• Practice
  • About 16 min
  • 5 practice questions

WTO agreements, benefits and criticisms

Explain the main WTO agreements in the textbook (GATT, textiles and clothing, agriculture, GATS and TRIPS), the benefits of the WTO, and the criticisms levelled against it.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Describe the five WTO agreements the textbook explains.
  • List the benefits of the WTO.
  • Explain the criticisms levelled against the WTO, presented as criticisms.

The WTO works through agreements that member countries accept. Some open up trade in goods, some in services, some protect ideas. Countries gain from them, but the textbook also records the criticisms many people make, especially on behalf of developing countries.

WTO agreements

AgreementWhat it does
Agreements forming part of GATTGATT is an important part of the WTO agreements and includes special agreements on non-tariff barriers.
Agreement on Textiles and ClothingAimed to phase out the quota restrictions that limited the export of textiles and clothing from developing countries, helping them expand these exports.
Agreement on Agriculture (AoA)Aims at free and fair trade in farm goods: developed countries reduce customs duties on imports and subsidies on exports of farm products; the textbook says developing countries were exempted from reciprocal offers because of their high dependence on agriculture.
General Agreement on Trade in Services (GATS)Members remove restrictions on trade in services in phases. It follows the most favoured nation principle: contracts go on the merit of the service supplier, not on nationality, so foreign and local providers are not discriminated against. Members must publish their laws on trade in services.
Trade-Related aspects of Intellectual Property Rights (TRIPS)Sets minimum standards of protection for seven kinds of intellectual property: copyright, trademark, geographical indication, industrial design, patent, layout design of integrated circuits and undisclosed information.

Intellectual property covered by TRIPS

  • Creative and brand
    • Copyright
    • Trademark
    • Geographical indication
  • Technical
    • Patent
    • Industrial design
    • Layout design of integrated circuits
  • Confidential
    • Undisclosed information (trade secrets)

Benefits of the WTO (as listed in the textbook)

  1. Promotes international peace and a good environment for trade.
  2. Settles trade disputes amicably.
  3. Raises living standards by increasing incomes through freer trade.
  4. Has removed quantitative restrictions and non-tariff barriers; import restrictions are allowed mainly to correct balance of payments difficulties.
  5. Stimulates growth of developing countries with capital and preferential treatment.
  6. Organises conferences where developing countries learn the rules and technicalities of world trade.
  7. Gives people a wider choice of goods and qualities.
  8. Lowers trade barriers, raising national and personal incomes.
  9. Provides one platform for trade links, instead of many separate agreements.
  10. Protects free trade with rules on subsidies and dumping.

Criticisms levelled against the WTO

The textbook records these criticisms; they are views held by critics, not settled facts:

  1. Free trade is said to benefit developed countries more, since developing countries are kept from protecting their infant industries as developed countries once did.
  2. The most favoured nation principle stops developing countries from favouring their emerging companies, which critics say gives multinationals an unfair advantage.
  3. It has not persuaded the USA and the European Union to remove high tariffs on agriculture, which hurts farmers in developing countries.
  4. It is said to neglect the interests of farmers in developing countries, who need protection while diversifying.
  5. It is said to neglect the environment by putting growth in GDP first.
  6. It is feared to neglect cultural and social factors, as MNC dominance may harm local firms and cultural diversity.
  7. Patent protection under TRIPS is said to raise prices of life-saving drugs, making them hard to afford in developing countries.

Most favoured nation: treat every trading partner, and every foreign and local supplier, without discrimination.

Worked example 1: which agreement applies?

(a) A made-up Tamil Nadu firm wants protection for its registered brand name in other member countries. (b) An Indian software firm bids for a service contract abroad and wants to be judged on merit, not nationality. (c) A country's farmers complain about subsidised farm exports from another member. Answers: (a) TRIPS (trademark); (b) GATS and its most favoured nation principle; (c) the Agreement on Agriculture, which asks developed countries to cut export subsidies.

Worked example 2: why tariffs matter

Illustrative figures: a farm product costs ₹1,000 to land in a foreign market. With a 40% tariff, its price there becomes 1,000 + 400 = ₹1,400. If the tariff is cut to 10%, the price becomes 1,000 + 100 = ₹1,100. Reasoning: the lower tariff makes the exporter's goods ₹300 cheaper to buyers, so they can compete with local produce. This is why the criticism about high agricultural tariffs matters to farmers in developing countries.

Key takeaways: the WTO's agreements cover goods (GATT, textiles, agriculture), services (GATS, with the most favoured nation principle) and intellectual property (TRIPS, seven kinds); its benefits include peace, dispute settlement, lower barriers and wider choice; critics say it favours developed countries and MNCs, neglects farmers and the environment, and raises drug prices.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. TRIPS sets minimum standards for how many kinds of intellectual property?

    1. Five
    2. Seven
    3. Three
    4. Ten
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Copyright, trademark, geographical indication, industrial design, patent, layout design of integrated circuits and undisclosed information: seven.

  2. 2. Under GATS, the most favoured nation principle means service contracts are awarded on the basis of:

    1. the supplier's nationality
    2. the lowest tax
    3. the merit of the supplier, without discriminating by nationality
    4. government ownership
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Contracts go on merit; foreign and local service providers must not be discriminated against.

  3. 3. Which is a benefit of the WTO in the textbook?

    1. It settles trade disputes amicably among members
    2. It raises tariffs on all imports
    3. It fixes exchange rates
    4. It lends money for war reconstruction
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Amicable settlement of trade disputes is one of the listed benefits.

  4. 4. Critics say that patent protection under TRIPS may:

    1. lower drug prices
    2. end all trade
    3. abolish trademarks
    4. raise prices of life-saving drugs in developing countries
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The textbook records the criticism that patent protection in drug manufacturing may make essential drugs costly.

  5. 5. A good costs ₹2,000 to land abroad. A 25% tariff is cut to 5%. The fall in its price to the foreign buyer is:

    1. ₹100
    2. ₹500
    3. ₹400
    4. ₹2,100
    Show answer

    Answer: C. At 25%: 2,000 + 500 = ₹2,500. At 5%: 2,000 + 100 = ₹2,100. Fall = 2,500 - 2,100 = ₹400.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery