- Practice
- About 18 min
- 5 practice questions
Objectives and limitations of a trial balance
State the four objectives of a trial balance and its limitations, and show with examples why omission, compensating errors and errors of principle leave it in agreement.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- List and explain the four objectives of preparing a trial balance.
- State the limitations of a trial balance.
- Explain with figures why some errors are not disclosed even when the totals agree.
A trial balance is useful, but students often expect too much from it. This lesson sets out exactly what it does and what it cannot do. That balance is a favourite theme in short answer questions, such as whether a trial balance is only prima facie evidence of accuracy.
Objectives of preparing a trial balance
Objectives of a trial balance
- Test of arithmetical accuracy Equal totals suggest posting, totalling and balancing are arithmetically correct.
- Basis for final accounts Trading and profit and loss account and balance sheet are prepared from its summary of balances.
- Location of errors A difference shows that errors exist and must be found and corrected before final accounts.
- Summary of ledger accounts It shows every balance in one place; the ledger is opened only when details are needed.
Location of errors. When the trial balance does not agree, an error may have occurred at any stage: journalising or recording in subsidiary books, totalling those books, posting to the ledger, balancing ledger accounts, carrying balances to the trial balance, or adding up its columns. Each stage is checked in turn and the errors are corrected before the financial statements are prepared.
Limitations of a trial balance
- It can be prepared only when the double entry system is followed.
- Even if some transactions are omitted altogether, the trial balance will still tally.
- It may tally even though errors have been committed in the books.
- If it is not prepared systematically, the final accounts based on it may not show the true state of affairs.
- Agreement is not conclusive proof of arithmetical accuracy: complete omission, compensating errors and errors of principle are not disclosed.
A tallied trial balance is prima facie (first-sight) evidence of accuracy, never conclusive proof.
Three errors a trial balance cannot catch
| Error | What happens | Why totals still agree |
|---|---|---|
| Complete omission | A transaction is not recorded at all | Neither the debit nor the credit is posted, so both columns are lower by the same amount |
| Compensating errors | One error is cancelled out by another of the same amount on the opposite side | An excess on the debit side is matched by an excess on the credit side (or two shortfalls match) |
| Error of principle | An item is recorded in the wrong class of account, for example an asset bought is debited to an expense account | The debit is still a debit of the right amount; only the account is wrong |
The textbook's chapter on rectification of errors (Unit 9) studies errors in detail, including errors that the trial balance does reveal, such as posting only one side of an entry, posting a wrong amount on one side, totalling a subsidiary book wrongly or carrying a balance wrongly.
Worked example 1: complete omission
A made-up firm's correct books show Cash ₹30,000 (Dr), Purchases ₹20,000 (Dr), Capital ₹40,000 (Cr) and Sales ₹10,000 (Cr). A credit sale of ₹6,000 to Ravi was never recorded. Working: if recorded, Ravi would show ₹6,000 (Dr) and Sales ₹16,000 (Cr), giving totals of 56,000 and 56,000. Because it was omitted, the totals are Dr 30,000 + 20,000 = ₹50,000 and Cr 40,000 + 10,000 = ₹50,000. They still agree, so the omission is hidden.
| S. No. | Name of account | Debit balance ₹ | Credit balance ₹ |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Cash A/c | 30,000 | |
| 2 | Purchases A/c | 20,000 | |
| 3 | Capital A/c | 40,000 | |
| 4 | Sales A/c | 10,000 | |
| Total | 50,000 | 50,000 |
Worked example 2: compensating errors
Suppose the Sales account is over-totalled by ₹1,000 (its credit balance is ₹1,000 too high) and the Wages account is also over-totalled by ₹1,000 (its debit balance is ₹1,000 too high). Working: the credit column rises by ₹1,000 and the debit column rises by ₹1,000, so the difference between them is (Dr + 1,000) − (Cr + 1,000) = Dr − Cr = 0. The trial balance tallies although two accounts are wrong.
Worked example 3: error of principle
Furniture bought for ₹7,000 (an asset) is debited to the Purchases account (meant for goods for resale) instead of the Furniture account. Working: debit ₹7,000 and credit ₹7,000 are both posted, so the totals agree. But the trading account will show purchases ₹7,000 too high and the balance sheet will show furniture ₹7,000 too low. This is why a trial balance that tallies can still give misleading final accounts.
- Key takeaways: the four objectives are test of arithmetical accuracy, basis for final accounts, location of errors and a summary of ledger accounts.
- A trial balance needs double entry and cannot detect complete omission, compensating errors or errors of principle.
- Agreement is prima facie, not conclusive, proof of accuracy.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which of these is NOT an objective of preparing a trial balance?
- Finding the market value of the business
- Serving as the basis of final accounts
- Checking arithmetical accuracy
- Giving a summary of ledger accounts
Show answer
Answer: A. The textbook lists arithmetical accuracy, basis for final accounts, location of errors and a summary of ledger accounts. Market value of the business is not something a trial balance shows.
-
2. A credit purchase of ₹12,000 from Kumar is not recorded anywhere in the books. The trial balance will:
- show the debit column short by ₹12,000
- show the credit column short by ₹12,000
- show a difference of ₹24,000
- still agree
Show answer
Answer: D. It is a complete omission: neither Purchases (Dr) nor Kumar (Cr) is posted, so both columns are lower by ₹12,000 and still agree.
-
3. Machinery repairs of ₹4,500 are debited to the Machinery account. This is:
- a compensating error
- an error of principle
- an error disclosed by the trial balance
- a complete omission
Show answer
Answer: B. Repairs are a revenue expense; debiting them to an asset account records the right amount on the right side but in the wrong class of account, which is an error of principle. The trial balance still agrees.
-
4. Rent account is under-totalled by ₹600 on the debit side and Commission received account is under-totalled by ₹600 on the credit side. The trial balance will:
- show debit column excess by ₹600
- show debit column short by ₹600
- show credit column short by ₹1,200
- agree
Show answer
Answer: D. Debit column falls by ₹600 and credit column falls by ₹600; the two errors compensate each other, so the totals still agree.
-
5. Statement: 'Agreement of a trial balance is a conclusive proof that the books are correct.' This statement is:
- true, because totals agree
- true only for computerised accounts
- false, because some errors are not disclosed by it
- false, because a trial balance never agrees
Show answer
Answer: C. Agreement is only prima facie evidence. Omissions, compensating errors and errors of principle can exist even when the totals agree.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.