- Practice
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Classification of the living world: from two kingdoms to seven
Explain why classification is needed, compare the two, three, four and five kingdom systems, describe Whittaker's five kingdoms with their merits and demerits, and outline the three domains, six kingdoms and seven kingdoms.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- State the needs that classification serves.
- Name who proposed the two, three, four and five kingdom systems and when.
- Compare the five kingdoms on cell type, organisation, cell wall, nutrition and motility.
- List the merits and demerits of the five kingdom system.
- Describe the three domains and the six and seven kingdom schemes.
Imagine sorting the photographs from a hill-station trip: mountains, flowers, birds, tall trees, trailing herbs. You would not put a mountain and a flower in the same pile, and to decide which things go together you must compare their characters. Biologists face the same task with millions of organisms. Over time, as microscopes, cell biology and molecular biology improved, the way the living world is divided has changed several times.
Early attempts
Theophrastus, called the Father of Botany, used form (morphology) to divide plants into trees, shrubs and herbs. Aristotle divided animals into Enaima (with red blood) and Anaima (without red blood). Carl Linnaeus divided the living world into two kingdoms, plants and animals, on morphological characters. His system had serious problems: prokaryotes and eukaryotes were placed together, and heterotrophic fungi were placed with photosynthetic plants. Later taxonomists added evidence from cytology, anatomy, embryology, molecular biology and phylogeny.
Why classify?
- To relate organisms that share common features.
- To define organisms by their salient features.
- To know the relationships among different groups.
- To understand evolutionary relationships between organisms.
Systems of classification
| System | Proposed by | Kingdoms |
|---|---|---|
| Two kingdom | Carl Linnaeus (1735) | Plantae, Animalia |
| Three kingdom | Ernst Haeckel (1866) | Protista, Plantae, Animalia |
| Four kingdom | Copeland (1956) | Monera, Protista, Plantae, Animalia |
| Five kingdom | R.H. Whittaker (1969) | Monera, Protista, Fungi, Plantae, Animalia |
Whittaker's five kingdom classification
The American taxonomist R.H. Whittaker proposed five kingdoms in 1969. His criteria were cell structure, thallus organisation, mode of nutrition, reproduction and phylogenetic relationship.
| Criterion | Monera | Protista | Fungi | Plantae | Animalia |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Cell type | Prokaryotic | Eukaryotic | Eukaryotic | Eukaryotic | Eukaryotic |
| Organisation | Mostly unicellular, rarely multicellular | Unicellular | Multicellular and unicellular | Tissue/organ | Tissue/organ/organ system |
| Cell wall | Present (peptidoglycan, mucopeptides) | Present in some (cellulose), absent in others | Present (chitin or cellulose) | Present (cellulose) | Absent |
| Nutrition | Autotrophic or heterotrophic | Photosynthetic or heterotrophic | Heterotrophic: parasitic or saprophytic | Autotrophic (photosynthetic) | Heterotrophic (holozoic) |
| Motility | Motile or non-motile | Motile or non-motile | Non-motile | Mostly non-motile | Mostly motile |
| Members | Archaebacteria, eubacteria, cyanobacteria, actinomycetes, mycoplasma | Chrysophytes, dinoflagellates, euglenoids, slime moulds, Amoeba, Paramecium | Yeast, mushrooms, moulds | Algae, bryophytes, pteridophytes, gymnosperms, angiosperms | Sponges, invertebrates, vertebrates |
Five kingdom system: merits and demerits
-
Merits
- Based on complexity of cell structure and thallus organisation
- Based on mode of nutrition
- Separates fungi from plants
- Shows phylogeny of organisms
-
Demerits
- Monera and Protista hold both autotrophs and heterotrophs
- They also hold organisms with and without cell walls, so they are mixed (heterogeneous) groups
- Viruses are not included
Domains, six kingdoms and seven kingdoms
In 1990 Carl Woese and co-workers proposed three domains of life, Bacteria, Archaea and Eukarya, using differences in the nucleotide sequence of ribosomal RNA and the lipid structure of the cell membrane. In 1998 Thomas Cavalier-Smith proposed six kingdoms, splitting Monera into Archaebacteria and Eubacteria. In 2015 Ruggiero and co-workers published a seven kingdom scheme, a practical extension of Cavalier-Smith's. It has two superkingdoms: Prokaryota (Archaebacteria, Eubacteria) and Eukaryota (Protozoa, Chromista, Fungi, Plantae, Animalia). The new kingdom Chromista holds algae whose chloroplasts contain chlorophyll a and c and the colourless forms related to them, such as diatoms, brown algae, cryptomonads and oomycetes.
Seven kingdom classification (Ruggiero et al., 2015)
-
Superkingdom Prokaryota
- Archaebacteria
- Eubacteria
-
Superkingdom Eukaryota
- Protozoa
- Chromista
- Fungi
- Plantae
- Animalia
Linnaeus 2 (1735), Haeckel 3 (1866), Copeland 4 (1956), Whittaker 5 (1969), Woese 3 domains (1990), Cavalier-Smith 6 (1998), Ruggiero 7 (2015).
Worked reasoning example 1: placing an organism
An organism is eukaryotic and multicellular, has a cell wall of chitin, cannot photosynthesise and absorbs food from dead matter. Where does it go in the five kingdom system? Step 1: eukaryotic rules out Monera. Step 2: a cell wall rules out Animalia. Step 3: no photosynthesis rules out Plantae. Step 4: chitin wall and saprophytic nutrition are the marks of Fungi. Answer: kingdom Fungi, for example a bread mould or a mushroom.
Worked reasoning example 2: why was Linnaeus's system replaced?
Put a bacterium, a mushroom and a mango tree into the two kingdom system: all three go into Plantae because they do not move and have cell walls. Now compare them. The bacterium is prokaryotic; the mushroom and the mango are eukaryotic. The mango makes its own food; the mushroom and most bacteria cannot. One kingdom therefore mixes organisms that differ in the most basic features, cell type and nutrition. Whittaker solved this by giving prokaryotes (Monera) and fungi kingdoms of their own.
Key takeaways: classification groups organisms by shared characters and shows their relationships. Systems grew from two kingdoms (Linnaeus) to three, four and five (Whittaker, 1969). Whittaker's system separated fungi and prokaryotes but left Monera and Protista mixed and left out viruses. Woese's three domains, Cavalier-Smith's six kingdoms and the seven kingdom scheme with Chromista followed.
Check your understanding
-
1. Who proposed the four kingdom classification, and in which year?
- Ernst Haeckel, 1866
- Copeland, 1956
- R.H. Whittaker, 1969
- Carl Woese, 1990
Show answer
Answer: B. Copeland proposed four kingdoms (Monera, Protista, Plantae, Animalia) in 1956. Haeckel proposed three, Whittaker five, and Woese proposed three domains.
-
2. Which is a demerit of the five kingdom classification?
- Fungi are separated from plants
- It considers the mode of nutrition
- Viruses are not included
- It is based on cell structure
Show answer
Answer: C. Leaving out viruses is a demerit. The other three options are merits listed in the textbook.
-
3. Carl Woese's three domains were based mainly on differences in
- Ribosomal RNA sequence and cell membrane lipids
- Flower structure
- Mode of nutrition only
- Presence of red blood
Show answer
Answer: A. Woese used differences in the nucleotide sequence of rRNA and in membrane lipid structure to separate Bacteria, Archaea and Eukarya.
-
4. In the seven kingdom scheme, diatoms and brown algae are placed in kingdom
- Plantae
- Protozoa
- Eubacteria
- Chromista
Show answer
Answer: D. Chromista was set up for algae with chlorophyll a and c and related colourless forms, including diatoms, brown algae, cryptomonads and oomycetes.
-
5. Which kingdom of the five kingdom system lacks a cell wall and shows holozoic nutrition?
- Monera
- Animalia
- Fungi
- Plantae
Show answer
Answer: B. Animalia has no cell wall and is heterotrophic by ingesting food (holozoic). Monera, Fungi and Plantae all have cell walls.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.