- Practice
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
Railway transport
Explain the features of railway transport, the three track gauges, and the advantages and disadvantages of railways as the Tamil Nadu textbook gives them.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain why railways are called a public utility needing huge capital.
- Name the three gauges of track.
- Explain the advantages and disadvantages of railway transport.
The steam engine, greatly improved by James Watt, made the railway possible, and railways transformed transport during the Industrial Revolution. The textbook calls the railway the most organised transport undertaking in the world, and the cheapest and quickest way to carry heavy goods over long distances.
Features of railway transport
Rail transport moves passengers and goods in wheeled vehicles running on tracks (rails). It needs huge capital: laying tracks, building bridges and buying locomotives. Railways are among the biggest public utilities of a country and render an essential public service. Three kinds of track (gauge) are in use: broad gauge, metre gauge and narrow gauge.
Advantages
- Well suited for heavy and bulky goods over long distances.
- Long-distance travel day and night without a break.
- Better protection and safety for goods than motor transport, since closed wagons keep out sun and rain.
- Although the initial investment is large, operating cost in the long run is low, making it cheaper; it is also quicker than road for long distances.
- Regular timetable, available throughout the year.
- Service is largely unaffected by weather.
Disadvantages
- For light goods over short distances, rail rates are higher than road.
- Inflexible: trains run only on fixed tracks and cannot leave set routes.
- Uneconomical in many rural areas, which do not offer enough traffic.
- Heavy investment in tracks and maintenance raises fares.
- If wagons and coaches run half empty, a heavy financial burden falls on the railway.
Rail and road
-
Railway
- Best for heavy goods, long distances
- Fixed tracks and timetable
- Huge capital, low long-run running cost
- Closed wagons protect goods
-
Road
- Best for short and medium distances
- Flexible routes, door to door
- Lower capital per route
- Feeds goods to and from railheads
Railways: cheapest and quickest for heavy goods over long distances, but inflexible and costly for light goods over short distances.
Worked example 1: rail or road?
Illustrative rates (made up): to send 50 tonnes of cement 1,200 km, rail costs ₹1.20 per tonne-km and road ₹2.00 per tonne-km. Working: rail = 50 × 1,200 × 1.20 = ₹72,000; road = 50 × 1,200 × 2.00 = ₹1,20,000. Rail saves 1,20,000 − 72,000 = ₹48,000. For 200 kg of goods sent 30 km, however, road is usually cheaper and faster, because there is no loading at a railhead and delivery is door to door.
Worked example 2: the cost of empty wagons
Illustrative figures: a goods train costs ₹3,00,000 to run on a route whether full or not, and carries up to 3,000 tonnes. Working: cost per tonne when full = 3,00,000 ÷ 3,000 = ₹100; when half full (1,500 tonnes) = 3,00,000 ÷ 1,500 = ₹200. Running half empty doubles the cost per tonne, which is the financial burden the textbook mentions.
Key takeaways: railways need huge capital but give low running costs, safety and regular all-weather service for heavy goods over long distances; they are inflexible, costly for light short-distance loads, uneconomic in thin rural traffic and burdened when under-used; tracks are broad, metre or narrow gauge.
Check your understanding
-
1. Railways are most suitable for carrying:
- heavy and bulky goods over long distances
- light parcels over a few kilometres
- goods across oceans
- perishable goods by air
Show answer
Answer: A. The textbook's first advantage of railways is carrying heavy and bulky goods over long distances.
-
2. Which is a disadvantage of railway transport?
- It runs regularly all year
- It protects goods in closed wagons
- It works day and night
- It is inflexible, being tied to fixed tracks and routes
Show answer
Answer: D. Trains cannot leave their tracks or set routes, so railways are inflexible; the other options are advantages.
-
3. Which of these is NOT one of the three track gauges named in the textbook?
- Broad gauge
- Double gauge
- Metre gauge
- Narrow gauge
Show answer
Answer: B. The three gauges are broad, metre and narrow.
-
4. Illustrative figures: rail ₹1.50 per tonne-km, road ₹2.50 per tonne-km, for 20 tonnes over 500 km. How much does rail save?
- ₹10,000
- ₹15,000
- ₹25,000
- ₹5,000
Show answer
Answer: A. Rail = 20 × 500 × 1.50 = ₹15,000. Road = 20 × 500 × 2.50 = ₹25,000. Saving = ₹10,000.
-
5. Why do half-empty trains cause a financial burden?
- Half-empty trains need no fuel
- Fares are fixed by passengers
- Running cost is spread over fewer tonnes, raising cost per tonne
- Tracks wear out faster when trains are empty
Show answer
Answer: C. Running costs are largely fixed; carrying less spreads them over fewer units, so cost per tonne rises.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.