• Practice
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

Joint Hindu Family business: meaning and characteristics

Explain the Joint Hindu Family (HUF) business, the Dayabhaga and Mitakshara schools of Hindu law, and the eight characteristics the Tamil Nadu textbook gives, including the role of the Karta.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Explain the meaning of a Joint Hindu Family business and how it comes into being.
  • Distinguish the Dayabhaga and Mitakshara schools as the textbook describes them.
  • Explain the characteristics of a Joint Hindu Family business, especially the Karta's position and liability.

In many Indian towns a shop or a trade has passed from grandfather to father to son, with the whole family living together and sharing its income. Business carried on in this way is the Joint Hindu Family business, also called the business of a Hindu Undivided Family (HUF). The textbook describes it as a form of organisation peculiar to India. The chapter opens with Kural 517, which advises a ruler to judge who can do a task well and then trust that person with it: in an HUF business, that trusted person is the Karta.

Meaning

When a family agrees to live and work together, invest its resources and labour jointly and share profits or losses together, it is called a composite family or HUF. According to the textbook, a Joint Hindu Family firm is created by the operation of law, not by an agreement among members. It has no separate legal entity apart from its members, and its business is governed by Hindu law. The members are called coparceners.

Two schools of Hindu law

SchoolWhere prevalent (as in the textbook)Key point
DayabhagaBengal and AssamA son does not acquire a right in the family property by birth; rights pass on the father's death
MitaksharaThe rest of the countryA son acquires a right by birth in the joint family property: as soon as he is born he gets an interest in the property jointly held by the family

The textbook adds that today the Hindu Succession Act, as amended in 2005, applies to all male and female members of an HUF. In other words, the older idea that only sons gain a right by birth has been changed by that law, as the textbook notes.

Characteristics

  1. Governed by Hindu law: the business is controlled and managed under Hindu law.
  2. Management by the Karta: all affairs are managed by one person, the Karta or manager. The textbook describes the Karta as the senior-most male member. Members have full faith in him; only the Karta deals with outsiders, and others may do so only with his permission.
  3. Membership by birth: a child becomes a member as soon as it is born into the family; no consent or agreement is needed.
  4. Liability: the Karta's liability is unlimited, so debts can be recovered from his personal property too; every other member's liability is limited to his share in the business.
  5. Permanent existence: the death, lunacy or insolvency of a member does not end the business; the family carries on.
  6. Implied authority of the Karta: only the Karta has implied authority to contract debts and pledge the firm's property for the ordinary purposes of the business.
  7. Minor also a coparcener: even a newborn baby can be a coparcener.
  8. Dissolution: the business can be dissolved only at the will of all the members; no single member can force it.

Karta and other coparceners

  • Karta
    • Manages all affairs
    • Deals with outsiders
    • Implied authority to borrow and pledge
    • Unlimited liability
  • Other coparceners
    • Members by birth, even as minors
    • Deal with outsiders only with the Karta's permission
    • Liability limited to their share

HUF business: created by law, managed by the Karta, membership by birth, Karta's liability unlimited and others' limited to their share, existence continues despite a member's death.

Worked example 1: liability in an HUF

A made-up HUF textile shop has the Karta, Shanmugam, and three coparceners whose shares are worth ₹1,00,000 each. The business owes ₹9,00,000 but its assets are worth ₹7,00,000 (illustrative). Working: shortfall = 9,00,000 - 7,00,000 = ₹2,00,000. Since the coparceners' liability is limited to their shares, which are already part of the business assets, they pay nothing more from their own pockets. The Karta's liability is unlimited, so creditors may recover the ₹2,00,000 from his personal property.

Worked example 2: does the business stop?

In the same made-up HUF, one coparcener dies and a baby is born to another. Reasoning: permanent existence means the death does not end the business; membership by birth means the baby becomes a coparcener at once, without any agreement. Contrast this with a sole trader's business, which ends with the owner's death.

Key takeaways: the Joint Hindu Family business is peculiar to India, created by the operation of law and governed by Hindu law; the Dayabhaga school prevails in Bengal and Assam and the Mitakshara school elsewhere, with a son's right by birth under Mitakshara; the Karta manages, deals with outsiders, has implied authority and bears unlimited liability, while other members' liability is limited to their shares; membership is by birth, the business has permanent existence and is dissolved only by all members.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. The business of a Hindu Undivided Family is managed by:

    1. the owner
    2. the Karta
    3. a partner
    4. an elected board
    Show answer

    Answer: B. All affairs of a Joint Hindu Family business are controlled and managed by one person, the Karta.

  2. 2. In an HUF business, membership is acquired:

    1. by agreement
    2. by investing capital
    3. by managing the business
    4. by birth
    Show answer

    Answer: D. A child becomes a member as soon as it is born into the family; no consent or agreement is needed.

  3. 3. The members of a joint Hindu family are called:

    1. coparceners
    2. partners
    3. shareholders
    4. Kartas
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The textbook calls the members coparceners; even a newborn can be a coparcener.

  4. 4. Under which school, as the textbook describes it, does a son acquire a right by birth in the joint family property?

    1. Dayabhaga
    2. Hindu law in Bengal
    3. Mitakshara
    4. None of these
    Show answer

    Answer: C. According to Mitakshara law, prevalent outside Bengal and Assam, a son acquires an interest in the joint family property by birth.

  5. 5. Whose liability in an HUF business is unlimited?

    1. Every coparcener's
    2. Only the minor coparceners'
    3. No one's
    4. Only the Karta's
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Except the Karta, every member's liability is limited to his share; the Karta's debts can be recovered from his personal property too.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery