- Practice
- About 16 min
- 5 practice questions
Advantages and limitations of CAS, and manual versus computerised accounting
State the advantages and limitations of a computerised accounting system, explain the audit trail, and compare manual and computerised accounting on nine bases.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- List and explain the advantages of a computerised accounting system.
- List and explain its limitations, and say what an audit trail is.
- Compare manual and computerised accounting basis by basis.
Before a business moves its accounts to computers, its owner should weigh what it gains against what it costs and risks. This lesson sets out both sides as the Tamil Nadu textbook does, then compares the two systems directly.
Advantages of CAS
- Faster processing: computers take far less time than people for the same task.
- Accurate information: each transaction is entered only once, so the errors of repeated posting are avoided.
- Reliability: computers do not get bored or tired, so repetitive work is done well.
- Easy availability of information: data can be given to several users at the same time.
- Up-to-date information: balances are updated automatically as each entry is made.
- Efficiency: better use of time and resources.
- Storage and retrieval: records need a tiny fraction of the space taken by books of account.
- Motivator to employees: trained staff feel more valued.
- Automated document production: trial balance and financial statements are produced at a click.
- MIS reports: real-time management reports help monitor and control the business.
Limitations of CAS
- Heavy cost of installation: hardware must be replaced and software updated from time to time.
- Cost of training: new hardware and software need staff training.
- Fear of unemployment: staff may feel insecure and show less interest.
- Disruption of work: the existing way of working is interrupted while the change is made.
- System failure: a hardware crash interrupts work, worse when there is no backup.
- Time consuming: after a failure, time is lost arranging an alternative and restoring normal work.
- Unanticipated errors not known: a computer cannot use judgement to detect errors no one foresaw.
- Breaches of security: viruses and hacking are dangers, and a person who wrote the program could tamper with records.
- Health dangers: long computer use can cause eye strain, muscle complaints and backache.
Weighing up a computerised accounting system
-
Gains
- Speed and accuracy
- Up-to-date balances
- Little storage space
- Reports at a click
-
Costs and risks
- Installation and training cost
- System failure without backup
- Security breaches
- Staff fears and health
Audit trail
In a computerised system it is possible to trace any figure back, from the final accounts at the year end to the original source document it came from. This is called an audit trail. It helps the accountant and the auditor check that every figure is genuine.
Worked example 1: advantage or limitation?
Made-up case: Priya Traders moves to a CAS. (a) The trial balance that took two days now appears in seconds: advantage, automated document production and faster processing. (b) A power surge damages the computer and the last week's entries were not backed up: limitation, system failure. (c) An auditor picks a sales figure in the profit and loss account and follows it to the sales invoice: the audit trail. (d) The owner must pay for staff to learn the software: limitation, cost of training.
Manual versus computerised accounting
| Basis | Manual accounting | Computerised accounting |
|---|---|---|
| Recording | Written by hand | Entered using computers |
| Storage | In volumes of books | In well-designed databases |
| Ledger, trial balance and statements | Prepared by hand | Prepared automatically once entries are made |
| Reports | Analysis and reports done by hand | Analysis such as ratio analysis and cash flow statements done automatically |
| Time | A lot of time, from journal to reports | Time is needed only to enter data; the rest takes seconds |
| Cost | High, as several books are kept | Lower, as records are kept in soft copy (the textbook's comparison) |
| Retrieval | Slow; many books to search | Quick; data found by giving instructions |
| Accuracy | Arithmetical and carrying-forward errors can happen | Correct input gives correct output, if the programming is correct |
| Communication of reports | Slow and done by hand | Easy and quick, anywhere, if online |
Notice that the textbook treats running cost as lower under a CAS, while it also lists a heavy cost of installation as a limitation. Both are true: the setting up is expensive, the day-to-day keeping of records is cheaper.
Worked example 2: where an error can still creep in
Made-up case: a clerk enters a purchase of ₹8,500 as ₹5,800. The software posts ₹5,800 correctly to both accounts, and the trial balance still agrees. Lesson: a CAS removes errors of totalling and carrying forward, but not wrong input. As the textbook says, the output is correct only if the input given is correct. Checking source documents is still essential.
A computer removes errors of copying and totalling, not errors of input or judgement: wrong data in gives wrong information out.
Key takeaways: CAS is fast, accurate, reliable and saves space, with reports at a click. Its limitations include installation and training costs, staff fears, system failure, security risks and health effects. An audit trail traces any figure back to its source document. Compared with manual books, a CAS stores data in databases and prepares ledgers and statements automatically.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which of these is a limitation of a computerised accounting system?
- System failure
- Accuracy
- Versatility
- Storage
Show answer
Answer: A. A hardware crash interrupts work, especially without backup. The other three are advantages or features.
-
2. Tracing a figure in the final accounts back to the original source document is called:
- a backup
- a procedure
- a ledger posting
- an audit trail
Show answer
Answer: D. The textbook calls the ability to track figures from source document to final accounts an audit trail.
-
3. Why does the textbook say information in a CAS is more accurate?
- Computers can judge unexpected errors
- Each transaction is entered only once, so repeated posting errors are avoided
- Accountants are no longer needed
- Input errors are corrected automatically
Show answer
Answer: B. In manual books the same data are copied many times; in a CAS one entry updates everything, removing copying errors (but not input errors).
-
4. Under manual accounting, transactions are stored in volumes of books. Under computerised accounting they are stored in:
- loose vouchers only
- a printed ledger
- well-designed databases
- the operating system
Show answer
Answer: C. The textbook's comparison: manual storage in books, computerised storage in well-designed databases.
-
5. Made-up case: a clerk keys in ₹4,700 instead of ₹7,400 for a sale. In a CAS, the trial balance will:
- still agree, because both accounts receive ₹4,700
- fail to agree by ₹2,700
- show the error automatically
- refuse to be prepared
Show answer
Answer: A. The software posts the wrong figure to both the debit and the credit side, so the trial balance agrees. Wrong input gives wrong output.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.