• Practice
  • About 18 min
  • 5 practice questions

Absorption of water and the ascent of sap

Trace water from root hairs to xylem by apoplast, symplast and transmembrane routes, compare active and passive absorption, and evaluate the theories of ascent of sap ending with cohesion-tension.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Describe root hairs and the three routes of water across the root.
  • Compare active (osmotic and non-osmotic) and passive absorption of water.
  • Show that xylem is the path of the ascent of sap.
  • Explain and criticise the vital force, root pressure and physical force theories.
  • Explain the cohesion-tension theory of Dixon and Jolly.

A tree may stand tens of metres tall, yet it has no heart to pump water. Somehow water enters thin root hairs, crosses the root sideways and then climbs the trunk. This lesson follows that journey and examines how scientists argued about the force that lifts it.

Root hairs and the path across the root

Young roots absorb most water, and the zone of fastest absorption is the root hair zone. Root hairs are single-celled outgrowths of epidermal cells, without cuticle, extremely thin and numerous, so they give a huge surface for absorption; they are constantly replaced. Water enters by imbibition and then moves radially inward through the cortex, endodermis and pericycle to reach the xylem, the 'superhighway' of water transport.

Three routes of water across the root

  • Apoplast
    • Everything outside the plasma membrane: cell walls, spaces between cells, interiors of dead xylem cells
    • Water crosses no membrane
    • A continuous, non-living system
  • Symplast
    • The joined cytoplasm of all living cells, linked by plasmodesmata
    • Water crosses one membrane at the outer root cell
    • Then moves cell to cell through plasmodesmata
  • Transmembrane
    • Water enters a cell on one side and leaves on the other
    • Crosses at least two membranes per cell
    • May also cross the tonoplast

Mechanisms of water absorption

Kramer (1949) recognised two independent mechanisms. In active absorption the root itself generates the force. The osmotic form (Atkins 1916, Priestley 1923) says soil water (hypotonic) enters the root hair (hypertonic cell sap) by endosmosis, then passes cell to cell through the cortex, endodermis and pericycle to the protoxylem, where it builds root pressure; this is symplastic movement. Objections: the xylem sap is not always concentrated, and root pressure is absent in many plants, especially trees. The non-osmotic form was proposed because water is absorbed even when cell sap is less concentrated than soil water; such uptake needs respiratory energy, and respiratory inhibitors such as KCN reduce both respiration and water absorption.

In passive absorption the roots play no active part. Transpiration removes water from leaf cells, raising their DPD; they pull water from the xylem, a tension develops in the xylem and is passed down to the roots, and water is drawn in from the soil through both apoplast and symplast. According to the textbook this accounts for about 98% of the water taken up.

Active versus passive absorption of water
FeatureActive absorptionPassive absorption
Force produced byActivity of root and root hairsTension from transpiration pull; roots passive
Effect of transpirationNoneControls the rate
Respiratory energyNeededNot needed
RouteSymplastSymplast and apoplast

Ascent of sap: the path is xylem

Water with dissolved minerals in the xylem is sap, and its upward movement is the ascent of sap. Stand a cut shoot of balsam in water coloured with eosin dye; red streaks appear up the stem, and a cross section shows only the xylem stained, not the phloem. So xylem is the path.

Theories of the mechanism

Theories of ascent of sap

  • Vital force theories Living cells are needed.
    • Relay pump theory: Godlewski (1884)
    • Pulsation theory: J. C. Bose (1923), using his crescograph
  • Root pressure theory Pressure built up in the root pushes sap up.
    • Term from Stephen Hales
    • Sap exudation (bleeding) from a cut stem
  • Physical force theories Dead xylem; purely physical forces.
    • Capillary theory: Boehm (1809)
    • Imbibition theory: Unger (1876), Sachs (1878)
    • Cohesion-tension theory: Dixon and Jolly (1894)

Vital force theories said living xylem parenchyma and medullary ray cells act as pumps (Godlewski), or that the inner cortex pulses rhythmically like a heart and pushes sap into the xylem (Bose). They failed because Strasburger (1889) and Overton (1911) killed the living cells of a tree trunk with picric acid and heat, and the trunk still conducted water; also, a pump would have to work between xylem elements vertically, not sideways.

Root pressure is real: a well-watered plant cut near the ground oozes sap. But it cannot explain ascent of sap: it is absent in gymnosperms, which include some of the tallest trees; it is low in summer when ascent is fastest and high in winter when ascent is slow; sap rises even in a stem without roots; and its size, about 2 atm, can lift water only a few metres, while some trees exceed 100 m.

Among the physical theories, the capillary theory failed because capillarity can lift water only a limited height and wide vessels conduct more water than narrow tracheids, the opposite of what capillarity predicts. The imbibition theory (water moves in the walls) failed because experiments showed water moves through the cell cavity (lumen), not the wall.

Cohesion-tension (transpiration pull) theory

Proposed by Dixon and Jolly (1894) and restated by Dixon later, this is the most widely accepted theory. It rests on three features.

  1. Cohesion and adhesion: water molecules attract each other strongly (cohesion) and also cling to the xylem walls (adhesion), forming an unbroken column. The textbook gives the cohesive force as about 350 atm, far more than needed for the tallest trees.
  2. Continuity of the column: air bubbles can break a column (cavitation or embolism), but water moves sideways into neighbouring xylem elements and the overall column continues.
  3. Transpiration pull: water evaporates from mesophyll cells and leaves through stomata; the mesophyll's water potential falls, it pulls water from the xylem, and the tension passes down the column to the roots, like pulling a rope from its top end.

Cohesion holds the water column together, adhesion holds it to the xylem wall, and transpiration pulls it from the top.

Worked example 1: testing root pressure

A student argues that root pressure of 2 atm lifts water to the top of a 60 m tree. Check: 1 atm supports a column of water about 10 m high, so 2 atm supports about 20 m at most, even ignoring friction. 20 m is far less than 60 m. Conclusion: root pressure alone is not enough, which agrees with the textbook's objection.

Worked example 2: a stem without roots

A leafy shoot is cut under water and kept in a beaker in sunlight; the water level in the beaker falls steadily. Reasoning: there are no roots, so no root pressure; the shoot still loses water from its leaves, so the pull must come from transpiration acting on a continuous column. This supports the cohesion-tension theory.

Key takeaways: water crosses the root by apoplast, symplast and transmembrane routes; most uptake is passive, driven by transpiration. Xylem carries sap. Vital, root pressure, capillary and imbibition theories fail; the cohesion-tension theory explains the ascent of sap best.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. In which route does water move across the root WITHOUT crossing any membrane?

    1. Apoplast
    2. Symplast
    3. Transmembrane
    4. Through the tonoplast
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The apoplast is everything outside the plasma membrane (cell walls, intercellular spaces, dead xylem). Water moving this way crosses no membrane. The symplast route crosses at least one membrane, and the transmembrane route crosses two per cell.

  2. 2. Which observation is an objection to the root pressure theory?

    1. Sap oozes from a cut stem near the ground
    2. Root pressure is absent in gymnosperms, which include very tall trees
    3. Xylem is stained red in the eosin experiment
    4. Water molecules show strong cohesion
    Show answer

    Answer: B. If root pressure lifted sap, tall gymnosperms could not get water, yet they lack root pressure. Sap exudation is evidence that root pressure exists, not an objection; the other two are unrelated to root pressure.

  3. 3. Strasburger killed the living cells of a tree trunk and found that water still rose in it. This disproved:

    1. The cohesion-tension theory
    2. The capillary theory
    3. The vital force theories
    4. The idea that xylem conducts water
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Vital force theories said living cells must pump the sap. If water rises in a trunk whose cells are dead, living cells are not essential, so these theories fail.

  4. 4. According to the cohesion-tension theory, the pull that lifts water starts in the:

    1. Root hairs
    2. Phloem of the stem
    3. Pericycle
    4. Mesophyll cells of the leaf, through transpiration
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Evaporation from mesophyll cells and loss through stomata lowers their water potential. They pull water from the xylem, and the tension travels down the continuous column to the roots.

  5. 5. Which statement about passive absorption of water is correct?

    1. It needs respiratory energy from root cells
    2. It is unaffected by transpiration
    3. It is controlled by transpiration and accounts for most water uptake
    4. It takes place only through the symplast
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Passive absorption is driven by the tension created by transpiration pull, so transpiration controls it; it needs no respiratory energy, uses both apoplast and symplast, and accounts for most (about 98% per the textbook) of water uptake.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery