benefiting several years? Yes: deferred revenue
- Otherwise Revenue: day-to-day running or maintenance
Worked example 1: a full classification
All names and amounts in the worked examples are made up for practice. Classify the items of Sevvanthi Garments with reasons.
| Item | Class | Reason |
|---|---|---|
| Registration fees and legal fees on buying land | Capital expenditure | Part of the cost of acquiring land |
| Carriage paid on goods purchased | Revenue expenditure | Part of the cost of goods for resale (direct expense) |
| Whitewashing the existing factory | Revenue expenditure | Routine maintenance |
| Repairs to make an old building just bought usable | Capital expenditure | Incurred to bring the asset to usable condition |
| Legal expenses for raising a long-term loan | Capital expenditure | Incurred to obtain long-term finance (as the textbook classifies it) |
| Renewal of factory licence each year | Revenue expenditure | Recurring, keeps the business running |
| Railway siding built into the factory | Capital expenditure | A long-term facility |
| Loss on sale of old furniture | Revenue (charged to profit and loss account) | A loss of the year |
| Carriage on goods sold | Revenue expenditure | Distribution expense |
| Issue of shares | Capital receipt | Money raised from owners |
| Dividend received on shares held | Revenue receipt | Regular income from investment |
Effect of wrong classification
Treating capital expenditure as revenue (for example, debiting a new machine to repairs) charges the whole amount against this year's income: profit is understated and the asset is understated in the balance sheet. Treating revenue expenditure as capital (for example, debiting repairs to machinery) leaves an expense out of the profit and loss account: profit is overstated and the asset is overstated. This is the error of principle met in Unit 9.
Worked example 2: measuring the effect
All names and amounts in the worked examples are made up for practice. Before any correction, Thamarai Stores shows a net profit of ₹1,80,000. Two mistakes are found: (a) ₹50,000 spent on an extension to the shop was debited to repairs account. (b) ₹12,000 paid for repainting the shop (routine) was debited to building account. Ignore depreciation.
Working: (a) a capital item was charged as an expense, so profit is understated by ₹50,000: add it back. (b) a revenue item was capitalised, so profit is overstated by ₹12,000: deduct it. Correct profit = 1,80,000 + 50,000 − 12,000 = ₹2,18,000. Building account: +50,000 − 12,000 = net ₹38,000 higher than shown. Check: the change in profit (2,18,000 − 1,80,000 = 38,000) equals the change in assets (38,000), as it must.
| Mistake | Effect on profit | Effect on asset |
|---|---|---|
| Capital expenditure treated as revenue | Understated | Understated |
| Revenue expenditure treated as capital | Overstated | Overstated |
| Capital receipt treated as revenue receipt | Overstated | Liability or asset misstated |
Key takeaways: classify each item by nature of business, purpose, period of benefit and materiality, and always state the reason. Capital treated as revenue understates profit and assets; revenue treated as capital overstates them. A receipt that is capital must never be counted as profit.
Check your understanding
-
1. Legal fees paid to a lawyer for acquiring land are:
- capital expenditure
- revenue expenditure
- deferred revenue expenditure
- revenue receipt
Show answer
Answer: A. They are part of the cost of acquiring the land, so they are capitalised.
-
2. ₹30,000 spent on a new machine was debited to repairs account. The effect is:
- profit overstated by ₹30,000
- profit understated by ₹30,000
- no effect on profit
- asset overstated by ₹30,000
Show answer
Answer: B. A capital item was charged as an expense, reducing profit by 30,000 that should not have been charged; the machine is also missing from assets.
-
3. Which item is revenue expenditure?
- Pulling down an old building and rebuilding
- Construction of a building
- Repairs to furniture in use
- Purchase of a railway siding
Show answer
Answer: C. Repairs to furniture already in use are maintenance: revenue. The others create or rebuild long-term assets: capital.
-
4. Net profit shown is ₹90,000. It is found that routine repairs of ₹8,000 were debited to machinery account. Ignoring depreciation, the correct profit is:
- ₹98,000
- ₹90,000
- ₹74,000
- ₹82,000
Show answer
Answer: D. Revenue expenditure was capitalised, so profit is overstated by 8,000. Correct profit = 90,000 − 8,000 = ₹82,000.
-
5. Carriage paid on goods purchased for resale is:
- revenue expenditure
- capital expenditure
- deferred revenue expenditure
- capital receipt
Show answer
Answer: A. It is part of the cost of goods traded, a direct revenue expense shown in the trading account.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.