• Practice
  • About 16 min
  • 5 practice questions

Advantages, drawbacks and documents of warehousing

Weigh the advantages and drawbacks of warehousing and explain the warehouse warrant, warehouse keeper's receipt, dock warrant, dock receipt and delivery order.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • State the advantages and drawbacks of warehousing.
  • Explain the five warehousing documents.
  • Distinguish a warehouse warrant from a warehouse keeper's receipt.

Warehouses help traders in many ways, but in practice they also face problems. And because goods in a warehouse are out of the owner's hands, documents are needed to prove who owns them and who may take them out.

Advantages

  1. Safeguards the stock of merchants who have no storage space.
  2. Reduces distribution cost: goods are stored in bulk and the trader takes them to his shop in small lots.
  3. Helps the producer choose the channel of distribution, for instance whether to appoint a wholesaler or a retailer.
  4. Keeps sales continuous and avoids 'out of stock' situations.
  5. Creates employment for skilled and unskilled workers.

Drawbacks

  1. Inadequate transport between places of production and warehouses.
  2. Not enough storage for different commodities, perishable and non-perishable.
  3. Complicated formalities that illiterate and innocent farmers find hard to cope with.
  4. Complicated barcode technology may discourage some producers from storing goods.
  5. Delay in obtaining finance may cause loss to the owner of goods.

Warehousing documents

  1. Warehouse warrant: issued by the warehouse keeper to the owner or depositor. It is a document of title to the goods and can be transferred by endorsement and delivery. To transfer all the goods, the warrant is enough; to transfer part of them, a delivery order is used along with the warrant.
  2. Warehouse keeper's receipt: an acknowledgement that the goods have been received, showing an agreement to keep them on certain conditions. It is not a document of title and is not transferable.
  3. Dock warrant: issued by dock (harbour) authorities, certifying that they hold the goods. It is a document of title; the right to take delivery can be assigned to a third party.
  4. Dock receipt: an acknowledgement by dock authorities that goods have been received. It is not a document of title, so the right to delivery cannot be transferred.
  5. Delivery order: the depositor's direction to the warehouse keeper to deliver specified goods to the named party or to the bearer; transfer of ownership takes place through it.
Differences as set out in the Tamil Nadu textbook
BasisWarehouse warrantWarehouse keeper's receipt
Title to goodsA document of titleNot a document of title
What it doesAcknowledges receipt and authorises delivery to the owner or a third partyOnly acknowledges receipt
TransferCan be negotiated or transferredCannot be transferred
LoansCan be given as collateral securityCannot be given as collateral, as the textbook's table states
DeliveryBy surrendering the endorsed warrantBy surrendering the receipt with a letter from the depositor

Documents of title and plain acknowledgements

  • Documents of title (transferable)
    • Warehouse warrant
    • Dock warrant
  • Acknowledgements only (not transferable)
    • Warehouse keeper's receipt
    • Dock receipt

A warrant is a document of title and can be transferred; a receipt only acknowledges that goods were received.

Worked example 1: selling goods without moving them

Made-up case: Murugan has 400 bags of pulses in a warehouse and holds a warehouse warrant. He sells all 400 bags to Fathima. Reasoning: he endorses the warrant and delivers it to her; as a document of title it passes ownership, and she can take delivery by surrendering it. If he had sold only 150 bags, he would issue a delivery order for 150 bags, accompanied by the warrant, and the keeper would release that quantity.

Worked example 2: reduced distribution cost

Illustrative figures: a trader needs 600 bags a year. Carrying small lots from a distant factory costs ₹20 a bag; bringing them in bulk to a nearby warehouse costs ₹8 a bag plus ₹4 a bag from warehouse to shop. Working: without warehouse: 600 × 20 = ₹12,000. With warehouse: 600 × (8 + 4) = 600 × 12 = ₹7,200. Saving = 12,000 − 7,200 = ₹4,800, before storage charges.

Key takeaways: warehousing protects stock, lowers distribution cost, helps choose channels, keeps sales continuous and creates jobs, but suffers from poor transport, too little storage, complex formalities and delayed finance; warehouse and dock warrants are transferable documents of title, receipts are mere acknowledgements, and a delivery order directs delivery of specified goods.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Which document is a document of title and can be transferred by endorsement and delivery?

    1. Warehouse keeper's receipt
    2. Dock receipt
    3. Gift cheque
    4. Warehouse warrant
    Show answer

    Answer: D. A warehouse warrant is a document of title transferable by endorsement and delivery; receipts are only acknowledgements.

  2. 2. A dock receipt is:

    1. a document of title that can be assigned
    2. an acknowledgement of receipt of goods and not a document of title
    3. a bill of exchange
    4. a delivery order
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The dock receipt only acknowledges receipt; the dock warrant is the document of title.

  3. 3. To transfer only part of the goods held under a warehouse warrant, the depositor uses a:

    1. delivery order, accompanied by the warrant
    2. dock receipt
    3. warehouse keeper's receipt alone
    4. fixed deposit receipt
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The textbook says a delivery order, accompanied by the warehouse warrant, is needed to transfer part of the goods.

  4. 4. Which is a drawback of warehousing given in the textbook?

    1. Continuous sales without 'out of stock'
    2. Lower distribution cost
    3. Complicated formalities that farmers find hard to cope with
    4. More employment
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Complicated formalities are a drawback; the other options are advantages.

  5. 5. Illustrative figures: 300 bags cost ₹18 a bag to bring directly, or ₹7 + ₹5 a bag through a nearby warehouse. What is the saving through the warehouse?

    1. ₹1,800
    2. ₹3,600
    3. ₹5,400
    4. ₹1,500
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Direct: 300 × 18 = ₹5,400. Through warehouse: 300 × 12 = ₹3,600. Saving = ₹1,800.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery