Revision notes

Chapter 5 Hindu Undivided Family and Partnership: Foundation

The key points, rules to remember, tables and diagrams from all 5 lessons, on one page for quick revision. To keep a copy, use your browser's Print and choose "Save as PDF".

Lesson 1

Joint Hindu Family business: meaning and characteristics

SchoolWhere prevalent (as in the textbook)Key point
DayabhagaBengal and AssamA son does not acquire a right in the family property by birth; rights pass on the father's death
MitaksharaThe rest of the countryA son acquires a right by birth in the joint family property: as soon as he is born he gets an interest in the property jointly held by the family

Karta and other coparceners

  • Karta
    • Manages all affairs
    • Deals with outsiders
    • Implied authority to borrow and pledge
    • Unlimited liability
  • Other coparceners
    • Members by birth, even as minors
    • Deal with outsiders only with the Karta's permission
    • Liability limited to their share

HUF business: created by law, managed by the Karta, membership by birth, Karta's liability unlimited and others' limited to their share, existence continues despite a member's death.

Key takeaways: the Joint Hindu Family business is peculiar to India, created by the operation of law and governed by Hindu law; the Dayabhaga school prevails in Bengal and Assam and the Mitakshara school elsewhere, with a son's right by birth under Mitakshara; the Karta manages, deals with outsiders, has implied authority and bears unlimited liability, while other members' liability is limited to their shares; membership is by birth, the business has permanent existence and is dissolved only by all members.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 2

Partnership: meaning, characteristics, advantages and disadvantages

Partnership: two sides

  • Advantages
    • Easy formation; registration optional
    • Larger resources
    • Benefit of consultation
    • Division of work, better management
    • Reduced risk (losses shared)
    • Credit standing from unlimited liability
    • Safeguard of minority interest
    • Easy dissolution
  • Disadvantages
    • Lack of harmony
    • No legal status; instability
    • Limited resources
    • Limited risk-taking
    • Risk of implied authority
    • Lack of public confidence (accounts not published)

Mutual agency is the essence of partnership: each partner is a principal to outsiders and an agent of the other partners.

Key takeaways: partnership is an extension of sole proprietorship, defined in Section 4 of the Partnership Act, 1932 as a relation between persons who share profits of a business carried on by all or any of them acting for all; its features are a contract, plurality of persons, a lawful business, sharing of profit and mutual agency; advantages include easy formation, larger resources, consultation, division of work, reduced risk and credit standing; disadvantages include disharmony, instability, limited resources, caution about risk, implied authority and lack of public confidence.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 3

Partnership deed; rights, duties and liabilities of partners

ContentWhat it settles
Name, nature and durationThe firm's name, its business, and whether it runs for a fixed period or a particular venture
Capital contributionWhat each partner brings; a partner may contribute skill or business acumen instead of capital
Withdrawals (drawings)How much each partner may withdraw
Profit and loss sharing ratioIf not stated, profits and losses are shared equally
Interest on capital and on drawingsWhether allowed or charged, and at what rate
Loans from partnersWhether accepted, and the interest payable
Accounts and auditHow accounts are kept and audited
Salary or commissionUnless provided, no partner is entitled to salary
Retirement, goodwill, responsibilitiesPayment to a retiring or deceased partner, method of valuing goodwill, each partner's duties
Dissolution and arbitrationProcedure for dissolution and settlement, and a method to settle disputes without costly litigation

If the deed is silent: profits and losses shared equally, no salary to partners, interest on partners' loans at the rate the textbook gives (6% p.a.), unanimous consent for fundamental changes.

Key takeaways: a written, stamped and registered deed avoids disputes and covers name, business, duration, capital, drawings, profit ratio, interest, loans, accounts, salary, retirement, goodwill, duties, dissolution and arbitration; partners have rights to manage, be consulted, inspect books, share profits, earn interest on loans, be indemnified, retire and continue; their duties centre on good faith, true accounts and no secret or competing profit; liability is joint and several.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 4

Types of partnership and types of partners

TypeMeaningWhen it ends
Partnership at willFormed for an undefined period; no time limitWhen any partner gives notice of his intention to dissolve
Partnership for a fixed termFormed for a definite periodOn expiry of the period; if continued after that, it becomes a partnership at will
Particular partnershipFormed for a particular venture or temporary businessOn completion of the venture; if it takes up new work, it continues until a partner gives notice
Limited liability partnership (LLP)Only the firm's assets, not partners' personal property, are used to pay its debtsGoverned by its own law, not the Partnership Act, 1932

Types of partners

  • By role
    • Active: manages the business
    • Sleeping or dormant: invests, does not manage
    • Secret: not known to the public
  • By what they bring or get
    • Nominal: lends only his name
    • Partner in profits only: shares profits, not losses
  • By conduct
    • Partner by estoppel
    • Partner by holding out
  • By age
    • Minor: admitted to benefits only

Sleeping, nominal and profits-only partners do not manage, but all three are liable to outsiders for the firm's debts. Estoppel and holding out make a non-partner liable because of how he was presented.

Key takeaways: partnerships are at will (no time limit), for a fixed term, particular (one venture) or limited liability partnerships (only firm assets pay debts, under the LLP Act, 2008 as the textbook states); partners may be active, sleeping, nominal, in profits only, by estoppel, by holding out, secret or minor; most non-managing partners are still liable to outsiders, and a minor can only be admitted to the benefits of an existing firm with all partners' consent.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 5

Registration and dissolution of partnership

Registering a partnership firm

  1. Prepare a statement Firm's name, principal place of business, other places of business, names and addresses of partners, date each joined, duration of the firm.
  2. All partners sign The statement is signed by every partner.
  3. File with the Registrar of Firms With the registration fee.
  4. Report changes Any change in these particulars is to be told to the Registrar; the textbook gives a limit of 14 days.
PointDissolution of partnershipDissolution of the firm
MeaningThe original partnership agreement endsThe relationship among all partners ends
BusinessContinues with a new agreement among remaining or new partnersComes to an end; assets realised, creditors paid
ExampleA, B and C are partners; A retires and B and C carry onA, B and C all decide to close the business
RelationDoes not necessarily dissolve the firmAlways dissolves the partnership too

Dissolution of a firm

  • Without order of the court
    • By agreement of all partners
    • Compulsory: insolvency of all but one partner, or business becoming unlawful
    • By notice in a partnership at will
    • On contingencies: expiry of term, completion of venture, death, retirement or insolvency of a partner (unless the others continue)
  • By order of the court (on a partner's suit)
    • Insanity of a partner
    • Permanent incapacity
    • Misconduct
    • Breach of agreement making business impracticable
    • Transfer of interest to a third person
    • Continued losses
    • Any other just and equitable ground

Dissolution of the firm ends the business and the partnership; dissolution of partnership changes the agreement but the business may go on.

Key takeaways: registration is optional in law but practically necessary; it needs a signed statement of particulars filed with the Registrar of Firms with the fee; an unregistered firm cannot sue third parties on contracts, nor can its partners sue one another under the deed, though third parties' rights are unaffected; dissolution of partnership changes the agreement while dissolution of the firm ends the business; firms are dissolved by agreement, compulsorily, by notice, on contingencies, or by the court on grounds such as insanity, misconduct or continued losses.

Read the full lesson

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery