- Practice
- About 13 min
- 5 practice questions
Balance of payments and balance of trade compared
Distinguish the balance of payments from the balance of trade on the textbook's seven bases, and see how an unfavourable balance of trade can sit within a balanced or favourable overall position.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Distinguish BOP and BOT on meaning, transactions, capital, structure, net position, indicator value and correction.
- Explain why the BOP 'always balances' in the accounting sense yet can show a surplus or deficit on its accounts.
- Show with figures how an unfavourable BOT can be offset by invisibles and capital.
Students often mix up the two terms. The key is size: the balance of trade is one part (goods only) of the much wider balance of payments. This lesson puts them side by side.
Differences
| Basis | Balance of payments | Balance of trade |
|---|---|---|
| Meaning | Systematic record of all economic transactions between residents and foreigners in a period | Statement of the net effect of exports and imports of goods |
| Transactions recorded | Goods and services | Only merchandise (goods) |
| Capital transactions | Recorded | Not recorded |
| Structure | Includes balance of trade, balance of services, unilateral transfers and capital transactions | Part of the current account of the BOP |
| Net position | Always balances in the sense that the receipts side is made equal to the payments side | May be favourable, unfavourable or in equilibrium |
| Indicator of economic status | The textbook calls it a true indicator of economic performance | Not a true indicator of economic prosperity on its own |
| Correcting unfavourableness | An unfavourable BOP means a deficit position | An unfavourable BOT can be offset by other items, giving a favourable BOP |
How can the BOP 'always balance' and still show a deficit?
Because the BOP uses double entry, every receipt and payment is matched by a financing entry, so the statement as a whole balances, just as an account's two sides are made equal. But its parts need not balance: the current account or the trade account can show a surplus or deficit, which is then financed by capital flows or reserves. When the textbook speaks of a BOP 'surplus' or 'deficit', it means the position on these accounts before such financing.
Balance of trade sits inside the balance of payments
-
Current account
- Balance of trade (goods)
- Balance of services
- Income and unilateral transfers
-
Capital account
- Private capital
- Banking capital
- Official capital
BOT is a part; BOP is the whole. BOT = goods only. BOP = goods + services + income + transfers + capital.
Worked example 1: unfavourable BOT, favourable overall
Illustrative figures for a made-up country (crore rupees): goods exported 30,000, goods imported 36,000; net invisibles (services, income, remittances) +7,500; net private capital inflow +1,200. Working: BOT = 30,000 - 36,000 = -6,000 (unfavourable). Current account = -6,000 + 7,500 = +1,500. Adding capital: +1,500 + 1,200 = +2,700 overall surplus before changes in reserves. So an unfavourable BOT has been more than offset, as the textbook's last point of difference says.
Worked example 2: identify the statement
(a) A statement shows only goods exported and imported. (b) A statement shows goods, services, interest received and paid, and foreign investment. Answers: (a) balance of trade, since it has goods only; (b) balance of payments, since it includes services, income and capital.
Key takeaways: the BOP records goods, services and capital and balances overall by double entry, while the BOT records goods only and may be favourable, unfavourable or in equilibrium; the BOT is part of the BOP's current account; an unfavourable BOT can be offset by invisibles and capital inflows.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which records capital transactions?
- Balance of trade only
- Balance of payments
- Neither
- Both equally
Show answer
Answer: B. The BOP records capital transactions; the BOT does not.
-
2. The balance of trade is a part of the BOP's:
- capital account
- official capital
- current account
- banking capital
Show answer
Answer: C. The textbook says the balance of trade is part of the current account of the BOP.
-
3. Which statement does the textbook make about the BOP's net position?
- It is always unfavourable
- It always balances, with the receipts side made equal to the payments side
- It records only goods
- It never includes services
Show answer
Answer: B. In the accounting sense the BOP always balances, while the BOT may be favourable, unfavourable or in equilibrium.
-
4. BOT -₹4,000 crore; net invisibles +₹5,500 crore; net capital inflow +₹800 crore. The overall position before reserve changes is:
- -₹4,000 crore
- +₹1,500 crore
- +₹10,300 crore
- +₹2,300 crore
Show answer
Answer: D. Current account = -4,000 + 5,500 = +1,500; adding capital: +1,500 + 800 = +2,300 crore.
-
5. According to the textbook, which is the true indicator of an economy's performance?
- Balance of payments
- Balance of trade
- Value of imports only
- Number of exporters
Show answer
Answer: A. The textbook calls the BOP a true indicator of economic performance, and says the BOT alone is not.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.