- Practice
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Essential minerals and how they are classified
State the criteria of essentiality given by Arnon and Stout and classify minerals by the quantity needed, by their mobility in the plant and by their functions.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Name the skeletal elements and where plants get them.
- State the four criteria of essentiality given by Arnon and Stout (1939).
- Classify minerals as macronutrients, micronutrients and unclassified minerals.
- Use mobility to predict whether deficiency appears first on old or young leaves.
- Classify minerals by their functions with examples.
Walk past a row of plants and some look sickly: pale or yellow leaves, dead patches, stunted stems. These symptoms can come from disease or weather, but very often the cause is a shortage of a mineral. Knowing which mineral does what lets a farmer diagnose a problem from the leaves and correct it, which is why mineral nutrition matters so much in agriculture.
Where plant elements come from
Plants take nutrients from the air, water and soil. Carbon, hydrogen and oxygen are called skeletal elements; according to the textbook they make up about 94% of a plant's dry weight and build carbohydrates, fats and proteins. They come from air (CO₂) and water, so they are non-mineral elements. All other elements are absorbed from the soil as minerals.
Criteria of essentiality
A plant's ash contains many elements, but not all of them are needed. Arnon and Stout (1939) gave the tests an element must pass to be called essential.
- It is necessary for normal growth and development.
- It has a direct role in the plant's metabolism.
- No other element can replace it.
- Without it, the plant cannot complete its vegetative and reproductive phases (its life cycle).
Classification by quantity needed
| Group | Amount in tissue | Elements |
|---|---|---|
| Macronutrients | More than 10 mmol per kg (0.1 to 10 mg per g dry weight) | C, H, O, N, P, K, Ca, Mg, S |
| Micronutrients | Less than 10 mmol per kg (0.1 mg per g dry weight or less) | Fe, Mn, Cu, Mo, Zn, B, Cl, Ni |
| Unclassified minerals | Needed by some plants in traces for particular jobs | Na, Co, Si, Se |
Unclassified minerals are not on the essential list for all plants, but some plants need them. For example, silicon helps pest resistance, prevents lodging (falling over) and helps build cell walls in Equisetum, sedges (Cyperaceae) and grasses (Gramineae). Iron sits on the border: plants need it in smaller amounts than macronutrients but larger amounts than other micronutrients.
Classification by mobility
When a mineral runs short, the plant may move it from older leaves to the growing young leaves. Whether it can do this depends on the mineral's mobility, and this decides where the symptoms show first.
Mobile and immobile minerals
-
Actively mobile
- N, P, K, Mg, Cl, Na, Zn, Mo (textbook list)
- Moved out of old leaves to young ones
- Deficiency appears first on OLD (senescent) leaves
-
Relatively immobile
- Ca, S, Fe, B, Cu
- Locked in the tissues where first deposited
- Deficiency appears first on YOUNG leaves
Old leaves sick first → a mobile mineral is short. Young leaves sick first → an immobile mineral is short.
Classification by function
- Structural: C, H, O and N build the body's organic compounds.
- Enzyme function: Mo for nitrogenase (reducing N₂ to ammonia); Zn activates alcohol dehydrogenase and carbonic anhydrase; Mg activates RuBP carboxylase-oxygenase and PEP carboxylase; Ni is part of urease and hydrogenase.
- Osmotic potential: K maintains the cell's osmotic potential, which governs water uptake, stomatal movement and turgidity.
- Energy-related components: Mg in chlorophyll and P in ATP.
Worked example 1: is the element essential?
A plant grown in a nutrient solution lacking element Q grows poorly and never sets seed. When a different element R is added instead of Q, the plant still fails to set seed; when Q is added back, it completes its life cycle. Check the criteria: (1) Q is needed for growth; (2) the plant cannot complete its reproductive phase without Q; (3) R cannot replace Q. If Q also takes part directly in metabolism, Q is essential.
Worked example 2: reading the leaves
Plant A shows yellowing of its lowest, oldest leaves while the top leaves stay green. Plant B shows pale, distorted youngest leaves while the old leaves are fine. Reasoning: in A, the plant has moved the short mineral from old to young leaves, so it is mobile (for example N, K or Mg). In B, the mineral could not be moved to the new growth, so it is immobile (for example Ca, Fe or B).
Key takeaways: C, H and O come from air and water. Essential minerals meet the four Arnon and Stout criteria. Macronutrients are needed in large and micronutrients in small amounts; Na, Co, Si and Se are unclassified. Mobile minerals show deficiency in old leaves, immobile ones in young leaves.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which group lists only micronutrients?
- Fe, Mn, Zn, Mo
- N, P, K, Ca
- Na, Co, Si, Se
- C, H, O, Mg
Show answer
Answer: A. Fe, Mn, Zn and Mo are micronutrients. N, P, K and Ca are macronutrients; Na, Co, Si and Se are unclassified minerals; C, H, O and Mg are in the macronutrient list.
-
2. Which is NOT one of the criteria of essentiality of Arnon and Stout?
- The element has a direct role in metabolism
- The element cannot be replaced by another element
- The element is present in large amounts in the plant ash
- Without the element the plant cannot complete its life cycle
Show answer
Answer: C. Being present in the ash does not make an element essential; plants absorb many elements they do not need. The criteria are about need for growth, direct metabolic role, no substitute, and completion of the life cycle.
-
3. Deficiency symptoms of a mineral appear first on the youngest leaves. The mineral is most likely:
- Nitrogen
- Potassium
- Magnesium
- Calcium
Show answer
Answer: D. Calcium is relatively immobile, so it cannot be moved from old leaves to new growth, and young leaves suffer first. N, K and Mg are mobile; their deficiency shows first on old leaves.
-
4. Which mineral is matched correctly with its function?
- Mo - constituent of chlorophyll
- K - maintaining osmotic potential and stomatal movement
- Ni - activator of PEP carboxylase
- Zn - component of ATP
Show answer
Answer: B. Potassium maintains osmotic potential, which governs water uptake, turgidity and stomatal movement. Mg is in chlorophyll and activates PEP carboxylase, Ni is part of urease, and P (not Zn) is part of ATP.
-
5. Silicon is placed among unclassified minerals because:
- It is needed by all plants in large amounts
- It is a skeletal element obtained from air
- It is not essential for all plants but some plants need it for specific roles
- It is toxic to every plant
Show answer
Answer: C. Silicon is not on the essential list, but some plants, such as Equisetum and grasses, use it for cell walls, pest resistance and preventing lodging. Such minerals are unclassified.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.